4 ms·
Things that are actually more efficient don't require subsidies.... I like trains, but as passenger transport, they're not competitive. Yes, I know about the
by anamax 18y ago
Things that are actually more efficient don't require subsidies....
I like trains, but as passenger transport, they're not competitive.
Yes, I know about the energy efficiency of a full train. However, you can't have both decent utilization (reasonably full trains) and reasonable ridership. And, if you don't shoot for reasonable ridership, the fixed and labor costs will kill you. At reasonable ridership, lower utilization kills the realized efficiency and you're still having trouble with fixed and labor costs.
Note that govt involvement makes things worse. If a congress critter comes from a particular town, that town will get a stop, regardless of whether that makes sense. (Stops have a huge impact on average speed.)
- jbert 18y ago> Things that are actually more efficient don't require subsidies.... This rings true, but I'm not sure. Isn't the truth the weaker statement that new ventures which can't clearly demonstrate, in advance, that their balance of return+risk is likely to be better than investment in their competitors are unlikely to be funded? And with larger ventures, which require significant investment in infrastructure, this calculation is skewed against new players (and new approaches - where rail counts as a 'new approach' for these purposes)? Subsidy can tip the balance by reducing the initial risk, effectively lowering barriers to entry and thus encouraging more competition? [Your other comments about viability are presumably dependent on passenger volumes/density etc. e.g. Local light rail works well in some cities. It may well be that all intercity services would come under your characterisation tho.]
- anamax 18y ago> Isn't the truth the weaker statement that new ventures which can't clearly demonstrate, in advance, that their balance of return+risk is likely to be better than investment in their competitors are unlikely to be funded? That's an interesting, but different and irrelevant question because there's no reason to believe that high speed rail in the US won't require on-going subsidies. The only argument is over how big they'll be. Run the numbers on every proposal you see. Compare the total salaries for the "jobs created" to the projected revenue (ridership * average fare). Look at the estimates for other on-going costs. Look at the startup costs.
- davidw 18y ago> I like trains, but as passenger transport, they're not competitive. That's an awfully broad statement without qualifications... They work quite well in many places in Europe. I think some components to the recipe for success are: reasonably dense population, lots of car traffic, convenience (train stations have to be fairly close to where people want to go, and connected to other public transport), reasonable distances (less than plane distances, greater than bus distances). Another thing that helps here in Italy is that they're reasonably frequent between major destinations... if I miss one train to Venice or Vicenza, there will certainly be another one in an hour, if not a half an hour. In other words, in the US, it makes sense to build trains, say, in the bay area, but probably not so much between San Francisco and Los Angeles - there isn't that much car traffic between the two cities, and in LA, which is so spread out, you're screwed if you depend on public transportation. Also, it's far enough that a plane is a lot faster. On the other hand, Milan to Rome is roughly a four hour train ride, center to center - so by the time you factor in going to the airport, checking in, flying, baggage claim, getting back to the center of Rome, they take about the same time, and the train is less stressful.
- Xichekolas 18y agoLA to SF - 382 miles (along I-5) Rome to Milan - 357 miles Not that much difference. Either way would take a couple hours at the 170mph figure they are citing, and you are right to point out that anything under about 4 hours is going to beat planes, where you waste a couple hours in pre/post flight. Los Angeles to Las Vegas seems like a prime route, at 278 miles. I have had to drive that a few times, and the traffic on I-15 is often so heavy as to be nearly at a standstill. Las Vegas would probably see an obvious boost in weekenders as well. I think there are other targets outside Cali and the NE too. The KC -> St Louis stretch of I-70 is very heavily trafficked, and is 250 miles, which is long enough that trains beat cars but short enough that they can also beat airlines.
- olefoo 18y agoI would be all for a train that went from Vancouver BC to San Diego, or even further south. Half the population of the US that lives west of the rockies, lives within 15 miles of I-5. Imagine getting on the train in Seattle in the morning, switching trains in Sacramento and arriving in San Francisco in mid-afternoon. With wifi and cell phone coverage fully available for the whole trip.
- Xichekolas 18y agoNot competitive compared to what? Combined spending by federal, state, and local governments on roads and airports amounts to hundreds of billions of dollars a year. Not exactly a profitable enterprise. Throw in the billions spent by end users of these roads on their own vehicles, and it's hard to see why there is such a fuss over the funding of trains. I'm not saying they are always the best solution in every situation. Planes will continue to win for long distances, and roads will continue to win for short ones, but there is a definite middle ground where trains shine. Having some double standard about profitability and competitiveness when we subsidize airports and highways to the tune of hundreds of billions a year seems rather disingenuous. And I wholeheartedly agree with your statement about government involvement leading to perverse decisions, but remember that this is the case whether we are talking about trains or highways or any other big spending project.
- anamax 18y ago> Combined spending by federal, state, and local governments on roads and airports amounts to hundreds of billions of dollars a year. Not exactly a profitable enterprise. Profit is not measured by spending, but by the relationship between spending and revenue. > it's hard to see why there is such a fuss over the funding of trains. Because they lose public money - they cost more to build and run than folks will pay to use them. I've no objection to you spending your money on them, but I'd rather not spend my money on them. > Having some double standard about profitability and competitiveness when we subsidize airports and highways to the tune of hundreds of billions a year seems rather disingenuous. We don't subsidize highways; the total taxes collected more than cover the costs. That's why the rail folks try to get a piece of it.
- Xichekolas 18y ago> We don't subsidize highways; the total taxes collected more than cover the costs. Sorry, but this is a commonly held misconception. From this article: http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,274113,00.html http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,274113,00.html "Close to two-thirds of the trust fund's $40 billion in receipts last year came from the gasoline tax." So the trust fund, which is made up of gas and diesel taxes, amounts to about $40 billion a year. As I have pointed out before here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=260824 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=260824 Total federal outlays were about $67 billion that same year, and states and local governments usually throw in billions more. And besides, I never claimed you can't fund rail via use taxes. But subsidizing roads to the tune of billions a year and expecting rail infrastructure to compete without such subsidies is just silly.