3 ms·
How secret do startup proposals to Y Combinator need to be? Should applicants avoid making any of their prototypes public?
- amichail 20y agoTo complicate matters, what if your proposal is rejected in this coming round but you are thinking of applying again in the following round? Clearly, not making a prototype public becomes more of an issue in that case.
- danielha 20y agoIt's your company. Why would it be an issue whether or not it was secret?
- staunch 20y ago
- domp 20y agoThis post says the wrong number of comments. Weird.
- jamiequint 20y agoI think except in very rare cases Derek from CD Baby says it best... Awful idea = -1 Weak idea = 1 So-so idea = 5 Good idea = 10 Great idea = 15 Brilliant idea = 20 No execution = $1 Weak execution = $1000 So-so execution = $10,000 Good execution = $100,000 Great execution = $1,000,000 Brilliant execution = $10,000,000
- motoko 20y agoSo an awful idea with a brilliant execution will cost you $10,000,000? That's quite a bit of bail money, yes?
- ecuzzillo 20y agoIt'll probably just cost some dumb VC 10 mil, not you personally.
- nostrademons 20y agoWindows Vista.
- staunch 20y ago
- pg 20y agoYou don't have to keep anything secret for our sake. This batch we funded three companies that were already launched, Buxfer, Weebly, and Virtualmin.