5 ms·
Comprehensive my ass. Comprehensive reform is a point based system with no caps. It is also what is required to end the current recession.
by tomjen3 14y ago
Comprehensive my ass. Comprehensive reform is a point based system with no caps.
It is also what is required to end the current recession.
- eli_gottlieb 14y agoIn what way is the recession caused or exacerbated by a lack of workers?
- gizmo 14y agoIt's not, but high-skill immigration would certainly give the economy a boost. This boost to the economy would be good for everybody: lowering unemployment and increasing aggregate demand. And technically the US isn't even in a recession right now -- although the economy is still depressed.
- yummyfajitas 14y ago...lowering unemployment and increasing aggregate demand. It's certainly true that importing new employed people will increase the denominator in the unemployment rate will reduce unemployment, but that doesn't help any human. I believe you are making the fallacy of reasoning from a composition change. Amusingly, one of the better explanations of this I've found is at OpenBorders: http://openborders.info/compositional-effects/ http://openborders.info/compositional-effects/
- gizmo 14y agoNo, those high skilled (and therefore high earning) immigrants use their salary to buy stuff so aggregate demand increases so unemployment decreases. I'm not playing compositional games here.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoThey also produce a bunch of stuff, thereby increasing aggregate supply commensurately. Since they are high skilled, they likely increase AS more than AD, since high skilled individuals tend to produce more than they consume.
- gizmo 14y agoYes, high skilled people produce more than they consume but that's of course a good thing. Look at it from the other way around. What would happen to the economy if 50% of high skilled people moved to a different country? It would be disastrous for the country. So AS and AD go down as a direct consequence of those people leaving, but AD will also go down as a consequence of the resulting recession/depression. Importing high skilled people has the opposite effect. So yes, high skilled workers add to AS and to AD, and the ratio of AS to AD won't change much because of that. But the economy will still get a boost (another increase in AD).
- yummyfajitas 14y agoI'm not a Keynesian, so I don't make arguments about AS/AD except in the context of "here is what the Keynesians believe". Looking at it the other way, if 50% of high skilled people moved to a different country, it would be a disaster. I just don't think it would be a Keynesian disaster. If anything, AD should hold constant while AS dropped, leading to an increase in employment. Note that I'm disputing your reasoning, not your conclusion.
- tomjen3 14y agoThe economy is hampered by too many useless, marginal workers; a point system would attract well educated, in demand workers. The kind of workers that companies need to grow, in turn hireing more people.
- thisone 14y agoHaving just gone through the paperwork for a non PB visa in the UK, after 3 previous PB visas. I'll take the PB system every time. With a PB system, you, the applicant, know where you stand when you make the application. With the non PB visa, it was so confusing as to what was actually needed, I hired an agency to help me. I'm now at the beginning of the up-to 16 week wait for a response. PB system: they tell you exactly what you need to show Non PB system: they suggest a range of what you should show. While the truth of the matter is you must show everything in the range along with a pile of other things that they don't even allude to.