There is certainly the other side of the coin, as you point out. Which is better depends heavily on perspective, so yeah, I'll accept that one is probably not

There is certainly the other side of the coin, as you point out. Which is better depends heavily on perspective, so yeah, I'll accept that one is probably not definitively better than the other. I do think that they are certainly different though. It should not be the same piece of paper because both routes, regardless of relative merits, are very different animals.