31 ms·
The advance from NiCd to NiMh chemistry gave approximately a doubling of watts per kg. So did NiMh to LiPo. It's hardly Moore's Law, but it's a significant rate
by jdietrich 14y ago
The advance from NiCd to NiMh chemistry gave approximately a doubling of watts per kg. So did NiMh to LiPo. It's hardly Moore's Law, but it's a significant rate of improvement. I can't imagine what smartphones and tablets would look like without the development of LiPo. We've seen substantial improvements in those battery technologies, perhaps most usefully Sanyo's development of low-self-discharge NiMh cells, which vastly broadened the useful market for rechargeable batteries.
The rate of change seems glacial compared to the rest of the computer industry, but it's unfair to imagine that no change is occurring. Properly sexy stuff is happening in battery technology and we'd be extremely foolish to imagine that batteries are at a dead-end.
- deelowe 14y agoThe author addresses this in the article. The claim is that the battery chemistry itself hasn't improved, just our ability to keep it stable has which has allowed us to explore ideas that were previously not feasible due to a limitation with charging/discharging electronics. The assumption that there is little to no further progress to be made in this area (charging or chemistry). So, while battery technology may be improving, it will continue to improve slowly or not improve at all as there's a limit to how much more improvement we'll get from better charging/discharging circuits. Whether that's a valid claim is debatable, I guess, but I share the same opinion personally. Now, we could see a super capacitor or something like that one day which may change things, but so far those have yet to materialize.
- ph0rque 14y agoClaiming that battery chemistry itself hasn't improved is like claiming that the physics constants haven't changed... scratch that, it is indirectly claiming that physics haven't changed. This seems like it's a few steps from a tautology. If you look at this graph ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Energy_density.svg http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Energy_density.svg ), which is from a wikipedia section linked in the article, there are materials that hold more energy both per unit volume and unit mass than gasoline, we just haven't been able to exploit them yet. Isn't that the whole of materials engineering progress?
- mikeash 14y agoI like "Fat Metabolism" sitting up there near diesel and gasoline. Imagine a fat-powered fuel cell that can draw from our own bodies....
- stcredzero 14y agoSo long as it doesn't smell like ketonic B.O.
- kylebrown 14y ago> a doubling of watts per kg Do you mean watts (power or rate of conversion) or watt hours (total energy stored)? I'm not positive but I believe you said it correctly, which is to say that the NiMh batteries don't store more energy than their NiCd predecessors. They can only discharge it faster (can push a higher wattage but still has the same total energy capacity).
- npsimons 14y agoI'll second this; it's the first thought I had when I started reading TFA. One thing I'll add, though, is that Sanyo might not have been the first (or at least the only one) to start pushing low self-discharge batteries. I've got a whole bunch of Powerex Imedions (not linking because I'm not a shill, just a satisfied customer; google it) that are awesome. Keeping 85% of their charge over a year of storage has made me happy. Being able to swap to rechargeables in everything and getting rid of the alkalines that _always_ end up leaking (yes, even the name brands; especially the name brands) has made me very happy.