4 ms·
I'm curious about the economic justification behind this statement: > Without market inefficiencies, capital would be unable to capture any more than its own r
by baddox 14y ago
I'm curious about the economic justification behind this statement:
> Without market inefficiencies, capital would be unable to capture any more than its own reproduction cost in any branch of industry. The elimination of competition is central to the logic of capitalism. Without unfair advantages, a capitalist class of owners could not accumulate wealth and there could be no capitalism.
I'm well aware that market inefficiencies are real and inevitable, but why is all net value increase attributable to them? In the most obvious case, I can certainly buy a shovel and recover way more value by digging and finding gold. Net wealth can and does increase over time, due both to the harvesting of natural resources and the cumulative advantages of human knowledge and technology.
Perhaps the whole statement hinges on the definitions of "unfair advantages." If the speaker considers exclusive ownership of capital to be unfair, then the claim is a tautology.
- scarmig 14y agoA world without market inefficiencies is a world where there are no excess profits--everything converges to the natural rate of profit. Any place money could be that offers an economic profit would immediately receive many competitors who would drag it down to the natural rate. What I gather he's saying is that the natural rate of profit is itself zero: given that and no economic profit, capitalism could not reproduce itself. It's probably true that, in a world with complete and perfect knowledge, the natural rate is zero: that world, however, is so radically different from our own or any conceivable socialist one that I've got to reject that part of his point.
- baddox 14y agoIt would require more than just perfect knowledge, wouldn't it? Market inefficiency has other sources, too, like transaction costs, non-excludability and non-rivalry (e.g. public goods), etc.
- dreamdu5t 14y agoYup, they don't believe there should be private ownership of capital/property. What is often overlooked is the only way to administer community ownership is an elite group that decides who gets what. A very common misconception amongst socialists and other self professed anti-capitalists is that economics is a zero-sum game. It is not.
- scarmig 14y agoAttributing to other people false opinions is pretty rude. This is what I in a separate comment referred to as "propertarian" libertarianism: it worships the almighty State as having full knowledge of what society should look like, and establishing it through a mass violence that's mischaracterized as "property." I'd encourage you to look beyond pamphlets on the Internet and into actual work on how economics works. Start with Elinor Ostrom: you put up a very false dichotomy between state management from above and state regulation from above via property rights. In reality, societies base most of their economic activity on something entirely different: shared community norms. That's how households are run, that's how open source is run, that's how the commons is typically protected. And it outperforms state control in many or most cases.