3 ms·
After all, if the archive torrented is completely inferior to the JSTOR service, then no one would find it valuable. It wouldn't help anyone. An analogy: marga
by nitrogen 14y ago
After all, if the archive torrented is completely inferior to the JSTOR service, then no one would find it valuable. It wouldn't help anyone.
An analogy: margarine is inferior in taste to butter. To those who can afford butter (universities), margarine is undesirable. To those who cannot (laypeople, journalists), margarine may be an acceptable substitute.
Inferior does not mean valueless, nor does it mean the value of the superior product is diminished.
Of course not. But violating the CFAA is. Copyright infringement, on a large enough scale certainly is.
This is a completely separate debate, and addressed elsewhere. Summarized, it is debatable whether Aaron's actions (changing MAC address) do or should constitute Wire Fraud or CFAA violations. It is also debatable whether any nonviolent crime should ever have a penalty larger than any violent crime. I will not address any of these points further in this thread.