7 ms·
This attitude of not taking responsibility for anything, of simply denying reality, not to mention humanity, has a very specific beginning: George W. Bush's def
by javajosh 14y ago
This attitude of not taking responsibility for anything, of simply denying reality, not to mention humanity, has a very specific beginning: George W. Bush's defeat of Al Gore. He demonstrated to everyone in government and in the private sector that you can reach out for power, nakedly, without respect to any kind of decency, and take it. And, gasp, the American people would not clamor for justice. They would not demand something (or someone) better. It was a watershed moment for government, when everyone realized: we can do whatever the fuck we want, and no-one can stop us.
And this thesis, hesitant at first, has been demonstrated again and again. By Bush himself - NSA wiretapping, gitmo, the TSA and the most epic 'fuck you' ever spoken to the American people: the attack and occupation of Iraq under false pretenses. Cheney's massive expansion of power of the office of the Vice Presidency was a more subtle but still important expression of this disregard for American oversight. Carmen Ortiz is an Obama appointee, but she is very much a product of the Bush era.
Bush was a wake-up call for all government employees: you have unchecked power. If you want to use it, expand it, abuse it then do it. No-one is going to stop you. Our justice system is so expensive that it's out of reach of most, and really, in the end, you're playing on the same team so go ahead and do what you want. 'Justice' has your back.
But the key to making this power grab work is to follow the Bush playbook: never, ever admit to any wrong doing. Do not, under any circumstances, even acknowledge the concerns of others - except possibly in tones of smirking dismissal and contempt. If you don't follow that playbook, then you give your opponents an opening, and weaken your position. Pretty soon you'll be explaining yourself, and when you're explaining, you're losing. You're losing power.
Stonewall, deny, and fight with every last tool given to you. Do not cooperate or discuss. Force your opponents to find leverage against you: don't just give it to them.
Ortiz is a smart woman, and learned her lessons well.
- scarmig 14y agoAh, those pre-Bush wonder years, when we all could look up to honest politicians.
- jacquesm 14y agoThe operative bit there is 'nakedly', without any pretense of decency or cover. Just do it and you can get away with it, nobody will lift a finger.
- scarmig 14y agoI'd say it's a difference in degree, not in kind, but I would guess that political culture has taken a turn for the worse since GWB. But... I'm not certain of it. Everyone has always complained about politicians. Are GWB's actions really that different from FDR or LBJ or RMN? In terms of respecting cultural/procedural niceties, not in terms of policy. How could that even be measured?
- jacquesm 14y agoI strongly believe it to be more than a difference in degree. It is a signal that something is extremely broken wrt to how the system actually works and how it should be working. It says that the foxes no longer care about the farmer when they're raiding the hen-house because they know he's trussed up and unable to retaliate.
- newbie12 14y agoYeah, FDR, LBJ and Nixon took the naked use of power to another level. The OP is a bunch of nonsense. Come to terms with it-- this is the action of the Obama DoJ.
- jacquesm 14y agoHello newbie12, FDR, LBJ and Nixon are only 'naked' in hindsight. They tried very hard to appear to be as respectable as possible and to hide their power grabs as good as they could. The only person from that era that I could accuse of doing this openly was McCarthy, and ended up censured by the senate. Something has definitely changed.
- jerf 14y agoNothing happened openly in that era. It couldn't; there was no "open" in any sense we'd recognize here today on HN. You, as a normal citizen, might here about the highlights of political actions a couple of days later, you certainly couldn't hear about the details, and you lacked any effective method of connecting with hundreds or thousands of other people in any reasonable period of time to do anything about it if you did. And media was hardly unbiased, with documented instances of wars all but created from whole cloth by media personalities. All that has happened is that it turns out that merely shining a bit of light on these practices didn't make them go away. The constraint now is people's bandwidth rather than raw ability to get them information, but that didn't turn out to be so much larger than the info conduit was in the first place. Even if you are inclined to call what Bush did a "coup" (which I am not, but I'll take it for a moment), consider the implications of the fact that not only did the word "coup" already exist, it is in fact centuries old, and still far newer than the phenomena is describes.
- protomyth 14y agoI would say the change dates to Woodrow Wilson, Herbert Hoover, Theodore Roosevelt, and Franklin D. Roosevelt. Each of these men did not care about the limits of Presidential power. Both Roosevelt's thought the Constitution was just a guideline. If you think GWB abused power, then the things FDR did would shock you. Other than trying to pack the Supreme Court, he violated the rights of many of his "enemies" in various ways only a government can get away with. If the courts had ruled another way when these people were in power, the USA could be a much better place. Heck, Nixon had price controls (voted to him by a Democratic Congress). GWB is vilified far more than he deserves compared to other Presidents.
- shadytrees 14y agoI'm in my 20s and the idea of Bush v. Gore being a watershed moment resonates with me, a loss of innocence occurring at a grand scale while a smaller private individual version happened to me. It's so easy for me to trace recent history back to that moment regardless of actual cause/effect. And I wonder what moment will resonate with the next generation.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- newbie12 14y agoBush initially opposed the TSA, a bipartisan majority of Congress foisted that on him.
- twoodfin 14y agoMore that it was the price to get his anti-terrorism agenda through the Democratic Senate: A new Federal agency with unionized employees. Now that's my perspective. They argued it was because real Federal employees could do a better job than contractors. javajosh's political worldview is simple, comprehensive and wrong. But it does provide an easy, conforting answer whenever something bad happens!
- smacktoward 14y agoThis explanation is oversimplified. Unionization had less to do with it than traditional DC power politics did. There had been a small group of members of Congress who had been pushing for the merger of the various independent agencies into a single Cabinet-level department since the early 1990s. Partly this was due to a sincere concern over terrorist incidents like the first World Trade Center bombing in 1993 (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1993_World_Trade_Center_bombing http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1993_World_Trade_Center_bombing), and the belief that merging the agencies would result in greater efficiency and better performance in countering these threats. But it was also partly due to traditional DC power politics -- these congresspeople were on the hawkish, national-security-oriented end of the spectrum, and pulling together all the little agencies that tended to their pet issues into One Big Agency would give that agency more budgetary and bureaucratic clout, making their views more prominent. And making its leader a Cabinet-level officer would create a new seat at the cabinet table that they could all aspire to fill one day. This faction was bipartisan. You can see this by looking at the makeup of one of its pre-9/11 projects, the Hart-Rudman Commission (see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/US_Commission_on_National_Security/21st_Century http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/US_Commission_on_National_Secur...). You had Gary Hart and Lee Hamilton (Democrats) working together with Newt Gingrich and Jim Schlesinger (Republicans). But "bipartisan" doesn't mean that they represented the opinion of the majority of Congress or the country -- these were all people who had been working in and around national security issues since the 1960s and '70s, and they looked at issues with the perspective of people whose idee fixe is that America is not sufficiently organized like an armed camp. They used the commission's final report, which it issued in February 2001 (http://govinfo.library.unt.edu/nssg/PhaseIIIFR.pdf http://govinfo.library.unt.edu/nssg/PhaseIIIFR.pdf -- warning, PDF) -- seven months before 9/11 -- to push explicitly for "an independent National Homeland Security Agency (NHSA) with responsibility for planning, coordinating, and integrating various U.S. government activities involved in homeland security." But this proposal went nowhere, because nobody outside the national-security world thought the enormous costs and bureaucratic turmoil that unification would involve would be worth it. So this proposal looked like it was going to do what most blue-chip commission proposals do: collect dust on a bookshelf somewhere in Washington. Then came 9/11, of course, and suddenly everybody in DC was running around shouting the same thing: Something Has To Be Done. The national-security faction, seeing this, was happy to dust off its report and say "We have Something That Can Be Done!" Which was a powerful thing to be able to say, at that moment -- while everyone else was running around trying to figure out how to respond, these guys had a plan all ready to go. When everyone else had nothing, they had Something. And on top of that, suddenly the things that had looked so negative about their big idea -- the huge expense, the bureaucratic turmoil -- began to look positive; these things would mean everyone would see that not only was Something Being Done, but that this Something was Something Big. Which must mean it's also Something Important. So Congress glommed onto the proposal, and the "National Homeland Security Agency," which had seemed like the ridiculous pipe dream of a bunch of defense obsessives, became the Department of Homeland Security that we all know and love today.
- steveplace 14y agoSounds like you became politically aware right around the time Bush got elected. A quick run through American history would show that the executive branch has pulled off some crazy stuff in the past. Executive order 9066 comes to mind. This did not start with Bush, it continued through his administration and, yes, to the current administration.
- AnthonyMouse 14y agoI don't know how convinced I am that Bush was responsible for all of this (he was clearly a major contributor, but there is plenty of blame to go around). But I think the general point hits the nail on the head. I was just reading something that Aaron wrote (that BenoitEssiambre linked to earlier) here: http://www.aaronsw.com/weblog/semmelweis http://www.aaronsw.com/weblog/semmelweis When Oprah started defending fabulist James Frey, she was savaged by the press. So she invited her critics on the show and apologized, saying “You were right, I was wrong.” It didn’t destroy her reputation; it rescued it. When the space shuttle Columbia exploded, launch manager Wayne Hale took full responsibility: “The bottom line is that I failed to understand what I was being told…I am guilty of allowing Columbia to crash.” He was promoted. When JFK admitted the responsibility for the Bay of Pigs fiasco was “mine, and mine alone,” his poll numbers soared. People, for good reason, like it when other people own their mistakes. But we've built bureaucracies that don't. They have far too rigid accountability rules. Everything you do gets put in your file, and the file is what it takes you get you fired when someone wants to get rid of you for internal political reasons, so everyone has to be sure they never admit they've done anything wrong. "For crying out loud, man, don't improve our ability to detect mistakes, those mistakes go in or records!" The criminal justice system works the same way. If you admit what you did, you get punished. If you deny it successfully you go free. But we can't have criminals going free, so we make it impractical for "normal criminals" to deny anything successfully. Then your choice becomes to confess and face punishment or assert your innocence and face an even larger punishment -- a choice that doesn't depend on whether you were actually guilty or innocent, or whether you should have been guilty or innocent under a more just set of laws. So we get where we are: If you get accused of something the penalties are absurd, so if you're a big Wall St. guy with a billion dollars, you spend a fortune on the Big Lie and get out of any real punishment whatsoever, and if you're not a millionaire then you plead guilty regardless of your guilt so that you "only" go to prison for six months instead of six years. And then we wonder where prosecutors and politicians possibly got the idea that the Big Lie is the way to go.
- purephase 14y agoThanks for posting the semmelweis piece from Aaron. With all of the links being passed around this week I missed it. It is amazingly relevant to this discussion and (if it hasn't been done already) it should be sent to the DoJ and Ortiz personally. Not that I think it will make any difference though.
- waterlesscloud 14y agoSome honest advice- Read up on American political history. You need some perspective that goes back at least a few decades, and ideally throughout at least the entire 20th century. None of what you imagine started with Bush started anywhere near that time. Not one bit of it. Your stance about government has merit, but it is severely weakened by a lack of understanding of American political history.
- jacquesm 14y agoI'm all for being educated, if there is a lack of understanding here could you please make it explicit with examples of similar cases in the past?
- 3pt14159 14y agoMkultra, project mocking bird, Tonkin affair, and many many more
- jacoblyles 14y agoFDR's court packing scheme. Oppenheimer's persecution. The alien and sedition acts. Lincoln's suspension of Habeus Corpus. Lyndon Johnson's disputed election.
- philwelch 14y agoAdding on: John F. Kennedy's disputed election. The entire Nixon administration, and Ford's subsequent pardon of Nixon. The prohibitions of drugs and alcohol. The Bonus Army. Smedley Butler's "War is a Racket". The entire career of J. Edgar Hoover.
- joshAg 14y agoKorematsu. and executive order 9066.
- tedunangst 14y agothe most epic 'fuck you' ever spoken to the American people: the attack and occupation of Iraq under false pretenses. Yes, let's pretend neither the Spanish-American or Mexican-American wars ever happened. (recognizing you're not the OP.)
- SoftwareMaven 14y agoCan this comment please not be the top comment (I'd prefer it gone altogether). It is politically charged and ignores two centuries of politics that have led us to this point. Further, it detracts from Lessig's poignant article and will not further constructive conversation.
- youngerdryas 14y agoYou sound like an idealistic young man who is just discovering the bizarre sausage-making quality of reality. The comforting idea that things were better in the past is a fallacy and if you believe in evolution and market forces, then as painful as it may seem, we are already on the optimal path. Everyone views this tragedy through their own lens and tries attach whatever is atop their grievance list and that is only natural. I tried to explain this story to a student from the Ukraine and she could not fathom it. I think sometimes we forget how good we really have it.
- jacoblyles 14y agoI've always wondered what Democrats think should have happened in the 2000 election. As far as I can tell, it was a very close one. The idea that Bush "stole" the election lacks credibility with me. 1,000 more votes on either side, and the controversy would have disappeared.
- zecho 14y agoWhen people say "stole the election" I think that's shorthand for "Bush won on a technicality." Bush v. Gore lead to an agreement from the court that Florida badly fucked up certification, but because of Title 3, the fuck up would have to stand. What I think everyone fails to remember, however, is that independent analysis of recounts that could have happened may have led to either Bush winning or Gore winning, depending on the type of recount, which gives you an even better idea of just how much Florida fucked up in 2000.
- enraged_camel 14y agoThis assumes that the voting process was fair to begin with, when it wasn't. There was plenty of intimidation, disenfranchisement and blatant cheating done by Republicans that skewed the numbers in their favor significantly. It also happened in 2008 and 2012, but Obama won despite it.
- protomyth 14y agoCompared to the 1876 and 1888 elections, the 2000 election was pretty tame. I cannot even comprehend what would have happened if the "Compromise of 1877" had been repeated for the 2000 election. I still think Fox screwed the country by calling Florida an hour before the polls on the panhandle closed. The voting margin in panhandle probably would have erased the dispute and allowed for an easier transition. That lack of a proper transition cost us in Asian politics (NK) and probably didn't help our readiness for 9/11.
- mindslight 14y agoJust "Something Else", of course. The function of elections is to blame all that went wrong on whomever got elected last time (and how they got elected - mostly the perceived supporters), while simultaneously converting that ever-present negativity into hope for a new leader and thus tacit support for the overall system. Since the election mechanics of 2000 added ambiguity to the outcome, some of the ongoing blame gets directed there as well.
- Daniel_Newby 14y agoYou sorely lack historical perspective. An example of naked use of power and bad leadership would be Robespierre's leadership of the French Revolution, also known as The Terror. That's the historical standard for what happens when government comes off the rails. The African woman whise four children were tied to her limbs before she was thrown in a river? That's an example of justice being out of reach. The government of George W. Bush was, in comparison, a gift from the gods that many people would consider unimaginable luxury. (Including the natives in Afghanistan and Mesopotamia, whose previous claim to military fame was vying for the title of 'graveyard of empires'.) Ortiz is a generic prosecutor who is wholly unremarkable. You could blow her up by bombing the building where she works and they would fly out interchangeable replacements in standard federal suits to finish grinding out her cases exactly like she would.