5 ms·
My wife is a doctor. For her, seeing people die horrible deaths is not an abstract possibility. It is something that she's seen far more of than she wants, an
by btilly 14y ago
My wife is a doctor. For her, seeing people die horrible deaths is not an abstract possibility. It is something that she's seen far more of than she wants, and is likely to see in the future again more than she wants.
Despite having no particular religious views, she would disagree with your "axiom" in the strongest of possible terms. So would I. I am not religious, but my preferences include not suffering horrible pain. I also am against causing severe emotional and/or financial distress for people I care about. Those preferences lead to there being situations where I am literally better off dead than alive, and I have made sure that my wife is aware of what those situations are so that she can make that decision for me if I am incapacitated and it needs to be made.
- nmcfarl 14y agoMy wife is a doc as well. Her opinions and experiences map to you wife’s, mine to yours. This is not about life being better than death. This is about the amount of pain and suffering you cause yourself and others while fighting off death.