3 ms·
"Car companies are [...] not even software companies" - Fuel injection: software - ABS: software - Airbags: software - Traction control: software - Brake a
by Someone 14y ago
"Car companies are [...] not even software companies"
- Fuel injection: software
- ABS: software
- Airbags: software
- Traction control: software
- Brake assist: software
- That clicker that opens your car door: software
Etc.
- deelowe 14y agoI don't think the op was arguing that car companies don't produce software. He was arguing that they don't produce it well, because it's not a core competency for the company. Car company profits are tied to industrial design, manufacturing, and logistics, not software. His point about GPS is an apt one. My brother has the best SUV Infinity makes and the GPS is so terrible, he uses his phone (android) instead.
- herval 14y agocurrent car companies don't produce user interfaces well. All the other software that runs in a car (or an airplane, or a mars rover) is great
- roisin09 14y agoSuppliers to the car makers, like those that produce anti-lock brakes, do good software. Car makers typically have Silicon Valley offices. And they typically buy components from companies rather than rely on themselves. None of that means Google will make and driverless car that sells in the way the original article claimed.
- nitrogen 14y agoCar companies write software that is incidental to their primary purpose. Software companies write software as a primary purpose. This is the definition of a software company. A more interesting argument is whether a software company is more likely to produce a successful self-driving car, which I believe the parent comment demonstrated to be likely by pointing out that it's an AI problem, and Google does a lot more with AI than car companies.
- krschultz 14y agoThose are very different kinds of software. Everything other than the last one is a real time OS problem with very known inputs and outputs. Validation is critical but manageable. And even then, most of them are outsourced to Bosch and other suppliers.