5 ms·
Edward Tufte’s defense of Aaron Swartz and the “marvelously different”
- frabcus 14y agoAs well as Tufte, the video at the end of the post, where Taren Stinebrickner-Kauffman talks, is well worth listening to.
- danso 14y agoI hope someone takes the time to transcribe it...at the end of an already emotionally draining service, Taren still managed to bring out a collective, audible weeping in the packed auditorium. She was very aggressive on her calls to make sure the prosecuting attorneys face reproach. But interestingly, Carmen Ortiz was mostly mentioned in passing. Stephen Heymann by far was the target of Taren's anger.
- pygy_ 14y agohttps://petitions.whitehouse.gov/petition/fire-assistant-us-attorney-steve-heymann/RJKSY2nb https://petitions.whitehouse.gov/petition/fire-assistant-us-... The petition asking for Heymann firing still lacks 15.000 votes. From what I read he was more instrumental than Ortiz in the aggressiveness the prosecution. Not that the witch hunt is very useful in itself, but it keeps people involved and the more shit we stir, the most likely things will move.
- cristoperb 14y agoHere's a transcription of Taren's eulogy (consider it a rough draft -- I don't have time to check it carefully now): http://mretc.net/~cris/swartz-transcripts/taren-transcript.txt http://mretc.net/~cris/swartz-transcripts/taren-transcript.t... If anybody does read it along with the video, please feel free to send me any corrections (or change the txt file and send me a diff). Thanks!
- kragen 14y agoThank you, thank you, thank you. I'm crying too now.
- jacquesm 14y ago> And so I told Bill Bowen that he had a great opportunity here to not wreck somebody’s life. And of course he thankfully did the right thing. MIT take note please.
- Anechoic 14y ago(I know this will be an unpopular post, so I'll preface this by saying that Swartz's transgressions didn't warrant multiple years in prison and the whole situation is a tragedy.) MIT take note please. I think they have - in Tufte's anecdote he mentions that the AT&T security person asked "why we went off the air after about three months." The implication is that between the security guy's technical interest and the fact that Tufte wasn't hacking the phone system anymore, there was no real reason to go after him. In Swartz's case, after the first few time MIT/JSTOR detected his activity, all they did was to (try to) block Swartz's access to the system. If Swartz had given up, that may have been the end of it. There are parallels between Tufte and Swartz but there are also differences. (again, I am in no way saying that Swartz deserved a long prison sentence or he deserved to die.)
- jacquesm 14y agoThe major difference that sticks out for me in your comparison is that free access to long distance calls is optional but free access to knowledge is not. A second difference is that it seemed there was a dialogue going, a dialogue during which if a similar one had happened between MIT and Aaron, MIT might have found out they were about to destroy something precious. AT&T, that well-known bastion of freedom and openness could do that. MIT apparently could not. Finally I urge you to please watch Taren's video at the end of the linked article.
- legutierr 14y agoIt's worth noting that for most of the twentieth century AT&T was a driving force for scientific and engineering innovation in the US, greater than most universities (though perhaps not MIT). Researchers there won seven Nobel prizes, and two Turing awards. On a more mundane note, Unix was invented there, as well as C and C++, and the photovoltaic cell. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bell_Labs#Discoveries_and_developments http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bell_Labs#Discoveries_and_devel... None of these accomplishments would have been possible if AT&T didn't know how to coddle geniuses.
- kandahar 14y agoOh, another old counter-culture guy who egged on an impressionable kid. How sad that Aaron's attempt to strike a blow like those of his mentors was so squalid. Kids, I'll tell you since these heroes won't: if your "hack" involves picking locks, buying multiple computers to bypass a download limit, and violating terms of use, it's not a movement and it is not heroic. Don't let these lazy essayits lead you down this path. Find your own cause, and make it worthwhile.
- jacquesm 14y agoI have an extremely pointy and very heartfelt remark that I'd like to throw your way but (1) I am trying very hard through all this to not let my seething anger get the better of me and (2) it would (rightly) get my account banned so in the interest of better judgement I've only downvoted you.
- asswartz 14y agoWhy do you get so butthurt every time someone says something remotely negative about your hero?
- kandahar 14y agoI am angry too, but at the mentors who accepted the worship of a troubled young man and led him to this. Why don't you make your pointed comment and risk a ban? Please, I can take it and it would be refreshing to see instead of all this crap directed at law enforcement. And if you are not creeper out by some of Aaron's mentors fondly recalling his cuteness, you are not paying attention to what was going on there. And now his corpse is being repurposed for several agendas. I'll go first and welcome a ban: fuck that.
- jacquesm 14y ago> I am angry too, but at the mentors who accepted the worship of a troubled young man and led him to this. Those mentors are mentors because they treat people regardless of age as equals. Yes, Aaron had his troubles. But he wasn't guided by those mentors as much as that he was guiding them. There was more give-and-take there than you give credit for, you are reducing Aaron to the level of an incompetent, he was anything but. You are also making the assumption that anybody could have stopped Aaron from doing what he felt and thought was right, I think Taren's address at the end of the linked post has few things to say about that. > Why don't you make your pointed comment and risk a ban? Because well over 3 decades ago I decided that there had been enough undirected anger in my life and I figured out I should put that energy to constructive uses. The whole JSTOR affair and the very unfortunate conclusion (to put it extremely mildly) has taught me something about myself, that the lid on the volcano is not as solid as those 30 years have made me believe. Dumb, insensitive and uninformed remarks about this upset me and I have to work just a little harder to stay on the right side of the line. So I won't be taunted by you. The last time someone successfully taunted me (highschool bully, he ended in hospital and I got a 3 month suspension) it was a disaster. I learned my lesson, and chose to develop in a different direction. > Please, I can take it and it would be refreshing to see instead of all this crap directed at law enforcement. Have you been paying attention at all? That 'crap' is grounded in a deep dissatisfaction with the way this case has been handled, by people at varying levels of power, including some in government. It has already led to an amendment proposal of the law. > And if you are not creeper out by some of Aaron's mentors fondly recalling his cuteness, you are not paying attention to what was going on there. And now his corpse is being repurposed for several agendas. I think you are entirely missing the point here. Aaron killing himself has woken up a large number of people to the fact that this has gone too far. > I'll go first and welcome a ban: fuck that. Too bad because I'd be happy to open your eyes a bit more, I think that's more productive.
- lizzard 14y agoI had no idea Tufte had been a blue box hacker. Amazing story.
- danso 14y agoI was hoping someone here could shed some light on this. This would apparently be the first time (according to Google) Tufte has ever talked about experimenting with blue-boxes. I have no doubt he (and whoever his Stanford roommate was) had the technical chops to do it. I just wonder how he knows his was the "first"...since blue-box experimentation seems to have spontaneously come about after hackers put 2 and 2 together...and there was no Hacker News/Slashdot/Internet to post (with a timestamp) the exploit. Perhaps the AT&T official acted as if it were the first time they encountered a blue box in the wild?
- hect0r 14y agoAs I recall, the first to exploit this was Joybubbles; however, Tuftes may have been the first to build a blue box. The information on MF signalling was freely available in 1960 when it was published in the Bell Tech Journal so it is conceivable that there may have been others who developed this in parallel. For those who are interested in more on Joybubbles, then there's a documentary being made about him. More info at http://www.joybubblesthemovie.com/ http://www.joybubblesthemovie.com/
- gluejar 14y agoThis was the first time Tufte had talked about this. I asked him after the talk. It was december 1962. http://go-to-hellman.blogspot.com/2013/01/edward-tufte-was-proto-phreaker.html http://go-to-hellman.blogspot.com/2013/01/edward-tufte-was-p...
- jackalope 14y agoThis reminds me of a line in Schindler's List: "Power is when we have every justification to kill, and we don't."
- maxharris 14y agoWhat would Tufte say about someone that tried to "liberate" his beautiful, expensive and excellent books? Would he be outraged at the sight of "The Visual Display of Quantitative Information" available as a pdf on a torrent site? If Swartz and his ideas were so marvelous, why is Tufte still charging any money for his work?
- jamesjporter 14y agoAs I understand it, Swartz believed in open access to publicly funded research, not freedom of information in a more general sense. There is a substantial distinction between the two; I don't think Aaron would have taken issue with Tufte charging for his book.
- maxharris 14y agoIt turns out that Tufte developed the content for "The Visual Display of Quantitative Information" while at Princeton. Although he did self-publish the book later at his own (considerable) expense, where do you think the money Princeton paid him all those years came from? If you consistently apply Swartz's idea here, Tufte is in the wrong for charging for work that taxpayers helped fund. But I have a different take: Swartz's idea is bogus. "In 1975, while at Princeton, Tufte was asked to teach a statistics course to a group of journalists who were visiting the school to study economics. He developed a set of readings and lectures on statistical graphics, which he further developed in joint seminars he subsequently taught with renowned statistician John Tukey, a pioneer in the field of information design. These course materials became the foundation for his first book on information design, The Visual Display of Quantitative Information.[5][6] After difficult negotiations with mainline publishers failed, Tufte decided to self-publish Visual Display in 1982, working closely with graphic designer Howard Gralla. He financed the work by taking out a second mortgage on his home. The book quickly became a commercial success and secured his transition from political scientist to information expert.[5]" Source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edward_Tufte http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edward_Tufte
- danso 14y ago
- keithpeter 14y ago"...in this part, Tufte related how he told Aaron, half-seriously, that Aaron’s main fault was downloading millions of articles when only a few thousand were worth downloading." So true; the trick is in recognising and curating those few thousand.
- hkmurakami 14y agoThe commonly accepted metric for "worthwhile" articles would be the number of citations they have received from other articles. One could conceivably figure out, through some clever parsing, which articles have been cited the most.
- keithpeter 14y agoThere are indeed citation indexes which are used to 'score' papers when they are cited, one such being the Science Citation Index, a subscription service available to many members of universities. http://thomsonreuters.com/products_services/science/free/essays/history_of_citation_indexing/ http://thomsonreuters.com/products_services/science/free/ess... There are issues with citation indexes, bias towards early publication &c. My comment was directed more at the 'paper mill' and the 'minimum publishable result' tendency in some areas of science!
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- mikeleeorg 14y agoI found this so touching and amazing. From http://www.aaronsw.com/weblog/001552 http://www.aaronsw.com/weblog/001552, linked to from OP's article: Dear Aaron, I would have so enjoyed talking with you. Next time let me know. Best, ET
- jacquesm 14y ago"There is one other chance: Tufte is giving a lecture about his forthcoming book, Beautiful Evidence, tonight. The only problem is that it’s scheduled at the same time as my IHUM final. I try to calculate what grade I will get if I skip the final. I decide that if I zip through the test answering the easy questions and jog over to where Tufte is speaking, I should be able to get enough of both. So that’s exactly what I do."
- gluejar 14y agoI talked to Tufte after the event. It seems this was the first time, apart from some late-night cocktail parties, that he'd spoken about it publicly. http://go-to-hellman.blogspot.com/2013/01/edward-tufte-was-proto-phreaker.html http://go-to-hellman.blogspot.com/2013/01/edward-tufte-was-p... http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5086036 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5086036