8 ms·
There is no better battery (2008)
- tocomment 14y agoHmm, what about lithium air batteries, and fuel cells, and all the other things that we hear about having 10x the energy density?
- runeks 14y agoHaven't heard about "lithium air batteries" but I'd say fuel cells aren't batteries since they basically just oxidize methanol (which is what an engine does with gasoline). But the lines might be more blurred than my thinking indicates.
- ars 14y ago> I'd say fuel cells aren't batteries since they basically just oxidize Many batteries also use oxidation reactions. That's not how you define a battery. I think the main difference is batteries release all the energy as electricity without associated heat, but fuel cells are partially electricity, partially heat.
- frankus 14y agoFuel cells are just "open" batteries, where the reactants are continuously fed into the battery and the products are removed (whereas in a battery the reactants and products occupy the same physical volume).
- ars 14y agoThen what distinguishes a fuel cell from a http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flow_battery http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flow_battery ?
- kylebrown 14y agoI'm pretty sure you're mistaken. The battery you describe violates the Second Law of Thermodynamics (no system can ever be 100% efficient). Both batteries and fuel cells (and any other open physical system) will lose some energy as waste heat in doing their work (producing electricity).
- tocomment 14y agoBy the way, are super capacitors still a promising technology? What's the hold up on getting those commercialized?
- jonmrodriguez 14y ago(1) Supercapacitors are commercialized, see: http://www.mouser.com/Power/Supercapacitors/_/N-6uivw http://www.mouser.com/Power/Supercapacitors/_/N-6uivw (2) Today's supercapacitors have very poor energy density even compared to batteries. What they do have is good power density, meaning they can deliver their limited energy very fast. (3) Boosting the energy density of supercapacitors will happen but requires many years of great strides in nanotech. Research like this, involving 3D nanostructures with enormous surface area: http://phys.org/news/2012-10-sponge-like-graphene-supercapacitor-electrodes.html http://phys.org/news/2012-10-sponge-like-graphene-supercapac...
- tocomment 14y agoHmm, I'm trying to compare these to batteries. Does anyone know how to convert farads to watt hours?
- irrelative 14y agoEnergy stored in a capacitor is equal to: 1/2 * c * v^2 Where c is the capacitance in farads, and v is the voltage. That will produce a value of joules. Note that the capacitor is rated for a given voltage, so that goes in as v. Converting watt hours to joules goes like this: A watt is one joule per second, so a watt hour is 3600 joules.
- tocomment 14y agoBy that formula, I only get ~12 joules for a 1 farad capacitor at 5 volts. That seems low. Are you sure it's correct?
- zokier 14y agoWolframAlpha confirms: http://wolfr.am/VWAp9B http://wolfr.am/VWAp9B
- gverri 14y agoConsidering that this post was written in 2008... What changed in these 5 years in the "battery" industry?
- jonmrodriguez 14y agoWhat's preventing us from putting fuel cells in laptops and tablets soon? Is it just that today's fuel cell designs are physically bulky? Are we near theoretical limits on fuel cell miniaturization or is there still lots of headroom? What's the safest way to store the fuel? Are there too many downsides to making the fuel cell air-breathing (as opposed to the danger of storing oxygen)? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fuel_cell http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fuel_cell Wikipedia says that fuel cells are typically "stacked" (placed in series) since each one only makes 0.7v, but if a new tablet is designed to save space by using only a single 0.7v cell and upregulating the voltage with a boost regulator, won't the total efficiency even with regulator losses still be far above li-ion?
- kalleboo 14y agoThere are a lot of fuel cells for sale in Japan right now for recharging a laptop, ipad or cell phone, but they charge lots for refills, so it's not an economical option.
- Breakthrough 14y agoIBM made a laptop some years back that was powered by a fuel cell combined with batteries. It ran off of methanol, and although it was kind of bulky, this was back in 2005. http://news.cnet.com/IBM-pours-a-shot-of-methanol-for-ThinkPads/2100-1044_3-5662616.html http://news.cnet.com/IBM-pours-a-shot-of-methanol-for-ThinkP...
- sallen 14y agoInteresting in the 5 years since this was written, what the friend claimed would happen has come to pass. Car2go runs several all electric car sharing fleets in various cities. I've used the one in San Diego a number of times.
- Tichy 14y agoReminds me of the time when it was declared that there was a physical barrier to sending more than 44kbps through a phone line.
- twoodfin 14y agoWasn't there? How much faster did modems over POTS really get? IIRC, even 56kbps only worked downstream, and only if you had a modern digital connection back to your telephone system.
- mikeash 14y agoYes, they were completely right, and improvements only happened by changing the game that was being played.
- takluyver 14y agoADSL connections over the same physical wire as a phone line can often get several Mbps.
- simonh 14y agoBut ADSL only goes as far as the exchange before being routed onto an IP backbone network. With modem signals the same signal goes over a voice circuit (albeit a virtual one) all the way to the receiving modem. They're not at all the same thing.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoThat's the point. People make sweeping assumptions about the limitations of something, and then someone else changes the ground underneath those assumptions and makes the cconclusions invalid. DSL, for example, is not much more difficult in terms of capital equipment cost compared to dialup and it doesn't require running a new line to the home, but the bandwidth available is a thousand times greater than the previous "hard" limit of phone land line based networking.
- 14y ago
- ricardobeat 14y agoThat's a very pessimistic view. There is plenty of on-going research in improving graphene batteries, molecular energy storage, and technology that is not that far from coming to market like Li-Si, Air-Lithium or solid hydrogen storage. Tesla now makes cars with a very useful range using standard Li-ion batteries and good thermal management, I wonder the author thinks of the Model S. http://gigaom.com/2013/01/14/13-battery-startups-to-watch-in-2013/ http://gigaom.com/2013/01/14/13-battery-startups-to-watch-in...
- stcredzero 14y agoAt this point, the Tesla's problem isn't range, it's charging convenience. 1/2 hour's manageable, but still a bit long.
- ricardobeat 14y agoIt's more than enough for urban use where the car will sit still for most of the night and have plenty of breaks during the day.
- stcredzero 14y agoThat's the happy path. What if things are hectic and you forgot to plug in last night, then you get an urgent page the next morning. That 1/2 hour won't seem so casual right then. However, I suspect you are taking my comment opposite to its intent. The only thing standing between Tesla and a 5 minute charge is enough current and economies of scale to allow cars with massively parallel charging hardware. Basically, if they can survive, they've won!
- ricardobeat 14y agoStill faster than walking to the gas station and back :) but yes, you're right. I hope they are not put down by a media scandal or legislation before that happens.
- 14y ago
- Xcelerate 14y agoNo. Just no. I don't know how freely I can talk about my research, but there's plenty going on with batteries.
- thoughtsimple 14y agoJust a note that this is from 2008. At least in the short term, he was right. Not much has happened in battery technology available to the public in the last 5 years.
- Xcelerate 14y agoI saw that it's from 2008. I'm not denying it's a hard problem, but to claim that improvement has stalled is short-sighted.
- 001sky 14y agoWithout any evidence -- even theoretical -- you are just posturing. The fundamentals of the post are not "short sighted", they describe a deep fundamental flaw that is (has been) historically perisistent. There is a difference between being "short sighted" and a lack of transparency. Until the "magic" ships.
- cryptoz 14y ago> Until the "magic" ships. So, there is a better battery. And it's inevitable.
- hosh 14y agoI'm not sure this is posturing. Or at least, it is certainly not "just" posturing. I'm not in research like this, so I just hear things fed off of Y(HN). I've heard of some interesting devices like the carbon nanotube based supercapacitors (was that what it was?). Who knows?
- tomjen3 14y agoIn research, maybe. But what we care about is when that research will result in better batteries _that_ we can buy.
- powertower 14y ago> None of this has done much to improve the fundamental energy storage densities of the underlying chemistries. The LENR (Low Energy Nuclear Reactions) field is really hot right now. COPs of 6-20x (and sometimes more) are being reported. Several labs have been burned to the ground who experimented with it and had a run-away reaction that was not expected. Whether it's Fusion or Transmutation or something else, the results are real and we are seeing heat anomalies that can't be explained, in table-top devices that use Ni nano-powder, some catalysts, a loading current and heat, and nothing particularly radioactive or difficult to procure. Also findings of direct EMF generation were reported recently, which could potentially bypass the heat-to-electricity step and the wasted energy in the Carnot cycle altogether. LENR is a fundamental shift in the energy storage density the author is talking about. http://www.slideshare.net/fullscreen/tylervan/lenr/2 http://www.slideshare.net/fullscreen/tylervan/lenr/2
- rwmj 14y agoLENR is the new baggage-free term for Cold Fusion. Extraordinary claims like yours need extraordinary proof. Please provide some.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- allerratio 14y agohttp://psiram.com/en/index.php/Cold_Fusion http://psiram.com/en/index.php/Cold_Fusion LENR is a fundamental shift from science to pseudo-science
- powertower 14y agorandom wiki website vs. Mitsubishi Heavy Industries http://indico.cern.ch/getFile.py/access?resId=5&materialId=slides&confId=177379 http://indico.cern.ch/getFile.py/access?resId=5&material... And that's just for a quick bite. See the slideshare for more relavant info.
- bmac27 14y agoalmost on cue: http://gigaom.com/2013/01/23/battery-startup-leyden-energy-raises-10m-for-its-next-gen-lithium-ion-batteries/ http://gigaom.com/2013/01/23/battery-startup-leyden-energy-r...
- skdoo 14y agoBatteries have improved significantly since 2008, and are still improving. The most important shifts have been in cost ($/kWh), but there have also been improvements in energy density (Wh/kg), power density (W/kg), and cycle life. Some of this is due to electronics improvements, but a lot is due to better cell design and manufacturing, funded in part by higher demand.
- jdietrich 14y agoThe advance from NiCd to NiMh chemistry gave approximately a doubling of watts per kg. So did NiMh to LiPo. It's hardly Moore's Law, but it's a significant rate of improvement. I can't imagine what smartphones and tablets would look like without the development of LiPo. We've seen substantial improvements in those battery technologies, perhaps most usefully Sanyo's development of low-self-discharge NiMh cells, which vastly broadened the useful market for rechargeable batteries. The rate of change seems glacial compared to the rest of the computer industry, but it's unfair to imagine that no change is occurring. Properly sexy stuff is happening in battery technology and we'd be extremely foolish to imagine that batteries are at a dead-end.
- deelowe 14y agoThe author addresses this in the article. The claim is that the battery chemistry itself hasn't improved, just our ability to keep it stable has which has allowed us to explore ideas that were previously not feasible due to a limitation with charging/discharging electronics. The assumption that there is little to no further progress to be made in this area (charging or chemistry). So, while battery technology may be improving, it will continue to improve slowly or not improve at all as there's a limit to how much more improvement we'll get from better charging/discharging circuits. Whether that's a valid claim is debatable, I guess, but I share the same opinion personally. Now, we could see a super capacitor or something like that one day which may change things, but so far those have yet to materialize.
- ph0rque 14y agoClaiming that battery chemistry itself hasn't improved is like claiming that the physics constants haven't changed... scratch that, it is indirectly claiming that physics haven't changed. This seems like it's a few steps from a tautology. If you look at this graph ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Energy_density.svg http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Energy_density.svg ), which is from a wikipedia section linked in the article, there are materials that hold more energy both per unit volume and unit mass than gasoline, we just haven't been able to exploit them yet. Isn't that the whole of materials engineering progress?
- ealloc 14y agoThe book "Powering the Future" also argues fuel will always outperform batteries, pointing out that both fuel and batteries store chemical energy, and that chemical energy density is fundamentally contrained by physics: Since all atoms are approximately the same size there is a limit to how many bonds/volume you can have, and since all chemical bonds are roughly the same amount of energy there's a limit on how much energy/volume you can store with chemical energy. The book then argues that hydrocarbon fuels come very close to the ideal energy density, and have many other advantages over batteries (weight (they're formed with light elements), extremely safe byproducts CO2 H2O, simple ingredients).
- frankus 14y agoFrom an energy policy perspective that sounds about right, but from the standpoint of what's theoretically possible that would seem to be ignoring some really promising areas of research.
- jcfrei 14y agoA 4 years old article on the front page of HN, with an attention-grabbing headline and no sign of serious research into the topic? Come on HN!
- joeycfan 14y agoHe's right. I just got through the battery course at Stanford Online and batteries suck. Downer.
- jbert 14y agoYou only need a battery to support you while you are off-grid. Electric trains don't run on batteries. Wireless charging is getting better. Electricity which is "too cheap to meter" would mean we didn't need 'great' battery tech, current tech would be ok. The other way to solve this problem is to say "burning hydrocarbons have great energy density, and the global transport industry is already tooled up to use them, so lets use those as our 'battery' tech", and just find: - a good way to turn our global energy output into stored chemical energy in hydrocarbons - a good way to use hydrocarbons in small-scale non-transport devices (phones?)
- ph0rque 14y agoFalse: http://www.akbars.net/images/battery%20energy%20density.png http://www.akbars.net/images/battery%20energy%20density.png
- brentledent 14y agoMan, every time great new technology comes along you guys have to come in and bust it all up with your logic and reason :)
- regomodo 14y agoHmm, didn't know there is a Palladium acid battery.
- drucken 14y agoThat graph shows Li-ion as the highest energy density, which is in accord with the article. What am I missing?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- icambron 14y agoThe trend. The point is that energy densities are improving steadily, contrary to the article.
- 14y ago
- jzilla 14y agoIf the issue with batteries for car sharing is that it takes too long to charge the batteries, why can't interchangeable batteries be used?
- GregBuchholz 14y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flow_battery http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flow_battery
- frankus 14y agoI agree with OP if your timeline is the next few years, but there is still a ton of headroom between, say, lithium polymer and the theoretical maximum for specific energy (the speed of light squared). Obviously nuclear batteries are going to be a long time coming (I'm not even aware of any theoretical way to make, say, a fission reaction release electrical rather than thermal energy), but if you expand on the definition of "battery" a bit from something you just plug in to recharge to something that maybe requires being physically swapped out and reprocessed, there are some very promising avenues of research. The one I'm most excited about is the vanadium boride-air cell, which has a practical energy density on par with diesel fuel. The catch is that is likely impractical to make one that can be recharged by simply reversing the current through it, so it would require a network of reprocessing plants and battery-exchange facilities.
- GregBuchholz 14y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atomic_battery http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atomic_battery
- jws 14y agoPerhaps the direction of improvement at this point is lifetime rather than energy density. 500 cycles was fine for portable electronics. Not so much for vehicles. Double the lifetime for a 10% increase in upfront costs would be a huge win. It isn't sexy enough to make it into the news, but there is progress here.
- simonsquiff 14y agoTesla, who presumably know a fair bit about this, say that battery energy density has been improving at a rate of 7-8% a year. http://www.eetimes.com/electronics-news/4370061/World-on-cusp-of-EV-tipping-point--says-Tesla-CTO http://www.eetimes.com/electronics-news/4370061/World-on-cus...
- SeanLuke 14y agoThat would imply a doubling every nine to ten years. A link from an earlier comment... http://www.akbars.net/images/battery%20energy%20density.png http://www.akbars.net/images/battery%20energy%20density.png ... would imply that this is overoptimistic by at least 2x.
- mynegation 14y agoLately there's been quite a development in the area of molten salt batteries, they look promising: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Molten_salt_battery http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Molten_salt_battery
- Aardwolf 14y agoHmm, the ZEBRA battery is in a museum and requires 245 °C to operate, I guess it's gonna be a while before this is in consumer devices :)
- hosh 14y agoThe post was written in 2008. Has there been any changes in the past five years to indicate any fundmental breakthrough in energy density? I know Tesla has come out with practical electric cars, but was that an improvement in energy density or an improvement in energy efficiency and management, as the article argues?
- Aardwolf 14y agoBiological organisms have quite a lot of energy stored in a small amount of space. A lot of inventions were based on nature, e.g. wings for flying. Who knows, one day maybe a battery invention will also be based on biology.
- dpark 14y agoBiological organisms aren't batteries. We manage to store lots of energy by storing it chemically. Internal combustion engines are already based on this. I burn fats, proteins, and carbohydrates for energy. My car burns gasoline. The issue is that we want to get away from that design, because it's not particularly sustainable. If we could come up with a reasonably-efficient way to produce gasoline (or an equivalent) in a renewable way, that would be wonderful, but it wouldn't be a battery.
- dspeyer 14y agoUsing something like cytochrome c reductase to turn hydrocarbons (bio- or geo-) into electricity and then into motion would be a big efficiency improvement over our current heat engines. Still, it's only half the problem. We also want an efficient and compact way to turn electricity into energy-dense chemicals. AFAIK, that doesn't exist in nature; we'd have to start from scratch.
- tocomment 14y agoHas anyone looked into using ATP in a battery? It seems to work really well for cells.