3 ms·
If you sufficiently internalize that there is another human being at the other end of the line, basic humanity should lead toward communication with that in min
by nitrogen 14y ago
If you sufficiently internalize that there is another human being at the other end of the line, basic humanity should lead toward communication with that in mind.
"Sufficiently internaliz[ing]" the emotions of another human being may be difficult or impossible for many who are drawn to the computer field due to the way their brains are wired, either due to childhood bullying stunting their empathic development, or to things like autism spectrum disorders.
For people in that situation, suggesting a pragmatic mental model may be more helpful than saying, "You're a jerk, and you're wrong," which might come across as like saying to a deaf person, "You never listen, and you're wrong."
- __cle 14y agoBullshit
- nitrogen 14y agoHuman minds are much more diverse than most people accept or realize. For example, consider these comments from someone who has no visual imagination: http://lesswrong.com/user/lindagert/overview/ http://lesswrong.com/user/lindagert/overview/ Also see: http://wiki.lesswrong.com/wiki/Typical_mind_fallacy http://wiki.lesswrong.com/wiki/Typical_mind_fallacy
- dpark 14y agoCould we stop with the Asperger's fetishism? The vast majority of people in technical fields do not have any autism spectrum disorders. The vast majority of people who are jerks do not have any autism spectrum disorders, either. Most people who act like jerks (in both technical and non-technical fields) are just that: jerks. Autism-type disorders don't just manifest as asshole behavior, and certainly not as just snarky inconsiderate behavior. They affect interpersonal interactions in general. Saying that jerks in tech fields have autism spectrum disorders makes as much sense as saying MBAs have sociopathic disorders. "When I hurt my coworker's feelings, it's because I'm autistic. When my boss hurts mine, it's because he's a psychopath." Yeah right.
- nitrogen 14y agoI didn't limit my comment to Asperger's syndrome, and at no point was I making excuses. My point is that saying "You're a jerk" is not a solution to the problem, whether it's caused by ASD, psychopathy, whatever. If you had read and considered my final paragraph, you would see that I did propose a solution. Edit: oh yeah: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fundamental_attribution_error https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fundamental_attribution_error -- This thread's full of it. Edit 2: My suggestion of a "pragmatic mental model" of others' emotions is influenced by the existence those who are able to learn to read emotion by analyzing facial expressions (e.g. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4630989 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4630989).
- dpark 14y agoYou didn't limit it to Asperger's but you basically limited it to Asperger's-like syndromes. (i.e. "due to the way their brains are wired".) References to bullying and whatever else are superfluous when you're basically chalking it up to equivalent syndromes (regardless of the particular names). And yes, there are some individuals who legitimately have Asperger's or some other disorder that affects their interactions. However, this is a rarity, and it's unhealthy that our industry talks about these things as if they are the normal case. It does the industry a disservice when we accept inappropriate behavior and don't call it out as inappropriate and unacceptable. Most people who act like jerks do not have any kind of diagnosable disorder. In fact, most people who act like jerks are just normal people who are not normally jerks, but occasionally act that way for various reasons. I disagree that your proposal is meaningful. I say this partly because you didn't actually propose anything concrete, but mostly because this is only useful for someone who wants to change the way they interact. This requires that these people admit that their behavior is inappropriate, so we should start there. Then we can move to conversation about how to change if they agree that they should. Imagine if we were having this conversation about racism or sexism. Would you be dismissing the behavior as a result of a syndrome or bullying or whatever? Would you propose that we should be suggesting a "pragmatic mental model"? As for the "fundamental attribution error", you're just as guilty as anyone else. "He's doing that because he's got Asperger's" is no more situational than "He's doing that because he's a jerk". A situational explanation might involve the anonymization of Internet interactions or the dehumanization that comes from discussing a person's code vs the person.