11 ms·
How Doctors Die (2011)
- ben1040 14y agoHN Commentary from 2011: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3313570 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3313570
- pitiburi 14y agoThe OP posted on that thread, so he knew this was a repost. Interesting article, but i fear for HN if reposting an old and interesting link you remember becomes a way of getting easy karma.
- ChuckMcM 14y agoI suppose if the goal was karma farming then to be complete you would first repost a highly ranked story and then you would repost the highest ranked comment on your repost. And presumably if the same people read it again and voted again then you would capture the most possible re-karma points :-)
- nkurz 14y agoOddly, I didn't know this was a repost. I came across the article again, I knew I'd read it before, but hadn't recalled that it had been on HN. It was posted long enough ago that the duplicate-catcher didn't alert me. While the karma was a pleasant addition to an otherwise rough day, my intent was simply to pass on a thoughtful article to people I hoped would enjoy it. Perhaps an exponential decay on reposts would prevent abuse?
- rosser 14y agoThis has been posted before, as indicated by ben1040's comment, but it's worth reading again.
- maeon3 14y agowe won't be able to repair these various cancers until we can do whole cell emulation on the offending cell and contrast/compare it to a healthy equivalent. We need to understand the mechanics of cells down to the molecular level. Then maybe we can think of a fix. At this stage in society, we know just enough about cancers to do more harm than good in the remaining years of life for the worst forms of cancer.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- reasonattlm 14y agoThere are plausible ways to fix cancer, outlined in some detail, but they are so different from the present status quo of cancer research that the community does not pursue them. If it doesn't look a lot like a drug, good luck in obtaining funding for your research. For example, WILT / OncoSENS. Which is to say turn off all mechanisms for telomere lengthening and work around the issues that will cause by replacing stem cell populations: http://www.fightaging.org/archives/2011/10/accumulating-the-groundwork-for-the-ultimate-cure-for-cancer.php http://www.fightaging.org/archives/2011/10/accumulating-the-... http://sens.org/research/introduction-to-sens-research/onco http://sens.org/research/introduction-to-sens-research/onco --- Further, even a robust cure for a specific cancer based on targeted cell killing (by surface chemistry or other markers) doesn't require a complete understanding of the cancer cell - you just need to identify a reliable marker, no need to understand why it's a reliable marker.
- crygin 14y agoWe won't* fully correctly emulate a single human cell using deterministic computers in any reasonable timeframe. Even if we had a fully characterized model of a healthy cell, what mechanism would we then use to prevent/eliminate cancers? You still have to get something in there in order to kill the cancerous tissue, whether it's drug-based, mechanical, or radioactive. Claiming that attempting prevention/treatment is futile until a probably-not-in-our-lifetime goal is achieved is defeatist at the highest level. *: Before responding, read the still-highly-relevant: http://www.andersonlocalization.com/pdf/more_is_different.pdf http://www.andersonlocalization.com/pdf/more_is_different.pd...
- afterburner 14y ago"someone breaking their ribs in an attempt to resuscitate them with CPR (that’s what happens if CPR is done right)" Is that always necessarily true...?
- elemeno 14y agoNot always, but very often. Guidelines in the US and Europe recommend compressions which are four or five cm deep, and that's a pretty significant percentage of the distance from your sternum to your back. Remember of course that one of the things that your rib cage is supposed to protect against is blows to your heart and lungs, so it shouldn't be too much of a surprise that a procedure that is supposed to compress your heart is also going to cause damage to your ribcage.
- meaty 14y agoYes this happened to my father. I remember the crunching sound of his ribs to this day. This was at waterloo station in London in 1993. He just keeled over. Fortunately for him, someone had just got stabbed 100 yards away so people were already on hand. The paramedic didn't even blink. Everyone else shit a brick. He survived though and after a bypass op is fine to this day.
- elemeno 14y agoIt probably helped as well that St Thomas's is literally within a few hundred yards of Waterloo Station. The speed with which you can be in specialist care is absolutely critical when it comes to cardiac problems - which is a large part of the reason why survival rates are far higher in places like Central London where you've got both fast response time for paramedics (for London as a whole, ~75% of 'immediately life-threatening' calls have a response time of under eight minutes) and multiple world class Hospitals with specialist cardiac centres. Even so, that's one hell of a lucky break your father had and fantastic that he both survived and is fine still!
- meaty 14y ago
- javert 14y agoAs a 26 year old American, my experiences with the US hospital system have been so abysmal that I would consider not even seeking treatment for many serious conditions unless I knew the solution would be straightforward. Abysmal in terms of having good medical outcomes, and being treated respectfully by hospital staff (who tend to be extremely overworked). Plus, it's degrading to have no control over how much you will be charged, and whether insurance will cover it. I personally have had one relatively minor medical issue, so the above comes more from experiences with family members in the hospital.
- danielweber 14y agoAs Americans, we seem unable to realize that in many cases the best thing to do is nothing, or just keep an eye on it. We love the thought of "fighting cancer." You can't just fix this problem at one level; it's pretty endemic. To start with, I'd love to be able to opt-out of unlikely-to-improve-my-outcome procedures, but even with those wishes doctors are likely to still act because of other pressures.
- robbiep 14y agoYou can make your wishes explicitly known, it's called 'advanced directives' however most people either don't know about this or don't want to have to think about it because it involves facing their own mortality. IF you really don't want CPR, or heroic measures to be taken on you, then get a DO NOT RECUSSITATE' or DNR tattoo on your chest or side, where the defib pads go (just in case) and carry around a copy of your advanced directives in your wallet. For everything else, you will be conscious and thus have the ability to tell someone 'no'
- nialo 14y agoThe previous HN thread claimed that it's better to have a bracelet or necklace or similar than a tattoo, and in particular that tattoos may not actually be followed as consistently as bracelets etc. I'm not interested in the debate as to why this is, just trying to inform people.
- richardlblair 14y agoI've saw this article back in 2011. Sometime after that I had conversations with my Grandmother and Mother about their wishes. I now know their expectations, and they know mine. It's important to think about death, and these situations. It's even more important to express your feelings to those who have the power to impact how you will be treated.
- fernly 14y agoThis is very good, but you need more than verbal undertakings. You need paper, in particular you need a Medical Power of Attorney, a notarized document authorizing you to make medical decisions on behalf of your Mother and Grandmother (and your Mother, for the Grandmother) (oh, and mutually reciprocal ones for you and your spouse if any). Without that paper, hospital personnel may ignore you when you say what she wanted, in fact may feel they are legally required to ignore you. And the paper needs to be accessible on short notice (not in a bank safety-deposit box). It's a good idea to have a copy filed at her primary care doctor's office.
- patrickgzill 14y agoI don't see any statistics, just a very well-written article with some anecdotes.
- martinced 14y agoNot everything needs statistics to ring a bell. I've seen two grandfathers of mine on which absurd medical care was given: one was seriously ill and maintained as a living mummy for months (he did look as bad as people who were rescued from extermination camp at the end of WWII) and another who, while in coma, had a leg cut off although everyone knew he wouldn't wake up. Who the heck wants to wake up with only one leg when one know you'll die in the next few hours / days of terrible cancers that spread throughout the whole body? It's precisely what this article is talking about because it's really what's going on. People dying in an environment they're not familiar with, experienced things they never experienced during their whole life: broken ribs due to overzealous CPR, one leg cut off, tubes everywhere. I've had a girlfriend who was a doctor and the sheer number of crazy situation like this she was describing were insane. Believe me: this is very real and you probably don't want the statistics. Because the probability that you will notice, the day your day has come, that you're missing one leg while feeling your ribs being broken is very far from zero.
- patrickgzill 14y agoNo, I DO in fact, want the statistics, if a writer is going to make the claim that: "And they don’t die like the rest of us. What’s unusual about them is not how much treatment they get compared to most Americans, but how little." It should be easy to prove/disprove this, as doctors get surveyed all the time on different subjects.
- pan69 14y agoIf, as a US citizen, you're going to have (or need) serious treatment done for which you will have to pay a considerable amount of money it might be an option to go overseas. I can highly recommend going to Thailand. They have great medical centers in Bangkok with very professional and highly skilled doctors and specialists AND you're treated like a patient who needs care.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- bstewartny 14y agoI dont know. Its one thing when you are 65 and all your kids are grown up. Its a whole other thing when you are 50 and have young children at home. I have a friend with 4 young kids. He has stage 4 cancer requiring constant chemo and pain, but he is going to fight it with everything they have in order to be there as long as possible with his kids - and maybe beat it.
- akiselev 14y agoEven that issue isn't that simple. There is no right answer to the debate between being there as long as you can for them and not wanting to have them experience their parents withering away and dying, entirely helpless. I have been fortunate not to be in this position but I can't imagine the latter being very healthy for the children. It's up to every parent and family to decide this in their own way. I've known two people in the medical field in this position, late stage cancer with young children at home. Both chose to fight with drug cocktails and experimental treatments (such as sipuleucel-T when it was in trials) but stopped short of life debilitating treatments like chemo, although one was lucky enough to get laser based irradiation therapy (I forgot the technical term, but it uses an accelerator to irradiate a tumor without harming surrounding tissue as much as chemo: http://www.protons.com/protons/index.page http://www.protons.com/protons/index.page). I never asked but I'm guessing that they've seen all too often what the family goes through with a loved one dying from terminal cancer and don't think it's worth the pain or suffering, for the family or for them.
- jonpeda 14y agoSome people choose to stop fighting, gain a few weeks or months of reduced pain and better (temporary) health, and settle affairs as best they can. Remember, if chemo doesn't work, then it is a longer, more painful demise. It's a hard tradeoff. Maximize the quality time you have, and prepare for your family's future -- especially before the diagnosis comes.
- csense 14y agoThe following is my point of view. I understand some people have a different point of view, and I don't have a problem if they make it known, and their families and health care providers respect their wishes. But from where I sit, the dying doctors' point of view, as presented in this article, struck me as irrational. Axiom: Being dead is better than being alive. Under all circumstances. I personally believe this axiom, very strongly. I'd rather spit in the eye of death with my last breath than go quietly into the night. It logically follows, then, that a treatment that has a 1% chance of working is better than doing nothing, if the latter has a 0% chance of working, no matter how extreme the treatment is. Living longer, even in a state of constant extreme pain, is better than dying. Well, maybe dying peacefully would be less painful for my relatives, but again, I personally place a much higher value on my own life than my family's feelings of sadness or whatever. The only question which remains is the validity of the Axiom. If this world is all there is, if when you die there isn't an afterlife or reincarnation or whatever...then the Axiom is clearly true. If you have strong religious belief, then perhaps your afterlife is better. But only a perfect belief that you are headed to a better place makes it rational to give up. If you have a little bit of doubt -- if you're 99% sure you're going to Heaven but 1% of you whispers that maybe there's nothing and you'll turn into dust instead -- you still want to put off rolling that die as long as you can. Ditto if you're 100% sure there's an afterlife and 99% sure you've been good enough to get into Heaven, but 1% of you says that maybe Hell is where you're headed. If your religion forbids suicide, and there's a chance that the Judge who will weigh your life will interpret not opting for the best available medical treatment as equivalent to suicide, then that affects your decision too. Although, to be fair, this cuts both ways: The suffering you cause your family by lingering beyond your time on Earth might count against you too. Literally "Damned if you do, damned if you don't." It's unclear enough that there should really be a few more commandments or something, to address all the corner cases.
- SoftwareMaven 14y agoEverybody is entitled to their own opinion, of course, but you would really choose six months in a hospital bed, puking your guts out over three months of a reasonable quality of life? It's one thing if fighting means a 50% or greater chance of making it five years; it's quite another if fighting it means a matter of months.
- noonespecial 14y agoIt seems almost purposely designed to bankrupt you as quickly as possible so that the agencies can start passing you around as some sort of billing token.