8 ms·
Linus is dead wrong on this. We have independent confirmation of everything that Ortiz said from the Boston Globe's interview with Aaron's defense attorney. T
by btilly 14y ago
Linus is dead wrong on this. We have independent confirmation of everything that Ortiz said from the Boston Globe's interview with Aaron's defense attorney.
The maximum statutory penalty for the original 4 indictments was 35 years. The prosecutor was planning to seek 6-7 years. There were two plea bargains offered, one was 4 months and no disputing the period, the other was 6 months but the defense attorney would be allowed to try to convince the judge to lower it. (The judge, of course, is not bound to follow the plea bargain.) And the average cost of defending one of these is $1.5 million, which is money Aaron did not have and could not raise.
- Osiris 14y agoAnd the average cost of defending one of these is $1.5 million, which is money Aaron did not have and could not raise. I thought that justice system was required to provide an attorney in the case that a defendant didn't have the means by which to procure their own representation? Is your comment only to suggest that a public defender wouldn't be capable of properly defending Aaron and thus he would need to pay for his own lawyer? If that's the case, then there is really something seriously wrong with our system if the inability to pay a lawyer basically condemns you to being guilty (or pleading) while the rich and defend themselves with teams of the best.
- btilly 14y agoI pulled the $1.5 million figure from http://blogs.law.harvard.edu/philg/2013/01/12/aaron-swartz/ http://blogs.law.harvard.edu/philg/2013/01/12/aaron-swartz/. The justice system is required to provide an attorney if you can't get your own. However if you look at http://www.innocenceproject.org/ http://www.innocenceproject.org/ you'll find that incompetent representation is one of the major causes of innocent people losing these cases. Furthermore in Aaron's case he's being charged under a fairly specialized part of the law, so his odds with a generic defense lawyer against a prosecutor who has specialized in computer crimes would be very poor. And yes, there is a lot seriously wrong with our system.
- pacala 14y agoGiven how the rest of the society works, I'd be not surprised that "incompetent" really means "poorly connected" and that the whole system is just a $1.5 million racket to get a "well connected" lawyer to grease your case.
- betterunix 14y agoNo, in this case, incompetent means "incompetent." Public defenders are often inexperienced and overworked, and are notorious for advising their clients to accept plea bargains rather than go to trial.
- atirip 14y agoThen you are really are fucked indeed. As an example here (Estonia) state pointed lawyers are choosen from reputable offices only, and they are forced to do that.
- glurgh 14y agoThe cases the Innocence Project deals with are invariably state cases, the quality of federal public defenders is significantly higher.
- dthunt 14y agoThe only good that has come out of this horrible episode is that more people are finally starting to understand the problems of CFAA and with the unbalanced situation in federal cases.
- gcp 14y ago"planning to seek...not bound to follow the plea bargain" So basically, if you don't want to confess (because you're innocent), all bets are off and you might get 35 years. How is he wrong?
- Xylakant 14y agoAny crime has a maximum sentence. If I rob a store, there's a maximum sentence. If I kill a man, there's a maximum sentence. If I cross on red, there's a maximum sentence. Depending on the circumstances I may or may not get a lower sentence. But the maximum sentence is always there and you might get it - the decision is up to the judge. So all the prosecutor can say "The maximum sentence is 35 years" and maybe add "and I'm seeking 6 years, but the decision is up to the judge."
- pacala 14y agoThere is one detail: she never added, in public, "I'm seeking X years". She always kept talking about the maximum penalty. The ball is in her court and Linus is right to call her backpedaling a lie.
- Xylakant 14y agoI would not expect a prosecutor to talk about the sentence she seeks before the actual court hearing. And we don't know at all what was discussed in the plea bargainings. So no - no lie. Not here. Coming from a different legal system (germany) I find the way prosecution and plea bargaining works in the states scary, but calling the prosecutor a liar when she works in the common framework is not helpful. It just undermines your cause by opening you up to an unrelated argument about semantics that you'll probably loose. Stick with the facts, argue against plea bargaining and pressure tactics in the legal system. Argue against the fact that to prevail in court, you need massive funding, that justice can effectively bought. Don't get caught up in false arguments about whether Ortiz technically lied or not.
- pacala 14y ago
- benatkin 14y agoThe main reason he's wrong is because she used lawyer speak. She said something that was misleading but technically true. She said that they didn't seek maximum penalties. What she must want people to think when they read it is that she didn't seek harsh penalties, which she did by increasing the number of counts. But since she didn't say this, it isn't technically false.
- jacquesm 14y agoExactly. Vivtek caught on to this in this thread: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5072066 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5072066
- runarb 14y agoShe can save the "technically true" for the other lawyers, the rest of us are not amused. The fact remains that she was seeking a severe sentence, but now want to magically make up another truth... If she think she was right in the first place, she sold stick to it. If not she should apologize. Now she is just looking like a fool.
- jacquesm 14y ago> She can save the "technically true" for the other lawyers She is saying this 'for the other lawyers', specifically her bosses in congress. She likely doesn't give a rats ass about what Joe general Public thinks about the case but is likely scared shitless that if this turns in to actual culpability that Aarons relatives will sue. Her political career is dead in the water, she might hold on to her job if the shitstorm doesn't get any worse. Google "carmen ortiz" to see how it is developing, you might as well google "Aaron Swartz", the results are much the same.
- rhizome 14y agoAnd when you have a situation like that where neither is "technically false," it's called "talking out of both sides of your mouth." However, besides the point, is "misleading the public and the defendant" a professional standard for federal prosecutors? In addition to repealing the CFAA, I'd like to see some hard character standards imposed for government prosecutors, some legal requirements and tests imposed on Bar Associations for the benefit of the public against and for whom they serve. We can call it "Carmen's Law."
- laurent123456 14y agoWas the $1.5 million only to lower the 6 months? Does that mean that if he had accepted the 4 months, he wouldn't have had anything to pay?
- ShawnBird 14y agoWell from my understanding the 4 months is not what he would get for sure, that is just what the prosecutor would tell the judge to do. He could still get anywhere between 4 months and 50 years (the maximum after the prosecutor added even more charges) but since he plead guilty as part of the deal he could no longer fight it in court.
- downandout 14y agoLinus isn't wrong. She made two directly conflicting statements in press releases, which is what he pointed out. The first, which she made at the outset of the case, was that he was facing 35 years if convicted at trial. They make statements like this in order to foster plea discussions, which resulted in the 4-6 month offer she mentioned in the second statement. While this would be considered extortion in any other context, this is entirely legal under current law and forms the basis for our entire "justice" system. In addition, no mention has been made of possible post-release restrictions that the US Attorney's office may have insisted on, but there is a very real possibility that the judge could have barred him from using a computer or the Internet during the mandatory 3-5 year supervised release period. Federal judges are free to implement any supervised release conditions they wish, and if violated the defendant can face significant additional prison time - up to the length of the supervised release (3-5 years). I didn't know Aaron, but I suspect that this fact may have weighed more heavily on his mind than the incarceration time itself. Four months on a federal case doesn't end after four months.
- gojomo 14y agoIn the weaselly shades of English used by lawyers and politicians, the two statements highlighted by Torvalds do not necessarily contradict one another. The older statement accurately describes the maximums the law allows, and was used when that was the emphasis. (At the time, the DoJ probably didn't know themselves what sort of sentence they'd ask for, so the only informative and unfalsifiable thing to put in a PR statement would be the statutory ranges: "faces up to".) It didn't necessarily imply the prosecutors were seeking or ever would seek that penalty. Even if the prosecutors kept mentioning the maximums, over and over, whenever the opportunity arose, unless they also specifically said they would ask for the maximum, the finely-crafted later statement from Ortiz isn't necessarily contradicted. Reminding of the maximums, to the accused and jury, could be an effective 'framing' rhetorical strategy to help make actual proposals of less (in negotiations or later motions) seem more reasonable or generous. None of this excuses the law itself or overall prosecutor conduct. But we still should read their statements fairly, aware they contain self-serving spin, but also recognizing the precise things they do and don't claim via their word choices.
- paulsutter 14y agoIf Linus said her statements were _false_, he'd probably be wrong. Both statements appear carefully crafted. If Linus said she made two _deliberate deceptions_, he'd be absolutely correct. Each statement exaggerates to suit the purposes of the context. But Linus said she lied. If you define lying as deliberate deception, he was right. If you think a lie must also be false, you can accuse him of sloppy English. But Linus is only "dead wrong" if you think deliberate deceptions can be perfectly ethical. Personally I wish Linus would slightly reword his post so that it doesn't confuse people who get hung up on semantics instead of his central point.
- jacquesm 14y ago> Personally I wish Linus would slightly reword his post so that it doesn't confuse people who get hung up on semantics instead of his central point. Yes, that would be for the best because as it is it's not just people who get hung up on semantics that are going to be bothered by this, it will allow opposition to his statements to reject them out of hand as untrue. And that is the bigger worry.
- delinka 14y ago"...hung up on semantics..." Which is precisely what the legal system in the US does. The judiciary gets into semantic analysis and declares a law unconstitutional. Sometimes, they get a little loose with the semantics and attempt to ascertain 'intent' and make a determination about the law. Semantics matter when your life is on the line. Semantics matter when you're trying to communicate clearly.
- jsight 14y ago> But Linus said she lied. Strictly speaking, he didn't. "Compare these two statements - one from July 2011, one from yesterday, and tell me Carmen Ortiz isn't lying.." Perhaps Linus' words were "carefully crafted" too. He didn't strictly say she was lying, but he sure did imply that she was deliberately deceiving. You said: "If Linus said she made two _deliberate deceptions_, he'd be absolutely correct." Hmmm... (FWIW, I think deliberate deception is the same thing as lying)
- javert 14y agoAs a regular intelligent American person (i.e., not a lawyer), you are correct, and Linus is wrong. It is just obvious that the first thing she put out was purely legal posturing. They do it all the time. It means nothing.
- watt 14y agoIt made Aaron kill himself. Must mean something.
- Xylakant 14y agoAaron killed himself for reasons we do not know. We are all saddened because of that loss and I understand that emotions are running high, but please keep in mind that he reportedly was suffering from a depression. The pressure from the investigation probably added to all of that, but the whole case may have just been a trigger or even an unrelated event. Depressive people sometimes kill themselves for a variety of reasons that mentally stable people would shrug off and ignore. Crying out loud "But Aaron killed himself, his death must mean something." just does not help any cause. He was a bright, talented man who got caught up in a legal case that highlights major problems with the way criminal cases get resolved. Focussing on that and highlighting the problems should be the goal, not revenge for his death.
- danielweber 14y agoAaron knew it wasn't 35 years. Aaron's own lawyers have said it was 6-7 years. Yes, I think 6-7 years is still too much, but you aren't helping anything by telling everyone something that isn't true, i.e., Aaron thought he would face 35 years in jail if he lost. 35 years is absolutely what Ortiz said -- to the public. Ortiz also wants to discourage other people.
- RobAley 14y agoLinus addresses this in a comment further down below his post : "oh, I'm sure that it's "true" that in private talks they were very much not seeking the maximum penalty. That's how the whole plea bargain thing works. But there's no question that Carmen Ortiz' office also made the whole thing very public, and everything that ever got written about that PR statement talked about the "up to 35 years" etc. So the whole "never said we intended to seek" thing is at very best misleading. It was always there very much as a threat. It was always there very much hanging over Aaron Swartz. And trying to say anything else is just lying."
- zokier 14y ago> It was always there very much as a threat. But wouldn't the maximum penalty be there always no matter what the prosecution would do? I mean, isn't the final decision made by the judges, who can give the penalty the deem fit (in the bounds of the law)?
- mverwijs 14y agoIsn't the max penalty dependant on what the charges were? Those charges were in the hands of the procecutors. If they really did not wish to come across as threatening, they could have charged him with less (as far as I understand it).
- anonymouz 14y agoWell, they need to charge him with something that they believe they can actually prove to the court. Furthermore, it is obviously in the interest of the prosecution to charge him with everything that they think they can prove, because if they pick just one and fail to prove it to the court they lose. Suppose for example they think they can prove charges A,B and C, and say, each of them comes with a maximum penalty of 1 year. Even if they seek a conviction for 6 months they will put forth all three charges, after all it might turn out that the court finds him innocent of A, and if they didn't bring B,C the prosecution is screwed.
- arthurrr 14y agoLinus is not dead wrong. This should not be reduced to simple binary. To argue whether or not Linus is technically right or wrong seems pointless to me. Tangentially, it really bothers me that there is even such a job as Government Prosecutor. Government should not have a self-interest. The system really is fubar, the only solution is probably 'rm -rf /'. At some point in Carmen Ortiz's life, she decided to devote her life to becoming a government prosecutor. That in and of itself speaks of her character. Whether or not she is lying in this particular instance is irrelevant, this is who she is, this is what she does, this is what she chose to devote her life to. (Of course she's lying! She a prosecutor for chrissakes! AND she works for the government! Did she open her mouth? That means she's lying!)
- anonymouz 14y ago> Tangentially, it really bothers me that there is even such a job as Government Prosecutor. Ignoring the personal attacks and hyperbole in your post: In a system without government prosecutors who do you think should prosecute for crimes? Should a murder victims family have to hire a private attorney to file a civil lawsuit? If they can't afford it, will the murderer go free? Please think your argument through to the end before taking cheap shots against the government in general.
- eliben 14y agoWhere emotions prevail, the chances of a real, objective discussion are very slim.
- sopooneo 14y agoOne thing that confuses me about this. Why couldn't Aaron raise money? A couple days ago I saw a repost of an old HN thread where people debated a notice Aaron had put on his website stating that he was accepting money for a legal defense. Did we just not help enough? Or was there some reason that making a more public plea, or giving details of the case would make the judge angry? I expect the answer these questions has already been covered in detail, so links are appreciated.
- btilly 14y agoExcellent question, and I'd like to know more about that angle. I've seen nothing about it publicly, other than comments that it would have annoyed the judge for Aaron to have publicized the details of what was going on. And, of course, if nobody knew what he was actually going through or what it would cost, nobody would have donated to him. After all we all thought he had money from Reddit. So the golden question is why the judge would be annoyed. Is it just a vague fear that the judge would not take kindly to an attempt to bias the jury by starting a media shitstorm? Was there a specific discussion that dissuaded him? Did his lawyer point out that his public statements could directly disadvantage him in the court? I have no idea, and wish I did know better. But the fact is that, for whatever reason, he didn't think he could speak publicly. And without speaking, he could not possibly have raised a significant sum of money.
- jacquesm 14y ago> Did we just not help enough? That was not 'not enough help', it was a net negative imho.
- edanm 14y agoThere seem to be two camps on HN, on this issue and on the case in general. One camp says: "The total penalty possible was 35 years. In general this scared Aaron Swartz. In specific Carmen Ortiz now saying that they weren't pursuing this penalty is a lie, since it was always a possibility." The other camp says: "Forget the total that was theoretically possible. Every knowledgable person to talk about this case has said that Aaron would almost certainly have gotten only a few months jail time. And this is also what Carment Ortiz meant when she said 'We're only seeking a few months in jail'. Never mind the theoretical maximum that her office published, that's what was actually on the table". It seems all the arguments here are about which point is "more true", but everyone seems to agree on the basic facts. The only fact we don't know, is how much the potential, theoretical threat of 35 years in jail affected Aaron. And about that, no amount of internet arguing will help get to the truth. Personally, I'm in the second camp - I don't see a reason to keep bringing up the 35 year figure, because I imagine that in a similar situation, I would be listening to the many people who know more than me telling me that 35 is not even close to a realistic possibility. And I certainly don't think it's lying for Carmen Ortiz to state the truth: her office did NOT seek the maximum penalty, and this was known to Aaron Swartz.
- podperson 14y agoNice synopsis although I suspect faction A will claim you're misrepresenting them. My take on it is that the prosecution did what prosecutors do. Jason Swartz seems to me to have been somewhat bipolar, and in manic phases he was brilliant, enthusiastic, idealistic, and a bit nuts -- which is what got him in trouble. In his depressive phase he killed himself. Blaming the prosecutors for his decisions is a tad harsh. The truth is complex and sad.
- jacquesm 14y ago> Nice synopsis although I suspect faction A will claim you're misrepresenting them. There are two kinds of people, those that try to divide the world into two groups and those that don't. > My take on it is that the prosecution did what prosecutors do. Likely true, but that does not make it right or morally defensible in this case. > Jason Swartz ... > seems to me to have been somewhat bipolar, and in manic phases he was brilliant, enthusiastic, idealistic, and a bit nuts -- which is what got him in trouble. No, what got him into trouble is his tendency to stand up against vested interests. If he'd been picking on the neighborhood streetpeople nobody would have noticed. But he wasn't that kind of person, he tried very hard to improve the world as he saw it, to fix broken parts of it using his skills. > In his depressive phase he killed himself. That's a shortcut for which you are missing a bunch of supporting evidence. > Blaming the prosecutors for his decisions is a tad harsh. Saying they don't carry any blame at all is equally harsh. The truth is - contrary to those that want to divide the world into black and white or two groups - something in the middle of that. There is plenty of blame to go around here. > The truth is complex and sad. That part of your comment we can agree on.