39 ms·
This scares me. How do you draw the line between someone having no choice to kill themselves and other actions that some majority might not consider to be choic
by mh9ndn 14y ago
This scares me. How do you draw the line between someone having no choice to kill themselves and other actions that some majority might not consider to be choices?
Yes, death is final. I still feel it's my choice, other's disagree. What makes their view more valid than mine?
(I don't necessarily believe in a free will, but if it exists it's hard to tell who has with concern to what decisions.)
- tptacek 14y agoThe Buddhist monks who killed themselves to protest the South Vietnamese government were probably not suffering from a mental illness. Most suicides are not monks protesting repressive governments. There is very little evidence to suggest that Swartz died in a deliberate act of protest, and much to suggest that he died of a terrible illness.
- mh9ndn 14y agoI'm sure Aaron was aware of that his suicide would bring a lot of attention to his causes and this will have played a part in his, as I consider it, decision. He was also aware of the practical problems, including depression, he faced including that there is a chance of them getting worse and that he could prevent that. I'm not against curing depression and investing more resources into getting better at it. My worry is that people with depression are portrayed as slaves to disease, as opposed to healthy people who are free to make decisions based on their interests. That encourages limiting the choice ill people can make. Aaron is no longer suffering from a mental illness. For him, ignoring others, it was a rational decision that he benefitted from.
- owenkahn 14y ago>I'm sure Aaron was aware of that his suicide would bring a lot of attention to his causes and this will have played a part in his, as I consider it, decision. I'm not sure: http://www.quinnnorton.com/said/?p=644 http://www.quinnnorton.com/said/?p=644 >We used to have a fight about how much the internet would grieve if he died. I was right.
- JabavuAdams 14y agoThere's no algorithm. We're learning things about the brain that, essentially, society isn't ready for. What should give one pause is the experience of many people who were suicidal at one point, who later can hardly believe / articulate what they were thinking. I.e. it seemed to make perfect crystal-clear sense at the time, but now the reasoning sounds absolutely stupid. I believe there's a parallel to over-constrained problems in engineering. One common pattern of depression and suicidal thinking is the feeling that there are no other options. People become trapped in seemingly unsatisfiable constraints, and the only option that appears to remain is to cease to live. Remove one or two of those apparent constraints, and all of a sudden the problem becomes satisfiable, and life can continue.