3 ms·
There are indeed places where drug dealing or use is punishable with death. These places still have pervasive drug use -- in fact, greater use than places with
by DanielBMarkham 18y ago
There are indeed places where drug dealing or use is punishable with death.
These places still have pervasive drug use -- in fact, greater use than places without such penalties.
How much more severe can you be? Seems like immediate death doesn't deter drug use. Does that idea still make sense to you? Or perhaps in all of those places it just hasn't been done correctly yet?
Prohibition (which took a constitutional amendment, btw) had zero effect on alcohol use -- it actually probably encouraged it and the organized crime that came with it. We're still cleaning that mess up.
Anything you put into your body changes the way your body and brain operate -- including tap water. So everything is a drug. It's just a matter of degree. I remember hearing about kids in the 60s who smoked pot laughing about their parents who were way more hooked on valium. In fact, misuse of legal drugs is much more pervasive than illegal drug use. We live in a society where you pop a pill for everything.
Nope -- shooting folks doesn't make much sense: unless you just don't like people and want to get rid of a few. I'm a libertarian and opposed to constraints on what government tells me I can do with my own body, but I wouldn't want crack being sold out of vending machines either. It's a tough subject, and part of the problem is that people need to acknowledge that it's tough. Only through socialization and education can we have an intelligent discussion about where the limits are -- just like we did with alcohol. Quick fixes aren't going to work.
- newt0311 18y ago"There are indeed places where drug dealing or use is punishable with death. These places still have pervasive drug use -- in fact, greater use than places without such penalties." Examples please. I have examples to the contrary: Singapore and China. What are yours?
- moe 18y agoSigh. Didn't they teach you in school that name-dropping makes no argument? About China, includes even a history lesson for you: http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articlerender.fcgi?artid=1402269 http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articlerender.fcgi?artid=14... And about Singapore: What are your sources? Last time I checked there was no data from Singapore because their government is not particularly interested in allowing independent studies to be made. There is data about their execution rate (death penalty), though. Amnesty international considers it to be amongst the highest worldwide. cf. http://www.hrw.org/legacy/englishwr2k8/docs/2008/01/31/singap17616.htm http://www.hrw.org/legacy/englishwr2k8/docs/2008/01/31/singa... cf. http://thereport.amnesty.org/eng/regions/asia-pacific/singapore http://thereport.amnesty.org/eng/regions/asia-pacific/singap...
- newt0311 18y ago"About China, includes even a history lesson for you: http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articlerender.fcgi?artid=14... http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articlerender.fcgi?artid=14... Read your source again. Maybe go beyond the title this time. Here is a nice excerpt: "The lifetime prevalence rates of illicit drug use among residents age 15 years or older in high-prevalence Chinese cities increased from 1.1% in 1993 to 1.6% in 1996, and the 1-year prevalence rate increased from 0.9% to 1.2% during this period [10,11]." Now go read that again and notice that in high-prevalence regions, use is ~1-2%. Wonder what it is in the low-prevalence regions... If the US had that kind of usage statistics, every anti-drug activist in the US and I would be very happy. Even happier if use went lower. "Last time I checked there was no data from Singapore because their government is not particularly interested in allowing independent studies to be made. There is data about their execution rate (death penalty), though. Amnesty international considers it to be amongst the highest worldwide." First point: Singapore gives the death penalty for quite a few crimes. By itself, it is not a useful statistic. Furthermore, AI is far from a "neutral observer" on these issues. Lastly, what exactly is the problem with a high execution rate? The lack of crime? Second point: from the CIA Factbook on Singapore: "drug abuse limited because of aggressive law enforcement efforts"
- colins_pride 18y agoFirst Point: My problem with the death penalty - as a libertarian - is that I can't imagine anything more wrong for my government to do to me than to unjustly take my life away. And if you think wrongful execution doesn't happen, you're kidding yourself. It's just a matter-of-fact combination of no system being perfect, and the law of large numbers. Second Point: That sounds like an opinion about cause and effect, rather than a fact. Which is okay, since the CIA always gets it right, like those WMDs they found right after we conquered Iraq!
- newt0311 18y ago"First Point: My problem with the death penalty - as a libertarian - is that I can't imagine anything more wrong for my government to do to me than to unjustly take my life away. And if you think wrongful execution doesn't happen, you're kidding yourself. It's just a matter-of-fact combination of no system being perfect, and the law of large numbers." "Unjustly" is a matter of opinion (specifically, a Humean ought) and cannot be argued away. Also, wrongful executions do not automatically mean that some policy is a bad idea. If one is interested in an aggregate reduction of problems, like in the case of the drug trade, its a matter of numbers and what works. If you disagree, then you need to explain to me why it is worse for the state to kill somebody than some random mob or a drug overdose. (btw, this especially applies to the death penalty when used against murderers). "Second Point: That sounds like an opinion about cause and effect, rather than a fact. Which is okay, since the CIA always gets it right, like those WMDs they found right after we conquered Iraq!" I used the CIA factbook as a proxy for information. If you wish, you are welcome to do more research on the subject. Keep in mind that Singapore is only 1 hour away from one of the largest drug production regions on the entire planet and yet continues to maintain proper law and order in its territory (this is largely incontestable as anybody who has ever been there will tell you).
- mcslee 18y agoJimmy Carter made an excellent quote about the penalties for drug use. "Penalties against possession of a drug should not be more damaging to an individual that the use of the drug itself." http://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Jimmy_Carter http://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Jimmy_Carter
- jibiki 18y agoThe counter argument is that this might be true in expectation. If we caught and executed 1 out of every 50 drug users, maybe the rest would stop using. If being on drugs is half as bad as being dead, then on net you've saved 23.5 lives for every 50 users. This is, of course, a very flimsy argument, which I would not stand by under any circumstances. But I think a better take on the subject would be "penalties against drug possession should be a net win for society", rather than what Carter said.