4 ms·
This is such a bizarre, vague, and non-sensical claim that it's impossible to know what to make of it. 1. Under what circumstances does Wikileaks ever find it
by danso 14y ago
This is such a bizarre, vague, and non-sensical claim that it's impossible to know what to make of it.
1. Under what circumstances does Wikileaks ever find it necessary to reveal a source? Or in this case, to say "maybe he was a source, maybe he wasn't, we're just putting it out there"?
2. He assisted Wikileaks...how? In a way different than being a source?
3. He communicated with Julian Assange...how? About what? about secret stuff? Complimenting each other? Trading recipes?
If this was an attempt to help Aaron's cause, it seems very misguided...Aaron really doesn't need the association with Wikileaks, especially as his supporters attempt to portray his work as benign and altruistic. If this is just a naked cry for attention, well, that's just sad. There are probably other ways of getting attention than to violate one of your most important precepts (the anonymity of your sources) with a vague tease.
- noibl 14y ago> especially as his supporters attempt to portray his work as benign and altruistic. Are you implying some kind of contrast?
- danso 14y agoI think Wikileaks would see its work as altruistic. I would say that they do not see their work as "benign" (nor should they, necessarily). But the problem with anonymity is that you never know what the leakers' motives are...and that is a tradeoff Wikileaks has to make. In Aaron's case, though, I don't think he ever obfuscated his motives (even as he tried to do the downloading in secret) in his actions.
- noibl 14y agoSo... you are implying a contrast or not?
- danso 14y agoHuh? Instead of asking me as if my speculation meant anything, why don't you ask the many publicly available confidantes of Aaron about why they haven't yet tied Aaron's JSTOR cause to Wikileaks?
- noibl 14y agoWait a minute. Your claim is this: 'Aaron really doesn't need the association with Wikileaks'. In support, you offer only 'especially as his supporters attempt to portray his work as benign and altruistic'. I'm trying to understand how this supports the claim. It would seem it could only do so if Swartz's actions were somehow in contrast to Wikileaks in the context of those terms. Yet you refuse to say whether you think Wikileaks' work is either benign or altruistic. Your opinion of how Wikileaks would characterise itself is of no benefit in understanding the basis of your claim. And now, instead of answering a straightforward binary question about a claim you did make, you want me to go and ask a whole bunch of other people about claims they didn't make? I understand less and less.
- danso 14y agosigh I'm not clear on what you're not clear on, but I'll be a good sport and take the bait. I assert that the altruism of Aaron Swartz stands in contrast with that of Wikileaks because the latter, being an anonymous organization that filters anonymously-submitted information, cannot be automatically assumed to have an altruistic motive regarding the information that it disseminates. Not because they're evil. But because we just can't know. Contrast this with Aaron and the many public statements he's made about freeing information and how it would help the world and what he gains (or rather, doesn't gain) from it. You don't have to agree that this makes him altruistic, you just have to see that there's a difference between a guy whose altruistic claims we can concretely evaluate and an organization that we just have to trust. Here's a good example: Whatever happened to all that supposed dirt on Bank of America that Wikileaks had? Not only do we not know the source (it could be someone working for Chase Bank who used to be at BoA and has an interest in destroying his former employer), but it suddenly got wiped out by a disgruntled Wikileaks officer?..but that's something we have to take on faith, that it was a careless, irreversible act and not something done out of some other ulterior motive. http://www.reuters.com/article/2011/08/22/us-bankofamerica-wikileaks-idUSTRE77L55P20110822 http://www.reuters.com/article/2011/08/22/us-bankofamerica-w... As for being benign...Well, let's tally up the score. Wikileaks' most famous alleged collaborator is in a military prison and likely faces a terrible fate for the information he disseminated. The information that Aaron disseminated, meanwhile, was not as critical...to the point that JSTOR decided not to pursue charges. Aaron's problem was that the prosecutor wouldn't let go of the actual act of hacking, which is the primary cause of outrage. So that's the issue here. Aaron and Wikileaks may have been friends and like-minded. But they had necessarily different paths.
- rdtsc 14y ago> you never know what the leakers' motives you don't know anybody's motives, you know only what you are told the motives are (which might not be true), or you see their actions (and you interpret it they way you want to interpret it)
- danso 14y agoSo...given: a) A known person who has stated what he believes in and why he does things b) An organization of unknown individuals, who has stated what it believes, acting on behalf of another unknown individual(s) You're saying we're in the same epistemological black hole when it comes to evaluating the intentions and consequences-suffered by a) and b)? If so, then OK, that's a philosophical debate that would be really fascinating to discuss on some other day, but pretty much underscores why we won't agree on much in this thread.
- mc32 14y agoI think he meant that not knowing the leaker's identity meant one can't construct/examine what someone's motives might be. He didn't say anything about (believing) a leaker's claims.
- anonymouz 14y agoI don't think any charges have ever been brought against Wikileaks. What they are doing seems 100% benign to me. The individual whistle-blowers that send information to them may get in trouble with the law, but Wikileaks itself only curates and distributes the information given to them. On the other hand it is pretty clear that Aaron Schwarz did break the law, only the severity of the crimes is in dispute.
- analog 14y agoHe broke a website's TOS, it's not at all clear that he broke the law imo.
- anonymouz 14y agoDon't get hung up on the JSTOR ToS. I think the more serious charges are the ones related to him obtaining access to MIT's network despite the fact that it was clear to him that he was not welcome, and circumventing measures that prevented him from connecting in the process. Not exactly a capital offense, but an offense nonetheless.
- analog 14y ago"despite the fact that it was clear to him that he was not welcome" Well this is the bit that's unclear, MIT has an open network. Is changing your MAC address to stay on illegal? Another TOS violation in my opinion, either that or we're all guilty of federal offences.
- anonymouz 14y agoPlease, this has been rehashed hundreds of times here already: Just because they decide to be nice and have their network open by default to anyone does not mean they can't revoke someones authorization and kick him out if he does not behave well on their network. Changing a MAC address by itself is not illegal. Doing so in order to gain access to a network which he is no longer authorized to access is. He was in an arms race, circumventing ever stronger countermeasures against him. He went much further than changing his MAC address, and he was obviously aware of the fact that he was no longer welcome.
- ratsbane 14y agoIt could also be an effort to divert attention from some other Wikileaks source.
- analog 14y agoOk, if you believe that Wikileaks are lying then your complaint is valid. If they're telling the truth however then this raises disturbing questions about why he was targeted by the DoJ.
- danso 14y agoI didn't say that Wikileaks is lying. I'm saying I don't know what the hell they're talking about because what they said could literally mean anything. And to provide no elaboration is just as bad as posting the question-headline, "Is the Government covering up Aaron Swartz's UFO abduction?"
- analog 14y agoTheir 3 points seem fairly clear to me. I'd assume assistance would be some kind of technical help? Being in communication with Assange is also pretty clear, and the third point is necessarily vague. Did you want to see the commits and email logs? I think the point they're making is that if Wikileaks were aware of these (possible) facts then other actors could be too.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- danso 14y agoI can think of at least a one time when the Wikileaks lied to serve its own purpose: http://www.cnn.com/2012/07/30/tech/web/fake-nyt-editorial/index.html http://www.cnn.com/2012/07/30/tech/web/fake-nyt-editorial/in... And before you say, "Well, the New York Times deserved it"...that's not what the argument is about. The argument is: will Wikileaks publish a lie if it believes that the ends justify the means? The answer is "yes". So until they show actual evidence in this case, I don't think they should be given the benefit of the doubt just because they're Wikileaks. I'm curious to what more harm could be done to Aaron besides, well, him already being dead, and also, the innuendo generated by Wikileaks' teaser tweets.
- 14y ago
- trevelyan 14y agoThe implication is that the severity of prosecutorial treatment and/or the other investigative activities to which Aaron was subject, which may have contributed to his depression and of which we may not be aware was related to his association with the journal. Wikileaks' interest is in clearly in ensuring any investigation does not sweep activities it suspects and we may not under the rug.
- danso 14y agoThe timeline asserted by the Wikileaks's #2 statement, "Aaron Swartz was in communication with Julian Assange, including during 2010 and 2011," implies that Aaron tried to collaborate with someone who was in massive legal trouble himself at a time when, by all accounts, Aaron was freaked out about the impending charges he faced. That would seem especially reckless of Aaron.
- analog 14y agoA lot of things he did could be seen as reckless, or brave depending on your viewpoint.
- rdtsc 14y ago> In a way different than being a source? Yes. Most likely. Remember Aaron was also a developer and doubt he had access clearance to have access to embarrassing classified materials. I don't see why that's not the first guess. > 3. He communicated with Julian Assange...how? About what? about secret stuff? Probably about secret stuff. > Trading recipes? So? Funny enough, I am 100% that is enough to put him on a black list of some sort in the DHS. > Aaron really doesn't need the association with Wikileaks Unless of course he was friends with wikileaks supporters and developers and then we got danso here telling who Aaron's friends should and should not have been.
- danso 14y agoWell yes, I guess that in a tragic death that was sparked in part by too many people blindly accepting the vague assertions made by one organization, it's hard not to be cynical of yet another organization making vague assertions related to that tragic death. Call me jaded.
- neumann_alfred 14y agoYou can't really answer those questions for Wikileaks, so why even pretend you can.