3 ms·
What do you mean the "law doesn't work" ? De Morgan's laws are working just fine!
by mindslight 14y ago
What do you mean the "law doesn't work" ? De Morgan's laws are working just fine!
- jessaustin 14y agoThe law [not "The Law"] referenced in the title, of course: CFAA. Like all USA laws, it can only be regularly enforced within the USA. Since many threats are based outside the USA, this crudely-designed law harms domestic innovation more than it reduces the overall security threat. This is covered in TFA.
- tptacek 14y agoThe CFAA harms domestic innovation... how?
- jessaustin 14y agoNumerous security researchers complained that the Weev/ATT case had unfortunate implications for security research. I'd argue it had even worse implications for the customers of companies whose calls US Attorneys will take. When they call the prosecutors rather than their IT staff, the customer suffers. Reasonable people can disagree about the proper form of disclosure, but surely the CFAA doesn't contribute constructively to that conversation.
- tptacek 14y agoI'm not happy with the idea that an IRC log taken out of context created a conspiracy conviction for Auernheimer, but that said, this is a bit of a false dichotomy. The options aren't simply "silently tell the company" and "publicly shame the company by publishing sensitive data". There's also "tell the company and present a timeline in which you're going to alert the press of the vulnerability without publishing personal information of any sort"; that option is the gold standard used by security researchers. Having said all that: testing for vulnerabilities in other people's deployed web applications is fraught and should be so. If you think consumers should be entitled to know about vulnerabilities, tell them to use only applications with a published disclosure policy, like Google and Facebook and 37signals have.
- jessaustin 14y agoIndeed that is excellent advice. I'm not sure what one's options are with respect to mobile phone service (this seems like the sort of thing "Ting" might do), but I'd avoid ATT.