4 ms·
It seems silly to have any modern Linux distro be anything but a well implemented rolling release, because people aren't getting physical dvds to install this s
by zanny 14y ago
It seems silly to have any modern Linux distro be anything but a well implemented rolling release, because people aren't getting physical dvds to install this stuff anymore. If you run a server, get the latest stable packages, run with it, and if something needs upgrading manually upgrade the select packages you want to update. Keep security updates. If you are a normal user, you can probably just let rolling updates upgrade everything.
The greatest problem I have with my relatives who I have running Ubuntu or Fedora is that major version increments will almost always critically break the system because they are often 4 - 6 kernels or other package versions behind. If you were to step through the update process in order, you might get a minor snag, but often it updates flawlessly. I have never had an issue in over a year running an Arch box (besides porting my init scripts to systemd, but that was a unique case, and that wasn't a problem, it just required effort) whereas on two separate machines going from 11.04 to 12.04 broke the kernel or graphics drivers respectively.
I do think most distros could do better with 3 tiers of packages in a rolling release, though - new releases for the actual developers of the package to run through the ropes and find and fix major bugs they specifically encounter, which then pass into a testing branch where enthusiasts can run bleeding edge software and submit errors they encounter to be fixed before it enters mainstream core repos. A lot of the current problems with rolling releases are that you don't have a big enough pool running in testing to catch the majority of slip-through-the-cracks integration problems that pop up after the release itself is solid, so you need to properly incentivize people to use the testing branch, and the main reason people don't do that is that updates often just outright break the software entirely rather than have integration issues, hence 3 tiers.
- BruceIV 14y agoSounds like Debian sid/testing/stable...
- imrehg 14y agoOr ArchLinux testing/stable.... though sometimes even stable feels like "testing", but with the occasional breakages I had less problem with Archlinux, then I had with the Ubuntu updates release by release....
- simula67 14y agoIt seems silly to have any modern Linux distro be anything but a well implemented rolling release The key here is of course well implemented. I switched recently from Debian back to Ubuntu because I need a system that is properly QC'ed. I was using Debian testing and every time I dist-upgraded something broke. It got so bad that I started waiting for weekends to do it. The greatest problem I have with my relatives who I have running Ubuntu or Fedora is that major version increments will almost always critically break the system because they are often 4 - 6 kernels or other package versions behind. Use an LTS version of Ubuntu. I do think most distros could do better with 3 tiers of packages in a rolling release This is how Debian does it. Problem is that stable branch does not contain many new software, testing/unstable branch is still too volatile for use as a regular system.