7 ms·
> PACER is a system for accessing court dockets, not a repository of case law. This is becoming more true than it was a few years ago, but traditionally PACER
by _delirium 14y ago
> PACER is a system for accessing court dockets, not a repository of case law.
This is becoming more true than it was a few years ago, but traditionally PACER has served both functions: it's the primary federal repository for publishing court dockets, including actual decisions, injunctions, and written opinions. That function has been slowly diminishing as public access through other avenues improves, but I believe some district court decisions are still available only via PACER. Some of these newer public-facing websites are actually implemented as some kind of no-login wrapper on top of PACER, e.g.: http://pacer.ca4.uscourts.gov/opinions/opinion.htm http://pacer.ca4.uscourts.gov/opinions/opinion.htm
The court system does seem to have realized that public access to court opinions vs attorney access to court dockets are two fairly different use cases, and there are moves to either free up or even offload the opinion-repository function of PACER. Since 2002, all final written opinions are free of page charges when retrieved via PACER, and there is a special opinion-search function that doesn't charge you for the search results either. But you do still need an account and to give them a credit card, so it's easy to get charged for something else if you run the wrong kind of search, or click on the wrong document. On the other hand, wrappers like that 4th-district one above make some PACER documents accessible without an actual PACER account.
Recognizing that that's still rather suboptimal, the courts seem to be moving to using a new service of the Government Printing Office, FDSys, as the conduit for public access to opinions, so non-lawyers won't have to rely on PACER for opinions anymore: http://www.uscourts.gov/news/newsView/11-05-04/New_Pilot_Project_Will_Enhance_Public_Access_to_Federal_Court_Opinions.aspx http://www.uscourts.gov/news/newsView/11-05-04/New_Pilot_Pro...
- rayiner 14y agoI'm certainly not a luddite, and the more documents I can get on line and the less in Lexis/Westlaw fees I rack up, the happier I am. What irks me is the misplaced moral outrage. Mr. Foster takes the $6.5 billion number and makes it seem like some collusion to make Lexis and Westlaw gate keepers of what should be publicly available information. In reality, the problem is far less sinister: outdated IT. The courts have been slow to evolve from putting a copy of the reporters in a public law library to the digital age. Is that a problem? Sure. Let's get them more funding and get these things digitized. But trying to work it into an anti-government, anti-business narrative just to send nerds into a frothy rage is stupid and counter-productive.
- subsystem 14y agoTell me this, do you think public domain documents available through PACER today should, as a matter of principle, be available free of charge? And if not, why not?
- rayiner 14y agoI don't really care, to be honest. I don't think "free as in speech" needs to be "free as in beer." I don't have a problem with a modest charge for PACER documents, just as I don't have a problem with a modest charge for using the subway. If someone wants to make it their mission, I don't object. But Mr. Foster's email was not about whether, in principle, PACER documents should be free. It was an uneducated attack on Lexis and West, claiming that they were engaged in "rent seeking." Wikipedia: "In economics, rent-seeking is an attempt to obtain economic rent by manipulating the social or political environment in which economic activities occur, rather than by creating new wealth. One example is spending money on political lobbying in order to be given a share of wealth that has already been created." The implication was that Lexis and West were colluding with the courts to make Lexis-Nexis and Westlaw a for-profit gateway to public domain documents.
- thinkcomp 14y agoFirst, "outdated IT" is only part of the problem. The courts have had decades to upgrade their systems, and they have consistently refused for one reason or another. Upgrades are not free, but the cost justifications have been blown so far out of proportion that it's simply not possible for them to be genuinely concerned about cost. There is real reluctance to change on the part of powerful individuals. Second, whether or not Lexis and West are explicitly colluding with the courts is not really the issue. The fact of the matter is that in many, many, many jurisdictions, Lexis and West are THE ONLY WAY to access public information. Take the Code of Maryland as an example... http://www.lexisnexis.com/hottopics/mdcode/ http://www.lexisnexis.com/hottopics/mdcode/ ...or the California Supreme Court... http://www.lexisnexis.com/clients/CACourts/ http://www.lexisnexis.com/clients/CACourts/ On both of these official government pages, one must agree to terms and conditions of Lexis Nexis in order to access public information for which there is no other official source. One of those conditions (if I remember correctly) is that I may not access what they might consider to be too much public information. This is outrageous. Whether or not legal contracts or illegal collusion resulted in this setup is totally irrelevant. What matters is that this information's availability should not be subject to anyone's approval. And what I see is Lexis and West acting precisely as "a for-profit gateway to public domain documents."