3 ms·
Removing / blaming one person without reforming the system is called a "purge" as in Stalinist Purge Please fix the system not the blame Suggestion: are plea
by lifeisstillgood 14y ago
Removing / blaming one person without reforming the system is called a "purge" as in Stalinist Purge
Please fix the system not the blame
Suggestion: are plea bargains public record?
If so can we parse and publicise them? Would it be interesting to know the ratio of years charged vs years pleaded - especially by race and offence and state?
Edit: no not trying to compare this in degree with marching thousands to death in gulags - just we should focus on fixing a justice system that basically tries to avoid the courts because of those awkward and time consuming human rights. I mean imagine if we had to deal with terrorists instead of copyright violators - we might skip plea bargaining and do something silly in Cuba. Luckily the rights of the individual are paramount in the worlds greatest democracy - otherwise we could all be in trouble
- philwelch 14y agoThe result of any charges are in the public record, and since no one just pleads guilty without trying to get something out of the deal, you can just analyze every guilty plea and the sentence suggested by the prosecution and assume it's a plea bargain.
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoIs this then a Freedom of Information request from a citizen in each state? Basically we seem to be certain that plea bargains are both denying large numbers of people trials and doing so with draconian threats that make both guilty and Innocent afraid It makes a good narrative - it would be nice to know it is true And it would be nicer to know it in real time (ie putting court records into electronic form)
- RyanMcGreal 14y agoI believe Aaron would agree with you on this: "[W]hen the system isn’t working, it doesn’t make sense to just yell at the people in it — any more than you’d try to fix a machine by yelling at the gears. True, sometimes you have the wrong gears and need to replace them, but more often you’re just using them in the wrong way. When there’s a problem, you shouldn’t get angry with the gears — you should fix the machine." https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5078343 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5078343
- danenania 14y agoPublic backlash against individual prosecutors who overreach is one of the best tools available for changing the system.
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoHow does firing one person change the system - do we have a manifesto of change, a set of coherent demands ? A vision of the future that we have all agreed upon? Yes the anger surrounding this will start some change - but do we want individual prosecuters to choose that change? - is not the more responsbile approach to start a locus for public debate and present our lawmakers with a consensus opinion - you know, lobbying.
- gnu8 14y agoRemoving / blaming Aaron Swartz without reforming the corrupt system of copyright laws that caused his offense in the first place was exactly what Stalinist Carmen Oritz wanted. It is a fact that Carmen Oritz is a snake and is not fit to serve in the United States government.