4 ms·
Ah, well that's where we disagree. I can't control what genes I'm born with, and I don't think there's anything wrong with socializing those risks across the po
by _delirium 14y ago
Ah, well that's where we disagree. I can't control what genes I'm born with, and I don't think there's anything wrong with socializing those risks across the population. Let's say there's a 1% risk of me being born with some condition. I think it's perfectly fair for me to pay 1% of the cost of treating that condition, whether I'm born with it or not. I don't see why I should pay 100% the cost if I get unlucky in the genetic lottery, or 0% if I get lucky. That's just upping the ante on a bet I wasn't even around to make. And that's the kind of pooling insurance usually does, but the mechanics of this particular risk are very hard for insurance to pool, because it happens to take place before I'm sentient enough to purchase insurance, unlike a tree falling on my house.
If anything, it strikes me as exceptionally petty and greedy for people who have the misfortune not to need to undergo surgery for a congenital heart disease to be angry about having to pay for their 1/risk chance of it.
I mean, I'm not even arguing anything particularly leftist here: F.A. Hayek made basically this argument.
- javert 14y agoI can't control what genes I'm born with, and I don't think there's anything wrong with socializing those risks across the population. What's wrong with it is that you're initiating force against me, and making my life manifestly worse. I mean, as someone who can pay for my own healthcare, this is what I get out of socialized medicine in the US: (1) Less money to spend on my own healthcare issues (2) Regulations that prevent my doctors from taking care of me in the best possible way (3) Regulations that prevent me from getting the best medicine (4) Anything medical is done in an extremely expensive and wasteful way That's what you're doing to me, in order to instill your notion of what is "perfectly fair." The U.S. medical system does not work effectively for the same reasons that the Soviet economy did not. It's likely only going to keep getting worse with Obamacare.
- gtaylor 14y agoYou know, these posts sound a lot like "I've got mine, screw you." Am I rare in that I wouldn't mind paying a little more if it'd mean that the country would be legitimately happier/healthier? Whether that be socialized healthcare, single-payer, or any combination.
- redler 14y agoYou cover a lot of ground here -- socialized medicine, Obama, government regulation, "initiation of force", the fall of the Soviet Union. But just to select one: "...as someone who can pay for my own healthcare..." What should be done about the people who cannot? Your profile reveals that you're an Ayn Rand fan; I don't believe Rand provided an answer to this question, other than to posit that harnessing the collective resources of society to address it, in any way, destroys essential freedom. Do you propose that "The Virtue of Selfishness" would be an effective and moral organizing principle for modern society?
- SoftwareMaven 14y agoas someone who can pay for my own healthcare Then just do it. It is unfortunate that Obamacare is forcing you to get insurance, but I'm sure you can find a medical plan with a ridiculously high deductible (specifically for people who are wealthy[1]) that will cost you next to nothing[2] and, similar to life insurance, protect you and your assets if something catastrophic happens. 1. I'm making no judgement about whether you are wealthy or just choose to pursue no healthcare. 2. Assuming they are still available next year. http://www.dailyfinance.com/2012/07/13/obamacare-could-kill-one-type-of-cheap-health-insurance/ http://www.dailyfinance.com/2012/07/13/obamacare-could-kill-...