2 ms·
That's a terrible argument. No law can ever prevent crime, but we don't just give up on the idea of the rule of law. Banning certain classes of firearm won't
by jdietrich 14y ago
That's a terrible argument.
No law can ever prevent crime, but we don't just give up on the idea of the rule of law.
Banning certain classes of firearm won't make them disappear completely, but it gives law enforcement the opportunity to reduce their availability substantially.
Here's the story from the UK. We banned handguns altogether in 1997, after a school shooting that left seventeen dead. We had been slowly restricting gun ownership over the previous decade, but this time we really bloody meant it - there was a major programme of amnesties, ultimately leading to a minimum 5 year sentence for possession of a handgun. Initially it didn't have a huge impact on criminal use of firearms, partly because of the number of guns already in circulation, partly because the IRA were still fairly active and had extensive gun-running apparatus. Bit by bit, the police started to turn the tide.
The headline statistic is 58 firearm fatalities in 2010/11 (<0.1 per 100,000), but that doesn't really tell the story. The great success of British firearm legislation is revealed when serious organised criminals are arrested. More often than not, illegal handguns in the UK are in fact converted replicas and blankfirers - crude and unreliable homemade weapons. Illegal firearms are often seized with half-empty magazines, not because the weapon had recently been used but because the owner couldn't procure enough ammunition to fill it. That's an astonishing success that massively undermines the usefulness of firearms to criminals.
You can't fully control guns, but you can get damned close if you've got an electorate that wills it.
- pionar 14y agoThere's a big difference in controlling guns on an island and controlling guns in a country the size of the US. Also, handguns have nothing to do with this. Some areas (Washington, D.C.) already ban handguns. This is about assault rifles. The problem is, these are all overreactions to a horrible event. In 2010 or 2011, "long guns" (shotguns, rifles, etc.) only accounted for something like 300 homicides in the US. 300 out of about 300,000,000 people. Way too much effort for the benfit of cutting that by MAYBE 10-20 percent.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]