4 ms·
> The first, which she made at the outset of the case, was that he was facing 35 years if convicted at trial. No, that was not what she said. She said that he
by zokier 14y ago
> The first, which she made at the outset of the case, was that he was facing 35 years if convicted at trial.
No, that was not what she said. She said that he could be facing up to 35 years. In other words 35 years would be the maximum penalty. There is no implication that she was seeking the maximum penalty at any time.
- lloeki 14y agoSaid once, of course. Regularly repeated though, it is a scare tactic to push for a settlement, with "up to" merely acting as a plausible deniability device. Being prosecuted is psychologically exhausting, and such tactics introduce lingering thoughts weakening one's mind even more.
- zokier 14y agoHer reasons behind the word choices may have been nefarious (although I hardly believe that either). But she didn't lie or contradict herself, which is what Linus is claiming.
- mpyne 14y agoIt's not even nefarious. What else is she supposed to say about the sentence when charges are initially filed? She can't say what a judge will do. She can't say what sentence the defense team might argue for. She can't even necessarily give a formal pronouncement of what she might argue for as that could tamper with negotiations between the prosecution and defense attorneys! The only factual statement you can make about the charges when they're filed to give an impression of the seriousness is the statutory maximum, so-and-so can face up to X years in prison based on these charges. I swear it sounds like a lot of the people here are either blissfully unaware of legal cases in general or are deliberately being hyperbolic now that it suits them. The former you can blame on ignorance I suppose, but the latter is disgusting.
- roc 14y agoShe identified the maximum the same way a protection racket says "It'd be a shame if anything happened to this nice business you've got here". They never actually say they're going to make 'something' happen if you don't deal. But everyone knows that is exactly what they mean. It's no different for the prosecutors. Stating the maximums in a case that clearly does not compel the maximums is an intentional negotiating tactic that amounts to intimidation. It quite clearly and obviously means "I will use the threat of the worst-case-scenario, in negotiations, to wring every last month of term and dollar of penalty out of you." And that implicitly indicates the prosecutors were gunning for Swartz.
- btilly 14y agoYou were fine until the last sentence. And that implicitly indicates the prosecutors were gunning for Swartz. No. This was business as normal. This is what they do to EVERYONE. Whether THAT is OK is a different issue. But they really weren't singling him out for significantly worse treatment than they give to other people.
- roc 14y agoThe point that they gun for everyone is no defense. (That everyone gets shaken down for protection money does not mitigate the immorality of that act in individual cases.) Such a defense would not only be an admission that the original criticisms against the office were 100% correct, but that the 'problem' of their unethical and immoral behavior is, in fact, much deeper than just Swartz. Which is, in fact, why Ortiz won't go anywhere near a claim that they treat everyone the way they treat Swartz, with similar disregard for the particulars of their case or any human sense of justice or proportionality. Attempting that argument would concede that the Swartz case is but today's face on the larger issue of proescutors run amok. [1] [1] A subject well covered in a blog post by Charles Pierce, that I previously linked to in a thread on this topic: http://www.esquire.com/blogs/politics/The_Case_Of_Aaron_Swartz http://www.esquire.com/blogs/politics/The_Case_Of_Aaron_Swar... I'm well aware that they treat everyone this way. That's not a different issue. It is the issue.
- sixbrx 14y ago