4 ms·
The main thesis I remember from Good to Great was that in each of its cases, the turnaround from good to great had come from a change in leadership at the top.
by gruseom 18y ago
The main thesis I remember from Good to Great was that in each of its cases, the turnaround from good to great had come from a change in leadership at the top. The new leaders (the book claimed) had all fit a certain profile and shared a similar leadership style. I liked the book quite a bit because the character of these leaders that Collins was describing seemed admirable.
It isn't obvious whether the demise of Circuit City refutes the thesis. Perhaps the leader Collins wrote about retired and was replaced with someone who didn't share the same values? In that case GtG would actually predict a decline. Alternatively, if the company failed under the same leader that Collins wrote about, that would refute GtG pretty well. One can also imagine scenarios between these two poles where it might not be so clear.
By the way, your point reminds me of a similar one people made about In Search of Excellence (the GtG of its day), the "excellent" companies of which didn't seem so excellent a few years later.
- tptacek 18y agoYeah, I guess I'm not saying this refutes the book so much as I'm asking whether the principles in the book (like "the hedgehog concept") illustrate what went wrong with Circuit City. You could level similar critiques against other GtG companies, like Abbott Labs or, hello? Fannie Mae.
- gruseom 18y agoI forgot that Fannie Mae was in there. Yikes. The analogy with In Search of Excellence is starting to look pretty convincing. These are really just story books anyway.