3 ms·
I've been a developer with a private office and I've also been on a small (< 10 person) team in an open office plan. Give me the open office any day. If there's
by majormajor 14y ago
I've been a developer with a private office and I've also been on a small (< 10 person) team in an open office plan. Give me the open office any day. If there's a side conversation not of interest to me, I tune it out. But frequently there are ones that are of interest to me that I'm able to either contribute to or learn something from. It's great for group troubleshooting of sudden issues, too.
- mnicole 14y ago> I tune it out Try as we might, some of us just can't do this.
- jacquesm 14y agoGet a pair of good headphones.
- MJR 14y agoSome people prefer a quiet environment versus listening to something, even if that's white noise. So, while getting a good pair of headphones is great for those who like having some auditory stimulation while they work, it just doesn't compare to having a quiet office if that's how you work best.
- eps 14y agoThere is basically no such thing as "quiet environment", unless it's a library. There will be some noise from the neighbors, from the street or whatever. I find that I can tune out easily enough if the noise is beyond my control. If, on the other hand, it's someone whom I can ask to keep it down (but would rather not to), then noise cancelling headphones is the best option there is.
- MJR 14y agoOk, you're getting into semantics now. I think most people reading that would understand what I mean when I say a quiet environment, especially vs a library where the only sounds tend to be the information desk, the hum of computer fans, photocopiers and the heating/cooling system. The quiet environment I was describing can be found in an office where the majority of people are heads-down working and not on the phone. This is harder to find when you're in an office that's setup as a cube-farm or an open layout. But this can be easily found at the beginning or end of the day and especially on work days that bookend holidays or three day weekends - days that lots of people typically take vacation. Those are the times when I find I get my best work done because it is the closest to quiet and distraction-free that one can find, other than working remotely where you can control the environment.
- rayiner 14y agoDo you sleep with headphones on? If not--there you go, quiet environment.
- mnicole 14y agoI've literally worn noise-canceling earbuds inside of over-ear Beyerdynamics to keep the noise out and ensure that people can see that I am distracted/not listening/not available, but if someone really wants to hang over your cube wall to try to have a conversation with you instead of just emailing you, nothing stops them and it's considered rude to suggest anything otherwise. That's the reason we have an open floorplan to begin with; the company's attitude is that everyone is available at all times. To non-technical staff, it's "faster" for them to walk up to us than it is to write it out. It's also worth mentioning that headphones were outright banned from the office for this reason, but slowly the creative departments have taken to ignoring it. As far as the "go-to" person people have noted having above, everyone on my team works on different aspects of what we do, so no one person can answer every question. Our PM is also not super familiar with what those roles are nor are they technically competent enough to answer those questions on their own (as of now, anyway).
- rhizome 14y ago....and then you're sitting there working while loud, open-plan loving boss is having an impromptu with a few people in the middle of the floor, you catch his eye a few times and take off the 'phones to see what's up, and it's nothing of your concern. Many times the difference is simply a people problem.
- mutagen 14y agoI suspect the two parent comments (and several more here and every time this topic comes up) point to a fundamental difference between various people, some are more productive in silence and solitude and some thrive on the productivity around them. While it might sound like the difference between introverted and extroverted, I suspect it isn't quite as simple. It very likely also depends on the job to be done (memory load), the content and quality of surrounding conversation and more ephemeral factors like company culture. I suspect it also affects how well things like pair programming work out, conversations about it often elicit quite polarized viewpoints on the subject.
- MattRogish 14y agoI really want to learn more about this. I think there's some level of cognitive bias here with respect to social interaction preferences. I certainly prefer to hang out with folks in a social setting compared to sitting in an office all day. I understand folks who prefer to do this in a work environment from a camaraderie and a "I'm not in a cave" perspective. That's totally fine and understandable. But from a real, practical standpoint - are folks that "prefer" to be in an open setting actually more productive than those not? What type of programming lends itself better to a distraction-filled environment? How does "culture" fit into the distraction equation, other than "we tolerate more distraction-killing productivity here than elsewhere"? (We have a chat room where we try and put all side discussions, so folks can virtually "overhear" conversations and chime in if applicable). I concede that there could be some people who will get so antsy in an office all day that the mosh pit-style work environment "feels" better. I'm not discounting that some folks prefer to be in a noisy environment. I just question whether or not they're actually more productive there or that the organization is better off in total with a noisy environment. The difficulty I have is that I cannot find any studies that show that a distraction-filled environment creates more knowledge-worker productivity than a quiet one. Mountains of studies scream the opposite. Personally, I'd rather find other ways to channel that ADHD energy in a more productive manner. :D
- majormajor 14y agoI would guess it has a lot to do with the team, especially the size but also the level of commitment to the work of the other devs. I've never been around a loud team or in a noisy environment (I'm not counting the sound of other people typing). Blocking out 50 conversations in a day, many of the much more inane or pointless, may be much harder for me than 5 business/tech-related ones. But I've never had to try to deal with that. Though I doubt that it would be much different for me, personally, because when I'm really in the middle of an interesting problem and cranking stuff out, I just don't notice background noise in the same way I don't notice that it's suddenly four hours later... I mean, maybe I'm just lucky in that, but my own coworkers have never expressed frustration with the environment either, so I don't know just how rare it is. (So I guess the key thing is that if the environment is getting to you, don't just keep it to yourself!) I also have a (maybe overly cynical?) hunch that in addition to the "ease of distraction by external noises" spectrum there's also a "desire to goof off more if nobody's going to notice" spectrum that comes into play. (He says, as he posts on HN in the middle of the day, heh...) I've never bothered to look into research on it, but I also don't see any trends of companies with private offices outcompeting ones without. I know the output of the team I was on at the company I worked at where I had a private office was not great, but there are other factors involved there too, of course. I also think the rotating "consulting developers" idea from grecy above sounds like a pretty good idea, regardless of office layout.
- abecedarius 14y agoIt's curious that nobody in this thread has mentioned visual distractions. For some of us they're a big deal too, and earplugs are no help.
- jonke 14y agoThe thing is that we (as a group in this thread) don't have a shared view what productivity is. That you feel more productive when you are allowed to interact with other fellow programmers maybe true or false. If you should deliver something in a short timespan that will allow your company to taker an order of 15M € and you get distracted by two junior programmers discussion C string concatenation I'm sure your Company owner would feel that you are 'not productive'. Most people outside the programming pack consider turning time at work into money as productive. Programmers usually don't use that definition for productivity.