4 ms·
I think tech's overall optimization/automation effect is good/great for humans, but only if society adapts. In Star Trek's utopia, it's said that the limitless
by danso 14y ago
I think tech's overall optimization/automation effect is good/great for humans, but only if society adapts. In Star Trek's utopia, it's said that the limitless bounty created by tech has basically removed the need for currency and competing economies...but will that happen in reality? If it becomes technologically possible to cheaply produce robots that replaces nearly everyones' jobs...will society be able to say, "Awesome, let's all relax now!"? I can't imagine that we'll ever accept that, even if natural resources become nearly limitless.
- angdis 14y agoThe ugly reality is that the effect of automation seems to be further stratifying the haves from the have-nots. By definition, automation makes things cheaper and more profitable by taking away jobs. If there aren't OTHER JOBS also created, we have a situation where the owners are systematically getting richer and the workers are systematically getting poorer.
- joonix 14y agoIsn't that the end result of capitalism? To optimize returns on capital. It says nothing about labor or workers.
- eli_gottlieb 14y agoWell yes, but there were previously variously reasons to either sincerely believe, or argue-against for ideological reasons, the notion that capitalism must impoverish everyone who isn't a capitalist. As it is, I think the Coming Model is going to have to be some extended form of Danish-style "Flexicurity": a market economy with the means of production under mixed control (nationalization of common assets but no seizing private wealth), near-complete market flexibility, but a system of social insurances and social dividends that share out some portion of the total wealth and prevent actual poverty and destitution for everyone. Then we'll see what people will actually create under such a model. It could well end up like the late '40s and the '50s-'60s: with a crisis resolved, demand is liberated, what had been financial wealth is converted into a real standard-of-living rise, and whole loads of new products and professions open up that can only exist because the working class is now secure and prosperous enough to support them.
- afterburner 14y agoI thought capitalism was centered around labour providing value and being rewarded accordingly? I'm not sure myself. Although the other inputs to production are land and capital goods, the latter of which could I suppose be interpreted as "the robots that will take care of everything".
- forrestthewoods 14y agoAnd yet the "have nots" of today have far more than the haves from yesteryear. An increase in the difference of relative wealth is not fundamentally bad if the absolute wealth increases for everybody. Of course no one thinks like this.
- bjustin 14y agoSome of them do. Some people (still) can't afford as much nutritious food as they should be eating. Any cuts to food stamps, reduced and free school lunches, etc., will make the situation worse. Some "conservatives" are seriously talking about cutting these programs.
- sliverstorm 14y agoThe way I figure it, jobs would indeed become irrelevant if energy was free or so-cheap-as-to-be-free, and raw materials were also free or so-cheap-as-to-be-free. Labor and natural resources are fundamentally the origin of all value in an economy (IMO). This doesn't mean we'd instantly all be equal- I would think we could look to communities of the ridiculously-wealthy today, in which case it looks like it would then be about having access to rare or unique things. In other words, no longer about money, but rather connections.