9 ms·
PIN number analysis
- wereHamster 14y agoPlease. Stop it already. The 'N' in PIN stands for Number. If you say 'PIN Number' you're really saying 'Personal Identification Number Number'. Same with ATM Machine, HIV Virus etc.
- chayesfss 14y agoAll of which everybody does so stop caring about it. My favorites this last year include CAC card & SMS message.
- PawelDecowski 14y agoSMS message is correct. SMS stands for short message service.
- martinced 14y agoI think I think you are you are right sir right.
- PawelDecowski 14y agoRAS syndrome: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RAS_syndrome http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RAS_syndrome
- alan_cx 14y agoI like to call it my "Personal PIN Number, for identification purposes" Now go explode!!! ;)
- edofic 14y agooh boy...religious wars are a coming
- jonsen 14y agoYou have to include the N or they will all be like 314159...
- dear 14y agoOr HN News
- martin-adams 14y agoIf the title didn't say PIN number, I might have thought it was about sharp pointy things. Language is about communication, not words.
- shocks 14y agoRAS Syndrome. LCD display is another good one.
- furyg3 14y agoMy bank issues a PIN which is not of my choosing, and since it's a smart card to change it means actually going down to the bank to select a new PIN. I think the majority of people never do this, so it seems like a great way to counter people selecting "1234" or their birthday. At some point I'd really like to see six to eight digit PINs, though...
- nwh 14y agoThey allow them (8+ digit PIN) in Australia, so I assume they are available elsewhere too. Parts of Europe are the exception according to my bank.
- alanctgardner2 14y agoYou can do up to 6 in Canada. Nobody ever told me, but when I was signing up at RBC I accidentally typed 5 and it worked. Now I know why they don't deterministically say 'OK, he's done' after you hit four digits.
- 3pt14159 14y agoWatch out! I also live in Canada, and a close friend of mine while travelling was frozen out of his accounts because there were no banks that could handle 6 digit pins there. For that reason I recommend having a 4 digit pin.
- dbaupp 14y agoWhere's "there"? (Presumably not Canada?)
- derpmaster 14y agoI couldn't use a 6 digit pin in Italy. Some ATMs in London,UK didn't like it either. Singapore it's mandatory for a 6 digit pin so have no idea if a 4 digit pin will work, anybody been there?
- davedx 14y agoSame here in the Netherlands. I don't think I can change mine at all. This has however resulted in me forgetting it several times, once I almost got stranded at a station and was lucky to have enough cash to buy a ticket. I won't tell you what I've done to mitigate against being stranded at random places due to forgetting my PIN but it's not secure. Therefore, I have my reservations about forcing people to remember random numbers.
- orjan 14y agoPrevious submission with discussion: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4535417 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4535417
- monkeyfacebag 14y agoThis is an interesting look at the data but some of the inference isn't quite there. The author uses the relative prevalence of the pattern 2468 over 1357 to justify the conclusion that people prefer even numbers to odd, completely ignoring the pattern-based analysis he just used to understand the prevalence of 2580!
- brittohalloran 14y agoHe quickly glossed over the fact that these are computer passwords which happen to be 4 numeric digits. "Given that users have a free choice for their password, if users select a four digit password to their online account, it’s not a stretch to use this as a proxy for four digit PIN codes." Though there probably wouldn't be drastically different phenomenon, I think the actual PIN distribution would be noticeably different. Particularly 1234. It may still be the top PIN, but I don't think it would have the same dominance. People choose trymynewwebservice.ly passwords a lot more callously than their bank password. I have to believe on average people put a little more effort into disguising it.
- rm999 14y agoI wonder about the 2580s (vertical numbers on a PIN pad). It makes perfect sense for PINs, but not a computer keyboard. It could be people keeping their passwords consistent with their PINs e.g. using their ATM PIN for their online bank account password. A lot sites (correctly) prevent people from using very short or simple passwords, including four digit numbers. I'm curious what sites his database comes from.
- maxerickson 14y agoThis paper(PDF) uses the RockYou password database to do a similar analysis: http://www.cl.cam.ac.uk/~jcb82/doc/BPA12-FC-banking_pin_security.pdf http://www.cl.cam.ac.uk/~jcb82/doc/BPA12-FC-banking_pin_secu... (RockYou discussed here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RockYou#Controversy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RockYou#Controversy ) The patterns displayed by the codes in the paper are similar to the blog.
- rm999 14y agoWow, it's worse than I thought. Rockyou doesn't allow 4 character passwords so they were extracting the numbers from WITHIN longer passwords. 'asdf1975' would equate to a 'pin' of 1975, or 37489 would equate to two pins, 3748 and 7489. What a terrible assumption to build all your research on top of.
- borplk 14y agoInteresting analysis but I don't understand the obsession with randomness of the PIN and such. Unlike 80s there are many counter measures to defend against brute force attacks. No one is going to sit down and guess/brute-force your PIN. Probably not even your other passwords. It's either going to be fully exposed or not at all, so how random or complicated it is doesn't protect you as much as most people make it sound like
- demallien 14y agoWell, yes and no. I actually mostly agree with your point, but just to play devil's advocate: When we talk about secure passwords (Not PINs for the moment, I'll get back to those in a moment), we're mostly worrying about how easy it is to recover someone's password from a database once a system has been compromised. However these days, we don't store the password, we store a hash of the password. To recover the password, the hacker has to successfully 'un-hash' the hashed password, which is done by applying a brute force cryptographic algorithm. The computer detects hits by examining the frequency of letters in the output, knowing that letters don't have an even distribution in passwords (or any other text). Choosing a random password is actually useful in this case, because even if the computer correctly finds the right key for de-hashing, it doesn't recognize your password as 'de-hashed' and just passes right over it. So, for passwords, it is fairly clear that a random password is going to be safer than a word / name or other commonly used password constructs, in its ability to resist extraction from a compromised database. Can we make the same claim for PIN codes? It would be harder - you only have 4 digits to work with, which makes it much harder to determine if digits are distributed in a pattern or randomly. You would expect a lot of false positives and false negatives. Nevertheless, distributions in real life numbers do exist - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benford%27s_law http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benford%27s_law is an obvious example, which leads us to the non-obvious conclusion that making PIN codes longer probably leads to a lower level of security. On the other hand, the scenario in which this is a problem is when a database is compromised, and bank databases are amongst the most hardened targets on the planet, so the increase in risk is probably negligeable.
- beering 14y ago
- neil_s 14y agoIs there a link anywhere to the full set of totals, so I can lookup my PIN and see how common it is? Surely that would be the most useful takeaway from this article?
- Sami_Lehtinen 14y agoBecause we all know this, it's just stupid to let people to select PINs. It's much better to pre-assign completely random PIN. As most banks in Finland do. Based on properly working random number generator, I would say that 1234 is exactly as common PIN as any other PIN number.
- newishuser 14y agoA database of of 4 digit passwords is not suitable as a replacement for PINs. Especially not for anything called a fucking analysis. Banks don't let you choose 4 consecutive numbers or 4 of the same number making his first conclusion completely invalid. A lot of banks assign pin numbers now making the rest of his conclusions invalid. I get wanting to analyze PINs, it's interesting, but pretending any old data that looks similar will work is misleading, disingenuous, and half ass.
- shocks 14y agoThis. How anyone can 'analyse' PIN numbers with unrelated data is beyond me.
- veb 14y ago> Banks don't let you choose 4 consecutive numbers or 4 of the same number making his first conclusion completely invalid I'm not sure where YOU live, but there's a WHOLE would out there. In New Zealand, you can choose anything you like on the number terminal they give you. They try to educate you on a good PIN, but it's ultimately up to you.
- shurcooL 14y agoI thought 1337 would be popular enough to be mentioned.
- SolarUpNote 14y agoLaughing at the XKCD cartoon -- I remember having the same idea (and realization) for having a license plate that's all O's and zeros.
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoOn a slightly different note rated to the XkCD comic, Irish police in 2005 started a manhunt for a serial and prolific traffic offender - they knew he was Polish, his name was "Prawo Jazdy" and he had committed over two hundred speeding offences across the country. Eventually they got a Polish officer through Interpol to help. On his first day on the case he asked - why are you looking for a guy called "Drivers License"? Cops had simply stopped ordinary traffic violations, and wrote down the name from the international license that was where you usually saw the name on national licenses.
- barrkel 14y agoNo, it was Prawo Jazdy.
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoThank you - was incapcable of handling lookups on iPhone whilst deciding if this was too cheesey for HN
- nathell 14y agoIt's actually "Prawo Jazdy" in Polish. http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/europe/ireland/4732923/Prawo-Jazdy-Identity-of-Irelands-most-notorious-driver-uncovered.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/europe/ireland/473...
- okamiueru 14y agoI'm guessing you saw this on QI? If so, I'd double check it with some other source.
- shabble 14y agoPossibly due to disobeying the instructions signposted here: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/wales/7702913.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/wales/7702913.stm The apparent number of people who request tattoos in foreign scripts without bothering to check their translation is also surprising.
- hayksaakian 14y agoDo you use your PIN number at an ATM machine?
- nnnnni 14y agoctrl-f atm machine upvoted.
- hayksaakian 14y agoAfter reading the comment on your LCD display and interacting with a GUI interface? As if this was an IRC chat.
- bsims 14y agoThis was a great write-up, thanks for sharing. Similarly here is an article about the most common passwords for 2012. http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-205_162-57539366/the-25-most-common-passwords-of-2012/ http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-205_162-57539366/the-25-most-com...
- eduardordm 14y agoPasswords and PINs are not the same thing (at least in most places). In my company (credit card company) and in most competitors the PIN is a random number generated when the smart cards are being written. Sequential, repetitive, years, et al are all discharged. PINs can be used as a password for transactions. Because my company focus on low-incoming families, this is actually great, they don't need a phone or website to create/change passwords. The problem here is delivering the password securely. There are banks that do not use PINs at all, the password is stored in their database. This is usually better because if you loose a password you can reset it. This isn't possible using PINs. They are hardwired in the smart card and cannot be changed. PINs cannot be changed or chosen, if you can change, it's not a PIN, it's an awfully insecure 4 digit password.
- Evbn 14y agoWhy awfully insecure?
- tripzilch 14y agoSo I wondered, and tried to google the number, one of his graphs shows a peak for '1472'. Anyone got an idea what's special about this number? And from the longer digit-sequences 292513 (#12) and 38317 (#15) and 42059 (#20). I didn't google those last two, maybe they're common US ZIP codes?