8 ms·
The Value of Downvoting, or, How Hacker News Gets It Wrong
- pg 18y agoThe reason HN doesn't need downvotes is that HN, unlike Reddit, kills lame articles. On Reddit, users need downvotes as a way of saying an article is lame. Downvoting is the only way you can get a (nonspam) submission off the frontpage. But on HN you can flag it and if it's bad the editors will kill it. We can thus safely assume a nonlame set of articles, and we also (so far at least) assume nonlame voters. And if you only have nonlame voters voting on nonlame articles, upvotes should be enough to pick the winners.
- codinghorror 18y ago> The reason HN doesn't need downvotes is that HN, unlike Reddit, kills lame articles. Honest question, and I do not mean this as a flame, because generally I quite enjoy Hacker News. How, exactly, is the current top-rated story on HN, "How to Stop the Drug Wars" ( http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=507509 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=507509 ) related to.. news of hacking?
- wfarr 18y agoHacker News isn't so much just about programming, but things that are interesting to programmers. It's entirely possible that the programmers that visit HN are interested in that topic.
- codinghorror 18y agoRegardless, I think it's a terrible story for a site about programming topics, and I would absolutely vote it down. But I can't.
- johns 18y agoFlag it if you believe it to be off-topic.
- codinghorror 18y agoWhere's the UI to flag a story as off-topic? I don't see anything on the article page itself, and the FAQ ( http://ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html http://ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html ) doesn't mention anything about flagging?
- johns 18y agoOn the article page, this is what I see: http://screencast.com/t/Wqa1zmMJ http://screencast.com/t/Wqa1zmMJ I don't know if there is a rep threshold for flagging, but I wouldn't be surprised.
- kylec 18y agoYou apparently need at least 51 karma to flag a post. (The number may not be exact, it's not an official source. Also, it says "comments" not "posts", so there may be a different threshold for that) source: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=439396 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=439396
- codinghorror 18y agoShouldn't these rep limits, and the information about them, be codified into the FAQ?
- allenbrunson 18y agokarma limits change all the time, due to "inflation." it used to be pretty difficult to get to 100 points. these days you could get there in a day or two, if you're determined.
- lacker 18y agoNo. Hacker News doesn't have to work the same way as Stack Overflow. Not only are these limits fluctuating and not really public, HN relies on human editors a lot. That's okay; the models are really different. Stack Overflow needs to scale more because to be useful, there need to be thousands of questions asked every day, and every question needs to be able to get a response. Hacker News can be useful to me even if it only gets a hundred new stories a day, and it's not really a problem if many stories get axed for a bad reason.
- whughes 18y agoIt's a valid point, though. At what point is the line drawn? Political issues often result in uncivil discussion. There is also probably significant audience crossover with reddit that caused that post to rise up. Hackers may have an interest in libertarianism or economics, but does that mean that this site should become one about Ron Paul if people feel that way? Editor control should be used to put a stop to that, IMO. Democracy is great, but it went too far with Reddit. HN would become much less useful to me if it went in that direction.
- wfarr 18y ago> It's a valid point, though. At what point is the line drawn? That wasn't really his point so much as yours. ;) > Political issues often result in uncivil discussion. There is also probably significant audience crossover with reddit that caused that post to rise up. Hackers may have an interest in libertarianism or economics, but does that mean that this site should become one about Ron Paul if people feel that way? That is in fact a good question to ask, and I wasn't precluding it from being asked, but rather reiterating the stated goals for Hacker News. Such questions ought to be asked.
- jhancock 18y agoThe reason political issues often result in uncivil discussion, me thinks, is we have not spent enough time in a forum (online or off) that demands civility in such discussions. If HN can provide both (1) topics members want to discuss along with (2) its approach of keeping the discussion civil, this seems a very good thing. I am a big fan of hacking social and economic problems. If a topic is not of interest I ignore it. A thread rarely stays on the front page more than a day or two. I originally came to HN for Web 2.0 news. But things have evolved.
- trominos 18y agoI don't think it's even that anymore. Hacker News is now pretty much, "Interesting things, plus a lot of programmers use the site." Which is good for everybody who uses HN as something other than a place to get tips about programming, which I expect is the vast majority of the HN user population.
- tptacek 18y agoNews for hackers doesn't mean news about hackers.
- pg 18y ago"On-Topic: Anything that good hackers would find interesting. That includes more than hacking and startups. If you had to reduce it to a sentence, the answer might be: anything that gratifies one's intellectual curiosity." http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html "Stories on HN don't have to be about hacking, because good hackers aren't only interested in hacking, but they do have to be deeply interesting. What does "deeply interesting" mean? It means stuff that teaches you about the world. A story about a robbery, for example, would probably not be deeply interesting. But if this robbery was a sign of some bigger, underlying trend, then perhaps it could be." http://ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html http://ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html
- potatolicious 18y agoThat seems almost reddit-like. Reddit is also (ostensibly) for news items of intellectual value... but look how that turned out :)
- whughes 18y agoThe comment implementation, however, does not appear to be substantially different from Reddit's aside from greater editor control. That means that lame downvoting is possible. If people start to downvote those they disagree with then we begin to see enforced groupthink. (Funny sidenote: In forums with alleged [real or fake] groupthink tendencies, like Reddit, it appears that referring to and criticizing the groupthink is very often voted up by the community. This is why I believe that groupthink emerges naturally as a result of the availability of the downvote. No one notices what's going on and attempts to correct their own behavior.) Killing articles and comments solves the problem of lame articles and comments. However, it does not solve the problem of lame voting hiding useful comments. I suspect that this problem will require a solution soon; I myself have noticed an increasing trend toward Redditism here. Additionally, I believe that the comment system is probably even more important than the article system. In some sites sites, including Hacker News, I get more from the comments than I do from the articles. Thus, ensuring that comments are good and fairly balanced is just as important to me as ensuring that stories are good.
- DarkShikari 18y agoI don't think Hacker News' system kills lame articles. I have seen obvious troll blog posts and such reach the top of HN repeatedly. The reason this happens is because of the following. Let us say that an ordinary story that is completely relevant to Reddit and is worth reading is upvoted by 50 people and downvoted by 10. This gets the story +40. Now, let us take a very controversial story, say, a blog post on how much git sucks that is obviously fishing for links. This story gets upvoted by many more people, say, 100 people... and downvoted by 300. It doesn't get near the front page. Now, take the same on HN. The first story gets +50, the second gets +100, despite the majority of people believing it should not be on the front page. This is not to say that the Reddit system is better, but rather that the HN system is not perfect.
- kajecounterhack 18y agoUsually lame articles are gone within a day. You can tell when all the comments object and eventually people flag and editors go "okay, we'll remove it."
- DarkShikari 18y agoMost articles are gone within a day as they fall off the front page.
- redrobot5050 18y agoYeah, that is correct, but lame articles usually only make it to the "new" page, and never the "real frontpage". I've submitted to HN 2 or 3 times now, and my articles have been killed for lameness. (In my defense I thought they were good articles. But the system appears to work from my experience.)
- Xichekolas 18y agoExcept in the second case, even if only a third of the people take the trouble to flag the article, it would have 100 points and 100 flaggings. Hopefully something getting flagged that much would be killed pretty quickly. I like making a distinction between something that I simply don't find insightful and something that is actually trolling/spammy/false. In HN's case, my lack of an upvote is equivalent of not finding something insightful... my flagging is an indication of the latter.
- jlouis 18y agoAnother thing worthy of mention is that if you only have upvotes the ranking of articles turn out to be considerably simpler. Ranking with both up and down votes is a lot harder.
- e40 18y agoI agree. Reddit started to get really messed up when the "silly pictures" posts were allowed to dominate the front page. Those posts attracted more of the same, and the change in the comments that followed should not have been a shock to anyone--the same people upvoting the picture of the "jesus toast" were the same ones making stupid comments. However, all of this is missing the main point: for a site to be popular (lots of eye balls) and be able to sell itself to a large media company for a large sum of cash, it needs to appeal to more than a small, coherent community. Reddit changed because their founders wanted to cash out. HN isn't changing because you have no (apparent) goal of cashing out, and are thus willing to keep HN as it is.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- codinghorror 18y agoFirst, I should apologize for my misunderstanding. I do feel like a doofus for not realizing that downvotes are possible on HN. But I swear I have never seen a single downvoted post any time I’ve visited! I am a very occasional HN user, mostly a lurker, and my karma is not even 2 digits. :) In my defense: 1) There's definitely an element of "if the user can’t find it, the feature doesn't exist" with downvoting here. 2) In practical terms, downvotes are so extraordinarily rare on HN that they almost don’t exist. Anyway, I'm encouraged that downvotes exist on HN, but the threshold could be considered so absurdly high that they're nerfed into oblivion.
- whughes 18y agoActually, I've noticed several downvoted posts in my short time here. Caveat: I think this is more a result of trollish posting in many of the cases, but of course that is another problem on its own. See: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=507278 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=507278 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=507604 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=507604 (the downvoting on this does seem questionable, although it is an extreme position) http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=507301 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=507301 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=505452 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=505452
- kajecounterhack 18y agoThose are comments, not posts. Posts themselves cannot be downvoted.
- whughes 18y agoAck, I'm getting my terminology confused. I meant posts in the usenet/forum sense.
- ajkirwin 18y agoYou can downvote comments, but you can't downvote posts themselves. You can only flag them.
- 18y ago
- nav 18y agoDo you need down voting when you have a team of 30 pre-screening? Their is a higher likelihood of foul play when one has the opportunity to down vote one's post relative to one's own or peer's posts. A simple bubble-up philosophy can work. It would also be interesting to see a separate section similar to the top post thread but only contains posts that have been recently down-voted, can potential have some interesting take-aways.
- jhickner 18y agoDownvotes are problematic, because even the best people can't always be trusted to use them correctly. A downvote should be reserved for something offtopic, evil, mean, etc., but too often a downvote simply means "I disagree".
- codinghorror 18y agoAnd yet we trust these very same people with upvotes? I agree the potential for damage is much higher with downvotes, but there's an asymmetry there. The trick is to make downvotes cost a little bit of karma, IMO. And while I'm on the topic, upvotes shouldn't be as free as they are, either.
- tptacek 18y agoWhat's the asymmetry? You're begging the question. Bad upvotes mean too many people see something. Bad downvotes mean not enough people see it. The latter is worse than the former. So only one of the features is supported. This is a simpler approach than turning karma into a currency to spend on suppressing things people disagree with. Having said that, the 2-1 downvote scheme you proposed does put some of us within spitting distance of taking nickb down to zero, so I support it wholeheartedly.
- codinghorror 18y ago> This is a simpler approach Having a secret cabal of editors, whose behavior and rules are not documented, is simpler than spending karma to vote against things? Really?
- tptacek 18y agoYes. A lot.
- codinghorror 18y agocan you elaborate?
- caustic 18y agoI don't care about downvotes. HN is just a great web site with great contents so that I hardly ever feel the need to downvote something.
- halo 18y agoSlight hijack, but I last time I used it I thought Stack Overflow missed the value of simplicity. On Stack Overflow, at its core, you have posts, and people reply to that post. That's fine. You can do that whether you're logged in or not (although you need an OpenID provider to sign up, which is a pain when it /could/ partner with a provider to seamlessly give you one on registering). You can mod up and down the posts. And mod up and down the comments. But only if you have a certain amount of karma for each. But the selected answer by the author of the question is at the top, ignoring the karma completely. You can have favourites. But only if you're logged in, despite the fact you can submit posts whether you are or aren't. And then you have comments on each post. But you have to click to view the comments. And you can only add comments if you have a certain amount of karma. This kills a lot of conversation needlessly. And you can edit other people's posts - if you have a certain amount of karma. And you can flag posts, but only if you're logged in. And then too often you view posts that make no sense until you see the context which is buried amongst the tags, rather than the site being naturally split into natural obvious 'sections' which will interest people who know about certain technologies. It's all very confusing, and completely needless. Hide things or at least make it obvious what I can't use before clicking. Reduce the arbitrary karma limits to add more distinct classes so that the majority have equal abilities.
- codinghorror 18y ago> It's all very confusing, and completely needless Well, the funny thing is that the complexity is there for the some of the same reasons that HN explicitly doesn't document its behavior -- it's a small barrier. But these are much lower barriers than HN, as I'll describe below. > Hide things or at least make it obvious what I can't use before clicking Ah, but this is a problem -- we tell you what you need to earn to do something when you click on it. So a) you have an idea that the feature exists, and b) you can do it at some point in the future. > Reduce the arbitrary karma limits Our limits are quite low, far lower than HN. We require the equivalent of 2 karma on HN to upvote, and 10 to downvote. More here, just divide by 10 to get the HN equivalents -- http://stackoverflow.com/faq http://stackoverflow.com/faq
- halo 18y ago
- ralph 18y agoWhat really annoys me is that pg took away the ability to downvote a comment after a day or two. Given I use RSS to visit news.yc every few days, that means I can't fully participate; I can upvote people's comments, but not downvote them. And all because someone went around downvoting all the comments for a particular user they fell out with. It's a sledgehammer, pg! Come up with something better.
- tptacek 18y agoComment votes are a tool for grooming the discussion. Discussion on most threads ends after a day or two. What's the value in downvoting a 3-day-old comment? Very few people are going to respond differently to the thread as a result. If you want to participate, you should write comments, or, better yet, submissions of your own.
- hcho 18y agoDownvoting loses more information than "no downvoting". Think about a submission with 110 upvotes and 100 downvotes, it is overall rating is 10. A submission with only 15 upvotes has a rating of 15. Surely a submission which attracts 210 user votes must be more valuable than the other one.
- JeremyChase 18y agoDownvotes and upvotes should both be shown for this reason as it calls to attention the divide in opinion.
- hcho 18y agoBut how about ordering? At the end of the day, these votes determine which submission makes it to the front page. Allowing down voting but sorting by upvotes might be one solution.
- codinghorror 18y agoThis is a good idea and conceptually similar to showing how many times something has been flagged as off topic. Although I still maintain that upvote and "off-topic" are not symmetric actions.. but choosing between public visibility of data vs "cabal of secret editors" is a no-brainer IMO.
- theBobMcCormick 18y agoIf Hacker News has got it wrong... I don't want to be right. IMHO HN is the most consistently readable, polite, and thought provoking news site on the net. The only other site I can think of that's close to as consistently a high level of quality in the posts and comments is MetaFilter. And unfortunately there are very few technology discussions over there. :-(
- known 18y agoWhy not just IGNORE instead of DOWNVOTE ?
- JulianMorrison 18y agoUp voting measures enthusiasm (and refuses any veto to the disapproving majority). Up/down voting measures peer acceptance.
- raganwald 18y agoWhat would "it" be that HN is getting wrong? The point is to (a) have quality posts on the front page, and (b) encourage a community of people to congregate and share valuable advice/wisdom/information. Design decisions are simply tools to accomplish these goals. Jeff says disallowing downvotes is "harmful to the community" and explains why he theorizes is the case, but why guess? We have HN, we can examine it and decide for ourselves if HN has been "harmed." I am all for him beating his chest and extolling the virtues of his complicated system. But I do not see the merit of his comparison to HN: It strikes me as fairly run-of-the-mill Coding Horror-style link-baiting.
- codinghorror 18y ago> We have HN, we can examine it and decide for ourselves if HN has been "harmed." When a clearly political post about the drug war stays on the front page for two days, that's harm in my book. I expect you will see more and more of this over time as the community grows. Sorry you feel that way about the post, reg. Just meant to be a discussion, and I went out of my way to say positive thingsa about HN. It feels almost like a personal attack the way you stated it here.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- rglullis 18y agoThe irony of it all is that is the first post that I really wish I could downvote. C'mon! The guy doesn't know what he's talking about, yet he is quick to say that HN "gets it wrong". Others show him he doesn't know the rules and he replies that the rules should be more explicit, when the fact is this very idiosyncrasy is what helps HN not to grow too much: it takes someone who is really interested in participating in the community to stick around and learn how things work around here. I'm flagging the link. I never liked Jeff's "from-the-hip" style of blogging, but now more and more of his articles is plain linkbait and a way to get attention to Stackoverflow. (Btw, Jeff, the whole spiel of writing even when there's nothing to say is annoying and makes more noise than signal. Quantity does not always trump quality. Practice makes it perfect, yes, but all I can say is that you're getting really good at producing crap.) To have a post on HN with such an inflammatory title and factually wrong claims is downright offensive. It's no different than me going to his office and screaming how stupid he is. In fact, I'll cancel my rarely-used StackOverflow account.
- codinghorror 18y ago1) submitted links cannot be voted down. This is, in fact, correct. 2) comments can be voted down, but it's uncommon, and the UI is invisible (literally) to the point that a casual user wouldn't even see it happening on most posts (very few posts go negative). This is a good thing, but it's not at all clear to a new or unsophisticated user that the possibility of being downvoted is on the table at all. Particularly given the front page which does not allow downvotes on submissions. 3) isn't your post the very sort of inflammatory stuff that you're claiming I write?
- rglullis 18y ago1) You've written a critique about the whole HN voting system while being factually correct about only one subsystem - the design decision about submissions. This is as silly (or arrogant, or plain stupid) as writing a critique of quantum physics just because you know how and when to use Schrödinger's equation. 2) It's not uncommon to downvote comments at all. Again, you are passing your perception as absolute truth. What you may see is few comments that have a negative score. Few downvotes and few negative-score comments are two completely different beasts, and you're inferring wrong things with the information you have available. 3) http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/inflammatory http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/inflammatory : tending to excite anger, disorder, or tumult. My comment was a response to your post. It comes off as angry, but it is a reaction to the sort of thing that you write. The post has more than 100 comments, few of them actually accomplishing anything except discussing with you and pointing out why you are wrong. So, the answer to your question is no; it's your articles that provoke reactions in others and excite disorder. It's your article that is inflammatory, not my comment. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - As a side note about what you write... I get it, Jeff. You're the textbook example of an extroverted person: you need to externalize things to process information. To you, doing supports thinking. For introverts like me (and most of HN, by the way) it's thinking that supports doing. There is no "right way" here, no "better side" to belong to. The problem lies in taking these opposites to radical extremes, and this is what is happening to you. While hardcore introverts end up suffering from analysis paralysis and never get anything done, you end up doing things carelessly and using "social brute-force": you say whatever comes to mind and expect people to throw you "warning messages" and point you to a better solution. Your blogging style is the equivalent of the guy that trolls in IRC channels (http://bash.org/?152037 http://bash.org/?152037) to see if he gets responses from the gurus. This is seriously irritating: not everyone wants to be your "idea compiler", and you consume much of other people's time and energy that could be better used elsewhere. You may even think that you are being successful with your approach: each post you write will probably make your readership increase more than decrease. But if you believe that, you'd be again relying on the idea that Quantity always trumps Quality, and again you'll be wrong by missing the point about the purpose of something like Hacker News. Quantity trumps Quality on SO - you are more interested in having hordes of beginner and intermediate techies to drive traffic than lots of experts that don't need to seek technical help as often - but HN is about insightful news and comments, and for that you need the participation of above-average and like-minded people; it's all about quality, not quantity.