2 ms·
I'm confused: 1) Most of the microlending is essentially aimed at being charitable, and is practiced in the third world. Most venture capital is 0-for-2. Th
by patio11 18y ago
I'm confused:
1) Most of the microlending is essentially aimed at being charitable, and is practiced in the third world. Most venture capital is 0-for-2. This is like comparing VC funding to consumption of chicken breasts.
2) Kiva et al get good press. They probably wouldn't if people knew the microscopic default rates were caused by local partners' automatically rolling over loans which go delinquent. This creative accounting just papers over the problems (and we will, inevitably, see a reckoning here.)
3) I don't see American entrepreneurs taking 100% APR debt anytime soon when many of them can do far, far better with consumer credit (which is itself a poor option for business financing, most of the time). (Oh, they didn't mention that in the microlending presentation? Must have slipped their minds.)
4) There are significant regulatory hurdles in front of microfinance in the US. Prosper, one American startup in the space, got essentially shut down by the SEC. They're also legally capped at about 30% a year for interest, which is unlikely to cover defaults if you aim at the sort of customer Prosper did.
5) I don't think loans in the $5k ~ $25k region would really help most startups that much. They're small enough that it is doable with familial resources for most people who are middle class. (The traditional first resort of startup funding.) They're also small enough to be covered by personal credit, which would take the average working professional about a day to arrange (quite possibly at painful rates, but not 30%).
And unlike selling equity they leave the entrepreneur holding the bag if things go south, which is the major reason we don't tell everybody and their dog "Put the business on your credit card!"