3 ms·
x264 isn't remotely free to you. If you use that encoded video in any business capacity at all that doesn't meet the "free internet content for end users" defi
by ajross 14y ago
x264 isn't remotely free to you. If you use that encoded video in any business capacity at all that doesn't meet the "free internet content for end users" definition, you're going to hear from them MPEG-LA lawyers about licensing. And note that isn't a license they're offering, just a promise. They can change their mind at any time.
And a quibble about words: h.264 isn't "closed". The standard is well-understood and easily available, and there are free high-quality implementations of both sides of the codec. What you mean to say is that it is "proprietary" and that its use is subject to IP laws and licensing restrictions.
- Silhouette 14y agox264 isn't remotely free to you. If you use that encoded video in any business capacity at all that doesn't meet the "free internet content for end users" definition, you're going to hear from them MPEG-LA lawyers about licensing. Are you sure you're not scaremongering just a bit here? For one thing, the royalties typically don't kick in until projects have reached a significant size. Using H.264 is explicitly free up to that point for those users, even if you accept the validity of the patents etc. Moreover, it seems unlikely that lawyers would trouble a lot of small companies anyway, at least in places like Europe. Firstly, they'd have to notice them. Secondly, they'd have to know that the use wasn't properly authorised (since bringing a groundless lawsuit in a loser-pays system can be expensive -- you don't see the equivalent of the xxAA shakedowns over here for similar reasons). Thirdly, are heavyweight industry lawyers really going to risk a legal action that could set a precedent that these patents are unenforceable, destroying their entire business model across an entire continent, just to extract a modest amount of licensing fees from a small business? If they wanted to pick that fight, I suspect the unlucky business having to defend itself would suddenly find itself with a lot of well-financed friends.