4 ms·
Comparing Germany to Alaska seems a bit unfair. If you want to live in a walkable, dense small town in the US, they do exist. I'd personally prefer to live in
by rdl 14y ago
Comparing Germany to Alaska seems a bit unfair. If you want to live in a walkable, dense small town in the US, they do exist.
I'd personally prefer to live in a place with multi-acre lots and driving and no kids. Trees are fine, though. The great thing about the US is you actually have everything from dense SF downtown to fairly "German" Palo Alto to Atherton/Hillsborough/Portola Valley, all within the same job market metro area.
- prawks 14y agoI'd say extrapolating Alaska to the rest of America is also a big problem in the point the author and her contact are trying to make.
- weeksie 14y agoAnchorage could be any random middle american town and it exhibits the same suburban sprawl issues. What problems do you see with the extrapolation?
- prawks 14y agoAmerica is not homogeneous. "Random middle America" I can't speak to, but certainly neither coast fits this article (from my experience). There doesn't seem to be mention of this in the article.
- weeksie 14y agoWow, that's exactly the opposite of my experience. Random middle American towns are a vast, bland expanse of strip malls, big box chain stores, suburban tract housing, and family dining restaurants. The towns that aren't like that are the exception.
- _delirium 14y agoThere are some choices, but I think you overestimate the amount of choice most people have with American development patterns. Sure, you could live in SF or Palo Alto, if you're well off (my brother pays over $1000 for one room in a shared apartment in the Mission). But if you aren't, you're going to be commuting from somewhere else; your only choice is whether you're going to commute from Gilroy or Fremont or whatever. With different development patterns, that's not necessarily the case: in Copenhagen or Berlin, you don't have to be particularly wealthy to live in a centrally located apartment.
- rdl 14y agoEven if you are poor, you could live in Oakland or San Jose in the Bay Area, or in Fremont/San Leandro/etc for the crappy suburb experience, or south of San Jose or west of the hills for rural.
- dennisgorelik 14y agoThe cheapest house I could find in Protola Valley is $2.1M: http://www.zillow.com/homedetails/140-Campo-Rd-Portola-Valley-CA-94028/15602465_zpid/ http://www.zillow.com/homedetails/140-Campo-Rd-Portola-Valle... It does not really seem like a choice...