4 ms·
@rprasad: 1. You're hellbanned. By the looks of it, starting from a comment that shouldn't even have been that inflammatory (email pg. really.). 2. As to your
by mindslight 14y ago
@rprasad:
1. You're hellbanned. By the looks of it, starting from a comment that shouldn't even have been that inflammatory (email pg. really.).
2. As to your comment and profile message:
I think a lot of what pushed the conversation towards "mob justice" instead of "whether his actions should even have been a crime" is that idealistic hackers have been making the argument to get rid of the CFAA and all other open-ended "unauthorized access" laws for quite some time, and are generally dismissed as unreasonable trolls. So rather than bringing up that same point again (which will still get dismissed out of hand by most people - I mean most people think that "identity theft" is actually a real thing!), "we" have to proceed on the assumption that those terrible laws are here to stay until digital natives become the majority, and can only hope to punish the prosecutorial bullying that made the threat of a three decade incarceration the price for a jury trial.
- jessaustin 14y agoa comment that shouldn't even have been that inflammatory A comment to the effect of "innocent people don't commit suicide"? That's pretty obnoxious in the best of times. In the current context the result is not so surprising. I don't advocate hellbanning for any specific person, but the practice itself is so amusing that I'm glad it exists. Perhaps HN's implementation is not subtle enough, if the hellban target notices so quickly.
- mindslight 14y agoHonestly I've always found 90% of his comments annoying lawyer status-quoism. And yeah I'm just noticing that the two comments before before the deadened ones are quite hostile. But, his comment in this thread: > Agreed. The solution to a bad law is usually to get rid of the law and start again from the ground-up. Amending a law leaves open the possibility of missing out on critical flaws. Part of profile when I first clicked: > A guilty man killed himself, and drove the Interwebz into a frenzy. The discussion should be about whether his actions should even have been a crime, and what society could do better to prevent future suicides. Instead, most of HN, including some of its most "respected" members have been demanding mob justice of the prosecutors handling the case. So my curiosity has been piqued. Perhaps it's too early and heels are still dug in, but what are the practical concerns for fixing these open ended extremely harsh laws? Clearly removing TOSs from the scope of "authorization" fixes something major, but it's certainly not the whole story and I personally don't think it would have prevented Aaron's predicament.
- btilly 14y agoPerhaps it's too early and heels are still dug in, but what are the practical concerns for fixing these open ended extremely harsh laws? Clearly removing TOSs from the scope of "authorization" fixes something major, but it's certainly not the whole story and I personally don't think it would have prevented Aaron's predicament. If part 4 of http://www.volokh.com/2013/01/16/the-criminal-charges-against-aaron-swartz-part-2-prosecutorial-discretion/ http://www.volokh.com/2013/01/16/the-criminal-charges-agains... has any truth to it, we really don't want legislation about the TOS authorization issue when we have good precedent for that, and the prospect of a Supreme Court case that solves the problem more cleanly than legislation would. The suggested legislative fixes that Orrin Kerr recommends seem reasonable to me. I'd personally like to see more informed commentary on that issue. ----- On rprasad, he made enough clearly wrong assertions about the law from personal authority that I had him on a list of people to assume by default they are wrong. However I still make a point of trying to listen to and engage people I disagree with. (Sometimes to my grief.) I'm not unhappy that he's gone, but if he chose, I think he could have made good contributions to HN. I strongly suspect that he'd have much more nasty things to say about me than what I just said about him.
- btilly 14y agoThere are accidental hellbans that get reversed. (I was subject to one once.) I doubt that his was accidental. See http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5065497 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5065497 and http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5065487 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5065487 for why, if I was running the site, I'd want him to at least have a cooling off period.