5 ms·
The problem is, it isn't about money. The government has all the money it needs, the government can print money if it needs to.[1] The problem is that all these
by jerf 14y ago
The problem is, it isn't about money. The government has all the money it needs, the government can print money if it needs to.[1] The problem is that all these old people will need goods and services, and no amount of legerdemain with mere money can get around the fact that those goods and services must actually be produced, and the people producing those goods and services are therefore not producing other goods and services.
When you hear that statistic about two workers per retiree or whatever, don't just be thinking about money; that's the output of those two workers putatively going to support the retiree, and what's leftover going to power the economy.
As convenient as it can be to analyze problems in terms of money in normal life, when it gets to these really big "structure of society" problems the abstraction starts to get in your way again. Many of the characteristics of money are downright deceptive; one may save $100 today, but $100 of, say, corn today is not going to feed any retirees 20 years from now, it'll just be a rotted mess. Goods and services store poorly; they need to be matched up producer/consumer in something more like real time. Money is a great abstraction over that, but a still a secondary phenomenon compared to that real-time match up.
Of course, we can indeed support quite a few retirees... if one adjusts their standard of living down a long way. If it's OK for them to dial 911 and for nothing to happen, we've got more than enough wealth to support all kinds of retirees. Start specifying out a "good" first-world life style, though, and it becomes problematic again.
The problem is not, in absolute terms, a "lack of money"; the problem is that we've made promises about the quality of the retired life that are going to be very difficult to keep with small single-digit numbers of goods and service providers, while at the same time having enough of a productive economy to produce the wealth that will make it possible to keep those promises. Money is a very poor lens to analyze this problem through.
(Personally I don't believe the problem to be as hopeless as it seems, as there are still some avenues for significant per-worker productivity enhancements, mostly in terms of significant improvements in robotics. However, it must be observed that with our current set of promises, we 20-, 30-, and probably even 40-year olds are effectively all-in with our retirements on that hope, because if tech were to stagnate at current levels the current set of promises is probably mathematically infeasible.)
[1]: I'm not saying this is good or desirable, btw, it's just part of my point about this not being about money.
- dasil003 14y agoBut tons of people are unemployed and we are not suffering any shortage of goods or services, so I don't understand how structural issues are applicable to this problem. Are you saying that if everyone magically got their social security checks regardless of government insolvency that the economy would not be able to support that additional purchasing power?
- jerf 14y agoWhat I'm saying is, money doesn't matter if we make promises to retirees that require three workers per retiree to fulfill and only two workers per retiree physically exist. No matter how much money you throw at the problem, retirees can not draw on more resources than physically exist. And you have to leave enough left over for the rest of the economy, too; those two workers can't be 100% allocated to retirees, because they also need to eat, provide shelter for themselves, ideally provide for some sort of family so there's someone there to pay for their retirement, also pay taxes so there's still a government, etc, etc. Money can only choose from the possible set of economic allocations, not the impossible ones. And the higher-level point is just that when it comes to this sort of big "how shall we structure society?" questions, thinking in terms of money affords bad logic. In particular, people can't resist straight-line interpolations based on current prices, as if prices don't change and we have an infinite pool of resources to draw on at unchanging prices, so it's just a matter of scaring up enough money. That works in your day-to-day life, it's not how it works at a societal scale.
- Evbn 14y agoWith 9% unemployment and 15% of the population retired, it seems we have a good amount of labor available for servicing and goodsing retirees.
- dasil003 14y agoYou're just rephrasing your original post, but you're not offering any evidence of why you think the burden of retirees is going to be so overwhelming. Why are retirees going to require an "impossible allocation"? Seems to me if demand increases then prices go up. Sure it starts to break down at extreme cases, but why would a marginally increased body of retired people be such an event? We do not have a shortage of workers at all, and the trend is to produce more stuff with ever fewer workers.