4 ms·
From Wikipedia: "On 20 November 2012, Auernheimer was found guilty of one count of identity fraud and one count of conspiracy to access a computer without auth
by crazygringo 14y ago
From Wikipedia:
"On 20 November 2012, Auernheimer was found guilty of one count of identity fraud and one count of conspiracy to access a computer without authorization. Auernheimer tweeted that he would appeal the ruling."
Is the problem that the laws themselves are terrible, or that the laws are being misused by overzealous prosecutors? I mean, if changing a public URL is considered "conspiracy to access a computer without authorization"... Or is this just not the full story, and he really was trying to do some "bad" stuff?
But if not: what can be done to change the law? Is appearing "soft on hacking" such a bad idea that politicians just won't support something better? Or is it really difficult to craft laws that actually do criminalize "bad" activity, without also technically criminalizing innocent activity?
What can be done?
- rayiner 14y agoThe problem is that there is little consensus on what the boundaries in digital space should mean. Law makers, not without a certain logic, approach things from the principles of private property. Is changing a public URL considered "conspiracy to access a computer without authorization?" Well why would you do it, intentionally? Would you jiggle my door handle to see if that would unlock it? And if it was a crappy lock and jiggling it did unlock it, would it be unauthorized access to my property if you then walked in the door? There is a line of thinking in the tech community that accessing data you're not supposed to access is only "bad" if you do something "bad" with it. But in meat space, we enforce fences in their own right, whether or not there is any other criminal activity involved. Arguably, doing so makes the larger problem of ensuring that their isn't associated criminal activity more tractable. Actually, real world example: over the weekend someone stole my phone out of my (unlocked) car while it was parked in my apartment building's garage. Now, let's say he hadn't stolen the phone. Just rifled through the glove box and center console. No harm no foul, right? Of course not. We presume there is no good reason to be looking through someone else's car, even if you fully intend not to take anything. Now, that doesn't mean we should treat digital boundaries the same as physical ones, but I don't think it's as obvious as some people in the tech community make it out to be that there shouldn't be penalties (of some sort--the magnitude of such penalties is a whole another debate) for intentionally violating digital boundaries, regardless of how well they are protected.
- greenyoda 14y agoIt's not likely that someone would get a long jail sentence for breaking into your car and not taking anything. If they had never committed a crime before, they'd probably get a fine or probation. There are usually monetary thresholds for a crime to be considered "grand theft" (a felony) vs. "petty theft" (a misdemeanor).
- rayiner 14y agoI don't think that violating digital boundaries without anything else should warrant long jail sentences (or any jail sentences at all). But I think there is value in enforcing borders in their own right, even if the punishment is nominal.
- jamesaguilar 14y agoAnd if weev had seen the exploit, thought to himself, "heh, that's funny," and not gone back, he would not be headed to prison. But, that isn't what happened.
- rsingel 14y agoIf he found it and then sold it to a government agency, he'd be rich and not in jail. Selling exploits to the government is a lucrative business. Google "CIPAV", for one.
- 73939133 14y ago- But if not: what can be done to change the law? - That's an easy one! Just get congress to pass a law granting you retroactive immunity for breaking the law. http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2012/oct/10/supreme-court-telecoms-win-immunity http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2012/oct/10/supreme-...