4 ms·
So here's a crazy little idea. Most gun violence is directly linked to gang activity. Gang activity is directly linked to the money involved in the drug trade.
by philwelch 14y ago
So here's a crazy little idea.
Most gun violence is directly linked to gang activity. Gang activity is directly linked to the money involved in the drug trade. So the best technological approach to reducing gun violence would be one that took all the money out of the drug trade, giving the gangsters less to shoot at each other over. There is precedent for this. The fact that crime, including violent crime and violent crime committed with firearms, is so low now compared to the 80's and early 90's is directly linked to the collapse in the price of cocaine.
We've made it almost impossible to stop everyday copyright infringement, why not make it almost impossible to stop physical smuggling or fabrication of narcotics? Commoditize the gangsters straight out of business. Part of what made the bottom fall out of cocaine was crystal meth. So there's one direction: freely distribute the information and materials necessary to manufacture competing drugs. Then there's the distribution: Silk Road is a start, but find a better way of doing it that will pull in more producers, consumers, and distributors. If you work all the angles, you can engineer an end run against the war on drugs the same way we engineered an end run against copyright.
Too far out? ;)
- rdl 14y agoHeh. I do agree that ending the drug war is the single best thing that can be done to reduce violence, poverty, racism, hopelessness-among-minorities, etc. Guns and gun violence are a very minor issue by comparison. I'd rather not have a widespread "everyone a tweaker" program, though. Crystal meth is actually pretty bad. Decriminalizing existing drugs and production of drugs would probably be a lot better than replacing illegal pot/coke/etc. use with illegal meth use.
- philwelch 14y agoSure, I was not being entirely serious. I'll just say that we're probably better off in the current heyday of meth than we were in the heyday of cocaine. Any reasonable approach to the drug problem is not about growing demand for drugs, just better meeting the existent demand with fewer externalities.
- lancewiggs 14y agoSo perhaps one of the HN responses could be "legalise, regulate and tax most of the illegal drugs". That would certainly send an interesting message.
- rdl 14y agoThat's not technical, though. This is specifically for 2 technical meetings they're having on technical measures to deal with gun violence.
- cookingrobot 14y agoExcept skip the tax. There's no need for it, and it would just support the incentive for a black market.
- taejo 14y ago> I'll just say that we're probably better off in the current heyday of meth than we were in the heyday of cocaine. As long as "we" excludes the drug users.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- strlen 14y agoIt's interesting that both pro-gun rights libertarians and most anti-gun violence liberals agree on this point but for (one reason or another) fail to advance this. Irrespective of what you think about gun laws, if you want to significantly reduce violence in US and Mexico, working on making drug trade less profitable would be a higher leverage activity than changing gun policy.
- codex 14y agoI think that ending the drug trade would actually increase violence against the average citizen. Drugs provide a lucrative means of employment for a large number of people with few skills. Take that away, and the world looks much bleaker. These newly unemployed, who used to make hundreds of times what they would working at McDonalds, can now no longer afford their own shoes. They might then turn from dealing drugs and occasionally shooting each other, to armed robbery and occasionally shooting a law abiding citizen.
- rdl 14y agoThe drug trade is uniquely violent. It has no recourse to legal contracts, high values of cash or cash equivalents, and people who are by virtue of being on drugs, predisposed to violence and irrationality. The average citizen is honestly not that much affected by gun crime, drug crime, etc. now. It's mainly confined to urban ghettos and some border regions, and the perpetrators are generally black and latino young males, and the victims are black and latinos of a variety of ages (primarily young males, too, but not as exclusively). It's pretty hard to separate racism and a history of racism and discrimination, the drug war, and culture of violence (including gun violence).
- raverbashing 14y agoWell, you know, about the substance you cited, it's difficult to synthesize it That's why they still get it from the leaves of the plant, and have to transport it There may be 'alternatives' but I suppose some people will just go for it, not to mention the 'new' different cheap format (rocks that can be smoked)