16 ms·
Ortiz says suicide will not change handling of cases
- wheelerwj 14y ago"We thought the case was reasonably handled and we would not have done things differently." How can a suicide of a 26 year old man under prosecution by your office not warrant some sort of change? How can you not reflect and try for a better outcome. To not change suggests that this was an acceptable outcome... which is the point we are trying to make. Prosecution should not be so severe that suicide is a viable alternative.
- TylerE 14y agoThe justice department is not in the healthcare business. Let's not shy too far from the facts here. Aaron knew what he was doing was breaking the law. He participated in an act of civil disobedience, that does not grant freedom from consequences.
- olefoo 14y agoThat's like saying that people who block traffic for ten minutes to make a point about nuclear weapons deserved to be charged under the conspiracy statutes with potential life sentences since it was near a federal facility... There's a certain proportionality that's very definitely lacking in this case.
- darkarmani 14y ago> He participated in an act of civil disobedience, that does not grant freedom from consequences. Way to intentionally not understand the situation.
- IheartApplesDix 14y ago9/10
- betterunix 14y ago"Aaron knew what he was doing was breaking the law. He participated in an act of civil disobedience, that does not grant freedom from consequences." Yes, it is obvious to anyone downloading academic papers that they are committing 13 crimes and could be imprisoned for the rest of their lives. After all, changing your MAC address, hiding a laptop in a closet, and ignoring JSTOR's TOS clearly add up to 13. He should have read the law? Have you read the law? Are you sure you haven't committed any felonies today? I seriously doubt that Aaron really considered the possibility of criminal action for what he did, and certainly not so many charges that he could have been legally imprisoned for the remainder of his adult life. A civil suit by JSTOR would have been a reasonable expectation, and note what Aaron did when faced with a civil suit: he returned a hard drive of files to JSTOR and settled the matter, without any suicidal actions. Your sort of reasoning -- that he allegedly broke the law, therefore no mercy can be considered and the prosecutor was right to harass him -- is one of the most destructive far-right concepts to have been popularized in America. It is the line of reasoning that leads to teams of soldiers attacking civilian homes to serve a basic search-and-arrest warrant. It is the sort of reasoning that opens the door to the crushing tyranny of overly broad laws and abuses of the justice system. Allowing ourselves to fall victim to the logic that the law is perfect and absolute, that prosecutors have a moral duty to enforce all laws, opens us to a system where nobody is safe from the government.
- TylerE 14y agoIf he didn't think he was committing a crime why did he attempt to conceal his identity? If he had been accessing student's personal info, would you still be defending him? Unauthorized access is unauthorized access.
- betterunix 14y ago"If he didn't think he was committing a crime why did he attempt to conceal his identity?" I did not say that he thought he was doing something entirely legal, I said that he probably only expected a civil case for his actions, which is entirely reasonable. If I had to guess, I would say that whatever attempt he made to conceal his identity was done to ensure that he would not face a court order to stop until he had finished what he had set out to do. If you are saying that concealing one's identity is evidence that a person is doing something criminal, then you are accusing a good friend of mine of being a criminal. He used proxy servers to download large numbers of patents, as part of his masters thesis project, to avoid bandwidth restrictions imposed by servers. In the end, he developed a system that helps locate patents, and could help people avoid violating patents or find prior art. Should he face a 50 year sentence too? "If he had been accessing student's personal info, would you still be defending him?" He did nothing even remotely similar to that. His actions were as close to accessing private information as posting to HN. "Unauthorized access is unauthorized access." His accessing was not unauthorized. MIT's network is open to the public, and JSTOR's archive is open to anyone on MIT's network. What access was unauthorized in this case?
- fusiongyro 14y agoI have two responses. The first one is that if someone is suicidal and they commit a crime, you can't decide not to prosecute them simply because they may kill themselves. Our community might be certain that his suicide was a result of the prosecution, and there may or may not be evidence of that, but all things being equal, simply being suicidal cannot be a get-out-of-jail-free card. The second response is that these people are lawyers. They're not going to openly admit to having done wrong even if it's obvious because it will only make their punishment that much swifter. Statements like the above are publicly made until it becomes clear that an act of contrition will reduce the penalty. That isn't obvious to Ortiz or her department right now, so there's no reason to expect them to attempt to publicly admit wrongdoing. Note that this would be true even if Ortiz actually were wracked with guilt. These people are lawyers.
- darkarmani 14y agoSo what you are saying is that she is waiting for the plea bargain?
- DanBC 14y ago> The first one is that if someone is suicidal and they commit a crime, you can't decide not to prosecute them simply because they may kill themselves. When a suicidal criminal is caught you do need to prosecute them. That means that you need to keep them alive to be able to prosecute them. Justice is not served when suspects kill themselves. We still don't know whether what he did was a crime or not. When no person is harmed, and there has been no physical damage, (but with some kind of monetary loss due to shutting off a connection) it's absurd to suggest that 35 / 50 years in prison is a suitable punishment. It's absurd to suggest that any time in prison is a suitable punishment. Note that this applies even if the suspect is not suicidal. Using these kind of plea-bargaining tactics when you know the suspect is suicidal is cruel.
- fusiongyro 14y agoIt's not the prosecutor's job to decide if the law is just or if the punishment is commensurate. The prosecutor's job is to prosecute. Unfortunately, a primary tool in that job seems to be plea-bargaining. I hope that some change in the way plea-bargaining is used comes from this tragedy, but it's disingenuous to get upset when that reform fails to arise from the very people who rely on abusing that tool to do their job and who in principle have no particular say in how the law is written or interpreted.
- oh_sigh 14y agoAh, so I guess it has been proven that Aaron committed suicide because of the prosecution. He didn't commit suicide because he was, you know, chronically depressed for years. Obviously, people who are chronically depressed for years but are in great life circumstances never kill themselves(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Foster_Wallace http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Foster_Wallace)
- nemo 14y agoFor the record, DFW wasn't in great life circumstances when he committed suicide. He'd switched his antidepressants that worked but had horrible side effects to another med which didn't work for depression and he fell in deep. When he switched back to the original meds. they no longer worked which left him feeling utterly hopeless in his depression.
- oh_sigh 14y agoI meant that his external circumstances were positive: He was a critically acclaimed author, he had a loving wife, he was financially secure.
- cschmidt 14y ago"It may lead to the U.S. attorney’s office looking at each case on its own merits." What a concept: prosecuting each case on its own merits.
- EvilLook 14y agoYes, well, if it's one thing that we've learned it's that the American legal system is wholly incapable of learning from its mistakes. It takes the action of the legislative, executive, or higher judicial bodies to actually change things.
- visarga 14y agoPlea bargaining has been here for many years. As bad as it can get, it is the default operating mode. Trumping up accusations in order to scare the defendant is a negotiation tactic that comes in package with it. So what can we do ? Is it a good idea to ban plea bargaining? I read that 90% of law suits end in plea bargaining, so, banning this avenue would DDOS the legal system. Justice being the best your money can buy - it's a sad reality. They can charge an innocent and he would have to spend all he has to prove he is not guilty. How can we stop that? Maybe we need more lawyerless law suits, like those from Small Claims Court, to even the playing field. If only we could get rid of mandatory minimums and put common sense back in the driving chair, it would be much better. Mandatory minimums are one of those thought free zones of US, together with the war on drugs, war on terror and "won't anyone think of the children?". I believe we need more common sense and ethic into our justice and less automatic rubber stamping of convictions.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jacquesm 14y ago> so, banning this avenue would DDOS the legal system. It is the reverse. If you have too many cases to deal with because of absurd legislation that criminalizes a large portion of your population then you are already DDOS'ing your legal system. The 'lets try to route all requests straight to jail' option is not a solution for this problem. The DDOS is cause, not effect, and it is the laws that cause the DDOS, not the fact that people have (in theory apparently) a right to a fair trial.
- EvilLook 14y ago>I read that 90% of law suits end in plea bargaining Then you don't understand what a plea bargain is. Plea bargains are used only in criminal cases. You may have heard that 90% of lawsuits are settled before they go to court but that has nothing to do with what a plea bargain is. >Trumping up accusations in order to scare the defendant is a negotiation tactic that comes in package with it. No, trumping up accusations is grandstanding. It is neither necessary nor wise if you have a plea bargain system in place. Yes, you can tell the defendant what the possible maximum sentence is, but that doesn't mean you have to grandstand and press conference the result for the rest of the world's consumption. >They can charge an innocent and he would have to spend all he has to prove he is not guilty. How can we stop that? Talk to Kevin Mitnick and Bernie S about this... >If only we could get rid of mandatory minimums and put common sense back in the driving chair, it would be much better. This I agree with. The entire purpose of having a judge involved in sentencing was to make sure that each case was judged on its own merits. Mandatory minimums castrate the judicial system and give too much control to a legislature that is largely bought and paid for by the military/prison/school/election/industrial complex.
- darklajid 14y agoWell.. Can she say something else? I mean - wouldn't any statement remotely similar to "In light of the recent events we will think about our approach and adapt our methods" basically admit guilt and having been wrong before? In other words: Is this surprising, in any way?
- wheelerwj 14y agoWe are deeply distraught over the outcome of this case. We will be examining our procedures to ensure that we acted correctly. Our duty to the American people is to uphold justice for defendants as well as accusers. Mr. Swartz's death leaves us having unfulfilled our obligation to both Mr. Swartz and the American people and was not the intention of this office.
- driverdan 14y agoWith Ortiz's political aspirations this seems like the worst response she could possibly make. It seems to me that the public would respond better to something like "we'll review our practices to ensure we're best serving the public." They could then just sweep it under the rug and wait for the public to forget. If it came up again they could then they could issue a statement along the lines of this one.
- wheelerwj 14y agoThat was my thought process. But she obviously thinks so highly of herself that she can stand up to the American public and defend her position, even though things obviously went sideways. This is not someone we want in a higher office.
- lkbm 14y agoWait, because she stands by principals rather than the whims of the public, we DON'T want her in office? 9/11 happens: people panic and demand action. School shooting happens: people panic and demand action. I want a leader who DOESN'T succumb to the panic.
- myko 14y agoIn the second case I don't see it so much as people panicking and demanding action; more like people saying "I told you so, now will you do something about this?" But anyway, yeah I'd like my public officials to recognize when they are wrong and to adjust their behavior. If her principles make her bully defendants and she wont adjust, yeah, I don't want her in office.
- sp332 14y agoThe people saying "I told you so" are wrong. School shootings hardly ever happen, maybe 3-4 times per year in the whole nation. There's statistically no way to tell if they're going up or down; it's just noise.
- marssaxman 14y agoOf course not - that would be an admission that they did it wrong.
- wheelerwj 14y agoHow can they not admit they are wrong? A MAN DIED. something went wrong.
- jlgreco 14y agoThey are lawyers. To them, unlike normal empathetic humans, admitting guilt is not seen as a nice gesture and part of making amends, but rather just something you do if you are foolish.
- oh_sigh 14y agoChronically depressed people commit suicide frequently. I'd be interested in hearing your evidence that Aaron killed himself because of his prosecution, besides from the mere coincidence of the two events.
- thoughtcriminal 14y agoWhat a rediculous thing to say. We're past 1+1=2 now. We've moved on to greater things. Try and keep up please.
- oh_sigh 14y agoGreat rebuttal. Filled with reason. A+. Great job keeping up
- jlgreco 14y agoWhat you have asked for as been discussed at considerable length already. If you want to read that discussion, use the search field at the bottom to get started. There is no sense in having that same conversation for the hundredth time.
- WalterSear 14y agoWhatever you say, "Baghdad" Ortiz. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muhammad_Saeed_al-Sahhaf#During_the_Iraq_war http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muhammad_Saeed_al-Sahhaf#During...
- ChristianMarks 14y agoNot only won't they admit wrong doing, but they will encourage suicides wherever possible.
- tomjen3 14y agoOf course not. Psychopaths don't care about what happens to others, only to themselves.
- olefoo 14y agoIf you haven't already. Today is a very good day to write your Representative http://www.house.gov/representatives/find/ http://www.house.gov/representatives/find/ And your Senators http://www.senate.gov/general/contact_information/senators_cfm.cfm http://www.senate.gov/general/contact_information/senators_c... And ask them why this person is allowed to wield the full might and power of the US Government. If you want to ensure that this gets attention it's a matter of sustained pressure, and of getting both houses of Congress to ask the embarrassing and obvious questions of the Justice department.
- cobrausn 14y agoWell, there has been some push from at least one Senator (John Cornyn, R-TX). He does appear to be asking some embarrassing and obvious questions. http://www.cornyn.senate.gov/public/index.cfm?p=InNews&ContentRecord_id=b026c108-ff4c-4ff9-a771-7307c72e14c5&ContentType_id=b94acc28-404a-4fc6-b143-a9e15bf92da4&f6c645c7-9e4a-4947-8464-a94cacb4ca65&Group_id=bf378025-1557-49c1-8f08-c5df1c4313a4&MonthDisplay=1&YearDisplay=2013 http://www.cornyn.senate.gov/public/index.cfm?p=InNews&C...
- olefoo 14y agoYes. However to be really effective the questions need to be coming from both sides of the aisle and from all over the country. That will only happen if you, yes you, reading this; go to your representatives and write, call, and send snail mail. This is not a partisan issue, it cuts straight to the core of our system of government; when prosecutors misuse their position for political purposes it undermines our system of government and eats at the legitimacy of our institutions. It's bad when done by Republicans like http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leura_Canary http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leura_Canary and equally bad when done by Democrats like Ms. Ortiz.
- keithpeter 14y ago"That will only happen if you, yes you, reading this; go to your representatives and write, call, and send snail mail." Any role for foreigners? Which body to make a modest monetary donation to? UK perspective: Trespass + Computer Misuse Act Section 1, so we are talking 6 months/£2000 if it ever went to court, which it probably would not have.
- lsiebert 14y agoCongress critter is from MeFi, I Believe.
- ck2 14y agoI am suddenly understanding the phrase "Don't make a federal case out of it!"
- malandrew 14y agoPersonally, I'd love for Congress to permit the publication of all correspondence done by the prosecution in this case. I want to know what was written and discussed among the prosecutors (Ortiz, Heynman and others in that office) and everyone else involved with this case (Secret Service). I think the Internet will do a much better job of investigating prosecutorial misconduct than any internal investigation could uncover. Once someone assumes a public office they should assume they are now a public good working for the betterment of the society that appointed them. One of the rights, we the people, should have, is the ability to provide direct oversight; maybe not in real time, but at least post hoc.
- nonamegiven 14y ago"I'd love for Congress to permit the publication of all correspondence done by the prosecution in this case." Similar things have happened, although not always with the government's enthusiastic cooperation: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Pentagon_Papers#Leak https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Pentagon_Papers#Leak
- FireBeyond 14y agoThis is bringing the worst out of HN. In this thread alone, I've read people claiming that it's unequivocal fact that Swartz committed suicide because of his prosecution, because his lawyer said so, but that we can't trust a single word out of Ortiz's mouth... because she's a lawyer. We have people claiming, in specific terms, that the US Attorneys as a whole have an interest in encouraging defendant's to commit suicide... This is hardly the first article to demonstrate this, and there are certainly many valid issues to be reviewed and discussed, but many commenters here are demonstrating that we're just as capable of turning into a lynch mob as anyone else.
- enraged_camel 14y ago>>We have people claiming, in specific terms, that the US Attorneys as a whole have an interest in encouraging defendant's to commit suicide... This is a strawman and nobody here has said it. The actual argument is that prosecutors have very strong incentives to put as much pressure as possible on defendants, and the latter most often cannot defend themselves because the process is so extraordinarily expensive. As a result, the defendant either has to settle for a plea bargain or lose the trial. Unfortunately, many times they take the third option, which is suicide. Make no mistake: this isn't about Ortiz. This is a systemic problem.
- jack-r-abbit 14y ago>>>>We have people claiming, in specific terms, that the US Attorneys as a whole have an interest in encouraging defendant's to commit suicide... >>This is a strawman and nobody here has said it. Well... http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5092900 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5092900
- enraged_camel 14y agoI think you are taking that comment out of context.
- jack-r-abbit 14y ago
- ericjeepn 14y ago"Many remark justice is blind; pity those in her sway, shocked to discover she is also deaf." ~DAVID MAMET, Faustus
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- popee 14y agoWhat is her mission?
- rdl 14y agoI don't think the suicide itself should change how cases are handled, but the revelations about how inherently wrong the prosecution of Swartz was, should change how cases are handled. You absolutely don't want other cases or issues to be advanced through people killing themselves, or threats of suicide. You also don't want non-violent civil disobedience hacking to face $1.5mm in legal costs, $1mm in fines, and 13 felony counts and multiple years in prison, particularly when the injured party comes to a successful private resolution with the offender. Also, the cases in the future should not be handled by USA Ortiz of AUSA Heymann, who should no longer be involved in the practice of law, particularly not as employees and representatives of the people of the United States.
- arbuge 14y agoPrecisely why she, and all prosecutors like her, need to go. They can't change - indeed, they can't find or admit fault with their unjust methods.
- aswanson 14y agoThere is a non-trivial proportion of humanity that simply cannot change their mind, cannot admit when they are wrong. If you think long enough about it and follow a rule-based mindset absent objective feedback (as fields such as law allow), you can justify almost any action taken ad-infinitum, as long as you follow a rule book and pattern you have practiced for years. That said, mentally inagile, cognitive calcified people should be culled from our justice system ruthlessly. We need people who can think through proportion, harm, and justice on a dynamic basis.
- jijji 14y agoShe should be disbarred for ethics violations.
- philprx 14y agoAdding insult to injury. Wow... nice, Department of _Justice_. Do that apply to justice to the dead to respect their memory?
- linuxhansl 14y agoShe's toast and she knows it. She's trying to save her political career. It doesn't even matter anymore whether she's right or wrong. Personally I feel that she mishandled this case (and that the whole system is pretty messed up), but the truth is somewhere between the two positions we keep hearing.
- wisty 14y agoI wish more people were pissed off at plea bargaining. Yes, I know people think, the US needs it. But there's plenty of countries without plea bargaining (or at least, with a greatly reduced plea bargaining system). IMO, it should simply result in a reduced sentence, at the discretion of the judge (as evidence of remorse, not a reward for making the court's job easier). The government doesn't threaten you with a bigger sentence if you refuse to be unconstitutionally searched (if you tell the cops to come back if they get a warrant). You don't get a smaller sentence for waiving your right to a silence, or counsel. But you do get a smaller sentence for waiving a right to a fair trial. I can't really see how this is constitutional, but being forced to waive other rights isn't. Yes, things would be easier if criminals were coerced (by the threat of a larger sentence) to let the police search them without a warrant, to answer everything the police asked, to not to lawyer up, and to confess their guilt without a trial. But it's not the way a free country works. And you are punished with stiffer sentences. If criminals are getting off lightly (due to plea bargaining), then politicians will raise sentences. This means people who do nothing more than demand a fair trial will receive stiffer punishments than they deserve. I can't see how a lack of fair trials serves justice either. It encourages lazy police work. And an unfair process turns people against the system. If people accept plea bargains, do they really see themselves a guilty, or simply persecuted by "the system"?
- josephlord 14y agoI largely agree with you though some sentence reduction for making the court's life easier, avoiding the cost (emotional, time and financial) to witnesses (including the victim) is appropriate it is a question of the magnitude. 10x sentence difference is undue pressure that is enough to make the innocent plead guilty (or worse). An expectation of 30%-50% sentence for pleading early is a significant reduction but not in most cases enough to make an innocent person plead guilty unless it crosses a threshold that allows a suspended sentence or community punishment (in which case the magnitude of any improper conviction is relatively low). I'm in the UK were there is talk of cautiously introducing some form of plea bargaining. At the moment I think pleading guilty (and how early it is done) is just something taken into by the judge. There may be some deals on the charges brought when there is some discretion but I don't think the opportunities are that great.
- fooooobar 14y agoI'd say she's a more dickless version of Bill O'Reilly, but after seeing her picture I'm not sure that's true...