5 ms·
I've said this before -- don't bother being a "white hat". The industry and the legal system doesn't have a pigeon hole for that. You'll be labeled as "hacker"
by rdtsc 14y ago
I've said this before -- don't bother being a "white hat".
The industry and the legal system doesn't have a pigeon hole for that. You'll be labeled as "hacker" (and not in a positive sense of it). Either disclose the vulnerability immediately to get recognition, hoping it is public enough they'll be ashamed of going after you, or or sell and profit from it. You are already treated as a criminal by these large institutions, so if you go in that direction might as well make some money.
- guard-of-terra 14y agoYou can also pastebin it. That's what you should do.
- eru 14y agoPerhaps from a tor connection?
- Tichy 14y agoHow do new pastebins get discovered? I've never used the service - was assuming someone should post the link to the pastebin on Reddit?
- guard-of-terra 14y agoYes, someone should. You can imagine some fun ways of doing so.
- jlgreco 14y agoYeah, Tor->Reddit should work. Alternatively you could fire off some emails to a couple high-ish profile twitter accounts of people/groups that would be interested in taking credit for it.
- gpcz 14y agoDuring undergrad I discovered the university's blackboard-like site sent plaintext passwords over http, and the majority of its use was over wireless. I went to the IT office responsible for the site, told them about it, and refused to give my name when they asked. After reading some of the horror stories on this page, I feel really lucky that the IT department didn't go further to figure out who I was and get me in trouble. End result was that quickly afterward their site forced https on you...
- guard-of-terra 14y agoThe fact that they went https tells us you would probably be okay. People who go after security bug reporters tend to never fix the bugs in question. They're, like, too righteous for it.
- jlgreco 14y agoProbably, but not necessarily. They could easily harass you saying that the cost of such an upgrade (probably actually measurable only in the effort of some salaried employee..) are damages that you caused. edit: see the $800k 'damages' Gary McKinnon allegedly caused. It's not like he smashed their equipment with a sledgehammer or something.
- rohansingh 14y agoMan. I found an XSS bug in the University of Washington's web portal several years ago. It would allow a hacker to impersonate any user if they clicked on a crafted hyperlink. After testing this on my own account, I reported it right away to the university. They thanked me and fixed the problem within days. But after reading these horror stories, I feel extremely lucky that they didn't do something much stupider. My entire academic career could have been destroyed, as well as my professional one if they'd decided to press frivolous charges.
- VMG 14y ago> You are already treated as a criminal by these large institutions, so if you go in that direction might as well make some money. In the second scenario, you probably are hurting innocent people. So if you have a moral compass, you should maybe bother being an anonymous white hat.
- lclarkmichalek 14y agoBeing anonymous isn't always easy unfortunately
- rwallace 14y agoThe one does not imply the other. Becoming a criminal is a bad idea (and rtdsc probably knows this and was engaging in hyperbole out of justified frustration), but becoming a martyr is also a bad idea. If you find a security flaw in a system you don't own, the best course of action is to ignore it and get on with your life. This is something every bright young hacker needs to be made aware of.
- sliverstorm 14y agoMaybe on your own, but if you manage to brand yourself as a consultant or get hired explicitly as a white hat, you can do it. Good example would be penetration testers.
- dagw 14y agoI'd revise that to don't be a hobbyist "white hat". If you want to do white hat hacking either get yourself hired by a serious security outfit or set yourself up as a company doing security consulting. On the whole people are far less likely to go after a genuine security company as opposed to 'just some kid in a basement'.
- jiggy2011 14y agoTrue, but then sites who are cavalier about security are unlikely to be the ones who think of hiring professional pen-testers.
- twentysix 14y agoIts certainly a grey area and covering all your bases legally before embarking on a penetration test would be good idea. Even with all the legal formalities, there needs to be a good level of trust between the client and the auditor for things to go smoothly. Two days later, Mr. Al-Khabaz decided to run a software program called Acunetix, designed to test for vulnerabilities in websites, to ensure that the issues he and Mija had identified had been corrected. If you find a security flaw in a system and report it, receiving positive feedback doesn't automatically imply that you have permission to conduct further tests. A web application vulnerability scanner can cause damage to production systems. Almost anyone can just download a scanner and run a wild test using default settings. But its illegal to do it without prior authorization. While his intentions were good, I think it was a bit naive of him to take upon himself the responsibility to make sure the flaws were fixed and conduct a test. Even when you have permission to conduct a test you stick to the scope and limits of the agreement. You cant just keep leapfrogging networks as you find holes. Manually finding holes/bugs accidentally and reporting them is different from running a vulnerability scanner. I dont think he should have been expelled without giving a chance to explain his story and the way they did it was not ethical. The management over reacted, especially considering there was no damages mentioned in this case. http://testlab.sit.fraunhofer.de/downloads/Publications/tuerpe_eichler_Testing_production_systems_safely_-_Common_precautions_in_penetration_testing_TAIC_PART_2009.pdf http://testlab.sit.fraunhofer.de/downloads/Publications/tuer... http://www.coresecurity.com/content/under-attack http://www.coresecurity.com/content/under-attack https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Randal_L._Schwartz#Intel_case https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Randal_L._Schwartz#Intel_case
- kibwen 14y ago> While his intentions were good, I think it was a bit > naive of him to take upon himself the responsibility to > make sure the flaws were fixed and conduct a test. Given that his own personal information could have been exposed by this exploit, it's just as likely that he was acting out of self-preservation rather than merely due to feelings of personal responsibility. The only naive bit here is that he obliterated his plausible deniability via 1) not allowing more time between submitting the report and attempting the scan, and 2) not masking his IP behind seven proxies.
- 14y ago
- emp_ 14y agoAgreed, when SQL Injections in ASP were all the rage some 10 years ago I contacted a couple dozen companies to inform of their full credit card visible customer admin pages and asked for nothing in return (at that time someone was offered money to help fix a security breach and was arrested for blackmail -- the employee that offered the money for services was actually the police speaking to him, so that saved my ass too) and I got a ton of threats, only one company actually gave me a number to call and thanked me but when I asked for a postcard of their city he got really pissed. Good times.