7 ms·
This assumes Google will have the market to itself. Cars aren't like search. It's not a winner-takes-all market.
by jacques_chester 14y ago
This assumes Google will have the market to itself.
Cars aren't like search. It's not a winner-takes-all market.
- zasz 14y agoWhy wouldn't self-driving cars be networked somehow? Like, what if in order to access the Google fleet of cars, you had to have a Google membership?
- anigbrowl 14y agoThat would conflict with public safety considerations and possibly with antitrust/consumer legislation. The system has to work on a standalone basis even if communications go down, but you can be sure it will be super-easy to integrate with or obtain Google account privileges. Having been part of the test group for several Google hardware products, I'm optimistic about the possibilities - although Google will have to up its game regarding customer service, tech support etc.
- anigbrowl 14y agoGoogle's not selling cars. It's selling automotive technology that will soon become standard in cars.
- wololo 14y agoI don't understand. Why license it out? Isn't this like the iPhone?
- jlgreco 14y agoAll those other car companies? They are the ones with the brands and the cars people want. They are the iphones in this situation. Sure, if you're pushing a new powertrain you can do okay making one or two of your own cars (which will take years) and you can shortcut the time to build up a brandname to a degree by being exclusive, but none of that effort is warranted because this technology does not require that sort of vertical integration. If your competency is not making cars but rather automated cars, why would you want to get into the business of making cars?
- logn 14y agoGoogle has loads of money. They can buy a car company. Tesla has a $4B market cap. Or they could invest significantly in a car company. Or they can strike exclusive agreements.
- jlgreco 14y agoGoogle can buy a lot of different companies. But why would they want to?
- dagw 14y agoWhy deal with the hassle of actually owning a car company and factories and all the related problems of actually building things. Also what does Google gain by offering an exclusive agreement to a nice car maker? Wouldn't it be better to offer the tech to everybody, sit back, focus on R&D and take a percentage of every sale made while let them deal with all the problems of actually building and selling cars.
- GIFtheory 14y agoThe solution is much farther off than Google would like you to believe. As in, we'll be lucky if driverless cars become feasible before fusion becomes commercially viable.
- sshumaker 14y agoEvidence?
- onedev 14y agoPlease don't make statements like that without providing your reasoning (whether right or wrong).
- GIFtheory 14y agoI've worked on autonomous cars, and no, I am not a crank. I could go into technical reasons why this is nowhere near ready, but there is no need. The onus is on Google to prove that they have the technology (or that it will arrive soon), and proof has not been forthcoming. I'm not even claiming that Google is claiming that autonomous cars are almost here--I am saying that people should take their carefully controlled demos with a grain of salt.
- taligent 14y agoVolvo is shipping a self-driving car in 2014. It's not far off.
- jacques_chester 14y ago> It's selling automotive technology that will soon become standard in cars. This still means that they aren't going to be making the "triiiillions of dollars!" [Dr Evil pinkie finger here] I mean sure, they can make a lot of money further down the value chain. But so do Motorola whenever someone installs a few dozen PowerPC chips into a new BMW. It's just lazy link-baiting conflation of the Biggest Number Available with what might actually happen, and that annoyed me.
- taligent 14y agoNobody is interested in Google's technology. They all have their own implementation: Audi, BMW, Ford, GM, Honda, Hyundai, Lexus, Mercedes-Benz, Nissan, Porsche, Tesla, Toyota, Volkswagen, Volvo
- daniel-cussen 14y agoThe software might become like Android---a standard. Largely because of interoperability: it's advantageous for cars to talk to one another in order to coordinate on the highway better than just with sensors, so it makes sense for them all to be of the same operating system. Further, people who make apps for these cars will want to deploy to as many as possible. So, "IceDriver 2015" will choose Google's car OS over (shivers) GM's OS.
- wwweston 14y ago> it's advantageous for cars to talk to one another If "never trust the client" is a truism in software, I'd assume it'd be doubly so for P2P communication, and add another doubling for a situation involving humans + relatively high masses and speeds.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]