4 ms·
The Wikipedia page on the 774-774 C14 spike even mentions that there might be an eye-witness account of a "red cross" in the sky: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/
by arethuza 14y ago
The Wikipedia page on the 774-774 C14 spike even mentions that there might be an eye-witness account of a "red cross" in the sky:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/774%E2%80%93775_radiation_burst http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/774%E2%80%93775_radiation_burst
- defrost 14y agoWhat that article tells us is that there was a 1.2% spike in Carbon-14 in 774 in Japan. What it doesn't tell us is if that spike was local to Japan, to the Northern Hemisphere, or was a global spike. There are three possible reasons for an increase in Carbon-14 (and combinations thereof); more Carbon in the upper atmosphere (either local to the cell above Japan or more extensive), a loop in the Earth's geomagnetic field increasing the amount of cosmic rays interacting with Carbon (with no change in external cosmic ray levels), or an increase in the external cosmic rays striking the Earth (with various possible extra terrestrial causes). More data and a better understanding of the Carbon cycle are needed to move beyond speculation.
- youngerdryas 14y agoFrom the article: In Antarctica, too, there was a spike in levels of a form of beryllium - beryllium-10 - in the ice. These isotopes are created when intense radiation hits the atoms in the upper atmosphere, suggesting that a blast of energy had once hit our planet from space. Using tree rings and ice-core data, researchers were able to pinpoint that this would have occurred between the years AD 774 and AD 775, but the cause of the event was a puzzle.
- defrost 14y agoThere are several articles in play here, the OP BBC News article, the wikipedia article (linked by the person I replied to and the one to which I referred) and the primary source papers about Carbon in Japan and Beryllium in Antartica. My points stand, increased external cosmic rays (for whatever reason, flares / nova / etc.) are not the only explanation for relatively low spikes in isotopes.
- youngerdryas 14y agoFrom the article at the bottom of the Wiki: When the scientists checked the carbon-14 levels in the cedar tree rings, though, they noticed something strange: a spike in carbon-14 corresponding to the years 774 and 775 AD. It's normal for carbon-14 concentrations to vary a little bit from year to year, but the normal variation is just five-hundredths of a percent. During 774 and 775, the levels jumped by more than 1 percent -- a dramatic leap. What kind of event would have showered Earth in the kind of radiation necessary to make so much carbon-14? Could a supernova do it? Supernovas do sizzle with gamma rays, which can produce carbon-14 in the atmosphere. Yet even the supernovas that happened in 1006 and 1054 AD -- which, unlike the 774 event, were dramatic enough to catch the eyes of ancient astronomers -- weren't big enough to leave a carbon-14 fingerprint in tree rings. If it was a supernova, it would have to be a strange one: the Invisible Man of supernovas, incredibly powerful yet unseen. Indeed, astronomers can still see remnants of the 1006 and 1054 supernovas today. If a bright supernova occurred in 774, we should see a correspondingly glaring source of X-rays and radio waves somewhere nearby -- but we don't. Could our own sun be the culprit? Solar flares douse the atmosphere in high-energy protons, which can also produce carbon-14. But a solar flare capable of making enough carbon-14 to explain the tree rings would be bigger than any solar flare ever recorded, say the scientists. Though it is not beyond the imagination that our sun could have belched out such a "super flare," someone on Earth would surely have noticed and made a record of the resulting auroras, which would be unlike anything ever seen before. And if the auroras weren't worth writing home about, surely the mass extinction would be, as it's likely that the flare would destroy the Earth's protective ozone layer. Not everyone is convinced that we should rule out the solar flare option, though. Maybe conditions were just right for a ho-hum flare to create a surge of extremely high energy protons. Or maybe, instead of just one flare, the sun let loose a series of smaller ones over a period of years. Whatever happened, there are hints that it was a global phenomenon, not a local one. Carbon-14 levels in trees from North America and Europe were elevated around that time, too. All the way in Antarctica, layers of snow and ice were laced with traces of another isotope made by cosmic rays, beryllium-10. Though it's difficult to put a precise date on the sudden peak in beryllium-10, it seems to have occurred around the same time as the carbon-14 spike.
- 14y ago