3 ms·
Despite how similar cases of Swartz and Auernheimer seem, and despite later's appeal to social justice and freedom causes, I must admit I still have a hard time
by smsm42 14y ago
Despite how similar cases of Swartz and Auernheimer seem, and despite later's appeal to social justice and freedom causes, I must admit I still have a hard time mustering sympathy for him. At least not even close to the sympathy I have to Swartz. I know justice has to be blind, but I'm not in the jury, so I have the luxury not to be. For me, the difference in approaches is striking. On one side, we have somebody who contributed to RSS and Reddit - I am not a big fan of Reddit, but one doesn't have do be a fan to recognize it's a major establishment in the Internet society - and on the other side, we have what? GNAA?
I can't read minds, but to me, it just seems that while Swartz was moved by genuine concern and willing to overstep some boundaries, for Auernheimer it was much more about overstepping bounderies, creating mayhem and pissing people off, and the cause came just as a convenient channel to direct his destructive energies.
That doesn't mean that I wish ill to Auernheimer - I wish that his sentence would be light and involve as little jail time as possible (by now realistically it looks like there would be some) - but I must say if we want to change public opinion about overprosecuting computer crimes, guys like Auernheimer don't exactly help the cause.