4 ms·
"So I gather that you believe the entirety of SSRI's popularity, as well as all the good/bad physiological effects many of us taking them find so apparent, are
by Alex3917 14y ago
"So I gather that you believe the entirety of SSRI's popularity, as well as all the good/bad physiological effects many of us taking them find so apparent, are strictly placebo effect?"
When you say "I gather that you believe" you seem to be implying that it's an opinion question. But for what it's worth, that's not how it works exactly. Again read The Emperors New Drugs for a good explanation. The book Anatomy of an Epidemic also has some good info in the relevant chapter.
- zzzeek 14y agoGoing on your statement, "not effective for any type of depression", you're saying that the SSRI I'm taking has no effect whatsoever, and that nobody else has any benefits from SSRIs. The good effects we all report are imagined. I'd just like you to directly confirm that's what you're saying. It's a little rude to state that I'm completely misguided in my healthcare choices, then to wave it off as "just go read this book" when i question that.
- rlucas 14y agoIt's incorrect to say that grandparent's quote "not effective" is the same as your phrase "no effect whatsoever." The suggestion, following Irving Kirsch's book, that the SSRIs are broadly "not effective," is a statement about the distribution of outcomes over a population. (It also takes into account the fact that even placebos cause changes in outcomes, and that we consider a drug not to be "effective" if its outcomes do not differ meaningfully from those attributable to placebos.) This is maybe better stated as "not efficacious" because we're talking about efficacy, vs. placebo, in a population. This is entirely different from the parent's (counterfactual) statement "the SSRI I'm taking has no effect whatsoever," which is an assertion about having any effect (not a relative effect vs. placebo) in a single individual (not a population). "Not effective"[as a vector operation and vs. a baseline established by placebo] != "has no effect whatsoever"[as a scalar operation and vs. a baseline of no intervention] Grandparent has most definitely not said that your perception of SSRI effects are "imagined," nor that you are "misguided." But you are arguing against a straw man until you at least acknowledge the distinctions here (which, it must be said, are pretty well explained in the book in question ;)
- zzzeek 14y agoThanks for the language litigation, I'm now aware of the many subtle inaccuracies in my language, despite my skepticism that my real question was really so occluded. So here it is again: Is it your opinion that the popularity of SSRIs is misguided, and that their use would be better off discouraged, since they have been shown to be no more "effective" than placebo? That the vast majority of (or all?) patients who report "success" with SSRIs are simply experiencing an effect that could just as easily be delivered via sugar pill? Wikipedia's paragraph on this here (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Selective_serotonin_reuptake_inhibitor#Depression http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Selective_serotonin_reuptake_in...) has a decent summary of the current status. SSRIs have been shown, by two meta-analyses, to have a "clinically significant" effect for very severe depression, and a "statistically significant" effect for moderate depression, which is considered below the threshold of usefulness. The original poster's words were, "not effective for any type of depression". So will you correct this statement as well?
- Alex3917 14y agoAgain, you need to read the book(s) if you want to understand the argument. The Wiki paragraph doesn't actually do a good job explaining much of anything.
- zzzeek 14y agoJust wanting a simple yes or no. Or "not sure". SSRIs, pointless or not, in your opinion/fact-based-knowledge/divine-guidance/whatever. Thanks.
- zzzeek 14y agonevermind, I've reviewed enough of Kirsch's book and discussion of it at this point to see that it is virulently opposed to antidepressants and is cited broadly by various career opponents of psychiatry as well as a large number of lay-people troubled by the concept of depression as a medical illness. And as one would expect, often challenged by actual psychiatrists (but not always), focusing mostly on the inherently flawed state of measurement with regards to depression.