6 ms·
Body mass is correlated with lifespan
- brazzy 14y agoChuck Norris tells nature when it's time to die.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- tocomment 14y agoWhat about tortoises? Jellyfish?
- JCraig 14y agoTortoises were the first to come to mind for me. Later in the article, it does state that it's not just size but metabolism that figures into this correlation. That being said. The article states that this relationship governs "all life" but only gives data for plants. Even there, "some variation, but not a lot" is an extremely generous representation. For the same mass, a difference in mortality rate could be 10^3 or more if I'm reading the graph correctly. While the relationship might roughly follow a trend, I wouldn't call that "not a lot" of variation. It's interesting, but I think the authors are overselling the relationship.
- travisp 14y agoFurther, it can't just be metabolism. It is unlikely that it's simply the metabolism of some tortoises, lobsters, and hydras that causes them to not actually age. It's not that they just have extra long lifespans, their death rates do not increase with age.
- gadders 14y agoI was thinking about parrots. Not especially heavy, and can live 50-100 years.
- mikecane 14y agoWhat about dinosaurs? What about that "hobbit" species (Homo floresiensi)?
- Irregardless 14y agoThe title is pure linkbait, which is surprising for NPR. I guess that's the only way to get more clicks when the entire article boils down to "Large plants/animals live longer, on average (except humans)". Thanks, we hadn't already noticed. A formula that "tells us when it's time to die" would imply some sort of prediction about individuals, which they admit is not the case at all. That would actually be interesting.
- hemancuso 14y agoVisual inspection also suggests a rather low R^2 on that regression. It looks much more like a loose correlation than a formula to me.
- Irregardless 14y agoGood point, I'd only glanced at the chart. Looks like the trees along the right have a half-life range of <10,000 to >1,000,000, even with nearly identical individual mass.
- travisp 14y agoThe actual paper really just applies to plants. But there are also far more exceptions than just humans. Giant tortoises have effectively no known life expectancy, at least as a result of aging -- they do not age: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Negligible_senescence http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Negligible_senescence
- AngryParsley 14y agoThe last graph amuses me: http://media.npr.org/assets/img/2013/01/22/graph_custom-3939b09513b4668a3e8aff03cd481e72683f1012-s4.jpg http://media.npr.org/assets/img/2013/01/22/graph_custom-3939... Even on a log-log graph, the data looks like a shotgun spread. Species of similar mass have lifetimes that vary by up to a factor of 1,000. Species with similar life-spans differ in mass by up to a factor of a trillion.
- bernardom 14y agoThis. I see how the three clusters (plankton, trees, and everything else) are arranged in a way suggesting a linear relationship, but within the clusters? Nothing.
- eduardordm 14y agoWell, I don't think the author understood the paper. Make sure you correctly read a paper before spreading wrong conclusions. The article is about the relationship between death, birth and mass (which are obviously connected, the paper is about that relationship). Time is just the scope there.
- xerula 14y agoThere is nothing new about the observation that body mass is correlated with lifespan, at the level of species - why should we be at all surprised that the correlation is described by some power law? There are compelling metabolic explanations for these patterns going back more than a century. What really excites modern biologists – and what the article completely fails to discuss (even to the point of claiming "this rule seems to govern all life") – are the numerous and dramatic exceptions to the rule: naked role rats, tardigrades, certain cnidarians ("immortal" jellyfish & hydra) and planarians, various lichens... In some of these cases, metabolic rate is divorced from body size through a well-characterized, indefinite hibernation 'mode', but more efficient DNA protection, repair and telomere length preservation systems are also important. And there is a substantial literature that explains unusually prolonged life-cycles using Evolutionary Stable Strategy modeling. All of which provide useful perspectives in aging research. Much more interesting would have been an article about how these violations of nature's "death formula" tell us how we might avoid death.
- jmilloy 14y agoAs usual, read the paper instead [0]. It's short, clear, and easy to read. In particular, it applies only to plants, so the article's musings about jellyfish and elephants is off the mark and even addressed in the paper [1]. So is the irrelevant discussion of "pulse", which is oddly supported with video that is just played forward and backward. The paper just claims to support some known, quantifiable correlations with some data. The correlations pertain to mortality rates and birth rates, and certainly suggests no formula for when to die, or causation of any sort for that matter. E.g, is it that bigger plants die less often, or that plants that die less often can get bigger? Does it matter? [0] http://www.pnas.org/content/104/40/15777.full http://www.pnas.org/content/104/40/15777.full [1] "Whereas the action of selective processes on animal lifespan cannot extend through their entire lifespan because many lose reproductive capacity with age, this is not the case in plants, which generally remain reproductive throughout their lifespan, suggesting that lifespan could be under greater selective pressure in plants."
- redwood 14y agoPerhaps it's better to suggest that plants which grow into their own foundations eventually reach a limit whereby it's hard for the plant to continue getting the nutrients it needs without being essentially blocked by its prior scaffolding? Bigger plants are the ones that reach this limit later, e.g. have evolved ways of using prior root systems/trunks to their benefit overtime. Plants can essentially live forever through cloning, where the plant lays new roots and isn't stuck on its former shell. On the other hand stressed plants go to seed (a good evolutionary move) and statistically no plant lives forever in the wild, with fires and etc, so perhaps this data is more of a testament to how fragile a plant is... e.g. how easily it's killed. It makes sense that smaller = more fragile, more easily burnt/frozen to death, etc.
- leeoniya 14y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Telomerase#Aging http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Telomerase#Aging
- travisp 14y agoAre you suggesting telomeres or telomerase activity correlates with the size of the species? It's unclear what exactly is the role of telomeres in aging. Your article says "it is currently unknown to what extent telomere erosion contributes to the normal aging process". It is a major hypothesis, but there's a lot we don't know about it.
- brenfrow 14y agoMy question is if we all get 1.5 billion heart beats. What if I run long distance and do alot of cardio and get my resting heartbeat down to 45 beats a minute. Will I on average out live someone who has a resting pulse of 70?
- nagrom 14y agoI would imagine that you use up some of those 'extra' resting heartbeats by doing all that cardio and long distance running, no?
- return0 14y agoThis works for plants. Plants have a very (very) stable environment.
- septerr 14y agoDid anyone else feel like the gifs were overused?