3 ms·
I agree with most of what you say, but with two quibbles. The punishments suggested by sentencing guidelines encapsulate what precedent says is "reasonable lim
by btilly 14y ago
I agree with most of what you say, but with two quibbles.
The punishments suggested by sentencing guidelines encapsulate what precedent says is "reasonable limits". Thus the sentencing guidelines in some sense are the definition of what our society thinks of as reasonable limits.
That said, you go on to say that that sentence is way beyond reasonable in almost anybody's estimation. If your circle contains lots of people who understand technology, that is obviously true of those you know. If your circle expands to include random lawyers, judges, politicians, and the uneducated public, there will be lots of people who think those limits are reasonable. That is how they came to be what they are.
- pdonis 14y agoWell, Orin Kerr is at least one lawyer who appears to think that the current sentencing limits are unreasonable, at least in some cases. :-) (More precisely, he thinks the current sentencing guidelines are too coarse; they don't differentiate well between different types of cases that deserve very different guidelines.) But you're right, different subgroups of the population can have very different ideas of what is reasonable.