3 ms·
We aren't lawyers, we can call her a liar if she appears to be one, especially if "there's a lot of room for interpretation." It's a huge joke that we're debati
by rhizome 14y ago
We aren't lawyers, we can call her a liar if she appears to be one, especially if "there's a lot of room for interpretation." It's a huge joke that we're debating whether "the lawyer says they're not lying" is a good argument. What's problematic for her is that "the ecosystem she's operating in" aren't the only forces at work. Maybe she thought the age-old mechanism of press releases and who-gives-a-shit-what-lawyers-say would work the same as it always has, but that doesn't mean it has to be that way. Lawyers can't force us to operate in their ecosystem, and I have a feeling that they're exceedingly poor at existing in any other ecosystem, as best exemplified by the words of her husband, former IBM Websphere QA Stud Tom Dolan (i.e. one of us).
An additional complication is that her bosses simply might not care what she said and will keep her on the job with no changes, regardless. Deaf ears are still an option.
- jacquesm 14y ago> Lawyers can't force us to operate in their ecosystem Unfortunately we are doing exactly that. All of us are operating in an ecosystem crafted by lawyers. And so when we run into the boundaries set we will find lawyers or legally schooled people on all three sides of the table, the prosecution, our defense counsel and the judge. They use our language but in a way that appears twisted and dishonest to laypeople. We pay - with huge sums of money and with time served - for the privilege. Ortiz is using her position as a stepping stone to further her career. Aaron was to her a conveniently placed cobblestone that she could put her spiked heel on to make it to the next level. I'm pretty sure she regrets this, but only because it damaged her career chances. I certainly wished that justice would be more about what's really best for society instead of about protecting special interest and selective prosecution but this is something that I did not need the Aaron Swartz case for to become aware of.
- twoodfin 14y agoOrtiz is using her position as a stepping stone to further her career. Aaron was to her a conveniently placed cobblestone that she could put her spiked heel on to make it to the next level. I'm pretty sure she regrets this, but only because it damaged her career chances. "Spiked heel"? Regret over a dead defendant "only because it damaged her career choices"? You've been fairly rational in most of these discussions, but you're just egging on the mob here.
- jacquesm 14y ago> You've been fairly rational in most of these discussions, but you're just egging on the mob here. Feel free to disagree, I call them as I see them. I think her statement is cynical in the extreme, quite possibly to head off any claims by the family and I think that her whole 'tough' stance is just to further her own career goals. If you have evidence to the contrary I'll be more than happy to adjust my position. Crocodile tears after the fact are not persuasive, not accepting any responsibility at all is very telling.