4 ms·
I've got a modest proposal - the second simplest idea of them all. Instead of beating around the bush with restrictions that should be ruled unconstitutional b
by mindslight 14y ago
I've got a modest proposal - the second simplest idea of them all.
Instead of beating around the bush with restrictions that should be ruled unconstitutional but won't be, simply ban all firearms. The building-a-better-world folks would be happy to finally get their wet dream. The constitutionalists could stop deluding themselves as to its applicability, and thus choose to secede or revolt. And everybody who wants personal freedom would be free of a red herring and could better concentrate on functional ways of neutering the modern governments' ability to do things like ban personal tools in the first place.
- nthj 14y ago> The constitutionalists could stop deluding themselves as to its applicability, and thus choose to secede or revolt Or revolt over seceding? The Civil War would not have taken place had Lincoln allowed the South to go on their merry way.
- rdl 14y agoIf someone passes an unconstitutional law, the reasonable response isn't to secede (which is itself unconstitutional), but to challenge it in the courts (as well as to vote out of office the legislators/executives who pushed those laws). "Cutting off your nose to spite your face" would be the cliche here.
- mindslight 14y agoThe courts actually ruling it unconstitutional would be a decent outcome as well. And maybe they even would with such a blatant contradiction. But if not, hopefully the incongruence would finally be explicit enough to dispel the wishful belief that the government is bound by a piece of paper.