4 ms·
The tone of the whole article is a little odd... I'm not sure what exactly her underlying view is. > Over the last few years, my colleagues, including Stephen
by gwern 14y ago
The tone of the whole article is a little odd... I'm not sure what exactly her underlying view is.
> Over the last few years, my colleagues, including Stephen Marder, Alison Hamilton and Amy Cohen, and I have gathered 20 research subjects with high-functioning schizophrenia in Los Angeles. They suffered from symptoms like mild delusions or hallucinatory behavior. Their average age was 40. Half were male, half female, and more than half were minorities. All had high school diplomas, and a majority either had or were working toward college or graduate degrees. They were graduate students, managers, technicians and professionals, including a doctor, lawyer, psychologist and chief executive of a nonprofit group. ...At the same time, most were unmarried and childless, which is consistent with their diagnoses...how had they managed to succeed in their studies and at such high-level jobs?
20 subjects is a lot? Less than half getting a college degree is success? With mild symptoms (as opposed to catatonia)?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schizophrenia#Epidemiology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schizophrenia#Epidemiology gives a lifetime risk of 0.7%. LA has ~4m people, giving 28k who have, had, or will have schizophrenia. It'd be impressive if all 28k could not cope at all and none could hold down any kind of job (and wouldn't we expect just from timing of schizophrenia onset to see plenty with degrees and jobs?).
- SoftwareMaven 14y agoHaving a loved one with schizophrenia, the tone is not odd at all (it is an opinion piece, not a journal). There are many people who believe schizophrenia is a sentence that means you'll be living under a bridge. I see that attitude regularly. In some cases, it is not possible to function, due to the disease; but there are a lot of people who can function, but they are told they cannot. Of course the 20 people are not a research cohort, but they are anecdotal evidence that people with schizophrenia can succeed regardless of their disease. And if you have schizophrenia, that can give you hope. And hope can bring change.