4 ms·
Until CD sales really stagnate, all those revenue streams bring in more money than facing reality. Sounds like it's urgent for CD sales to really stagnate. Do
by swombat 18y ago
Until CD sales really stagnate, all those revenue streams bring in more money than facing reality.
Sounds like it's urgent for CD sales to really stagnate. Do a Good Thing today: convince a friend never to pay for recorded music again.
On a less snappy note, I sincerely hope that these two-faced bastards will go out of business, along with their "360 plans" and other nonsense. The world doesn't need Big Labels - with or without free recorded music. Their only survival tactic is basically to maintain a cartel-like control over distribution - this time by making big payola payouts to music sharing sites.
I don't see why anyone should feel even slightly inclined to support that kind of mindset.
- tptacek 18y agoYou really think I'm going to stop paying for Matador and Merge records because some d-bag at EMI told Arrington they were eventually going to "free" their shitty American Idol music?
- nickh 18y ago> Do a Good Thing today: convince a friend never to pay for recorded music again. If you do that, how do you plan on showing support for artists whose works you enjoy?
- ciscoriordan 18y agoConcerts. Merchandise. Tipjoy.
- seertaak 18y agoConcerts: so if I understand correctly, paying for concerts is morally justified as opposed to paying for recorded music -- which apparently is wrong -- because... you're confronted with a threatening-looking bouncer if you attempt to jump a fence? Honestly, I admire the chutzpah in the finger-wagging at record labels when the proffered philosophical justification essentially runs: "I can get away with it. Ergo it's ok." That's deep, man! Merchandise: SRV dolls, anyone? There's no question that money can be made through merchandising. But anyone who thinks this is going to work to the advantage of real acts consisting of real musicians who aren't photogenic and doll-able etc., as opposed to say your next class of X Factor, is living in la-la land. Or, for that matter, that merchandising can act as a substitute for the revenue streams that recorded music sales once provided. Tipjoy: seriously though; you're kidding, right? Tipjoy is your answer to a 50% fall in revenue for recorded music in less than a decade? Can I just suggest that all you armchair record execs put your money where your mouth is and create this awesome benevolent no-label label which only pushes, y'know, cool music, and makes lots of money doing it but doesn't do anything nasty like asking you to pay for it? Is everyone here so arrogant as to think the entire music industry consists solely of fat buffoons who are simply lacking in vision or technical know-how to find these el dorado musicbiz 2.0 revenues? Recorded music takes huge time and effort on the part of a wide range of individuals, all specialized on different aspects of the production. From songwriting through arranging, recording and mic placement and the myriad expertises that this requires, through mixing, mastering, etc.. You're telling me that all of this has no value? As a singer-songwriter in a band who loves music as much as programming let me just say: you, sir, are cheap.
- cabalamat 18y ago> Recorded music takes huge time and effort on the part of a wide range of individuals, all specialized on different aspects of the production. From songwriting through arranging, recording and mic placement and the myriad expertises that this requires, through mixing, mastering, etc.. You're telling me that all of this has no value? It has the value, in the market sense, of the amount of money someone is prepared to pay for it. If people aren't prepared to pay enough money for some musicians to make a living as musicians, they should get another job instead. The world doesn't owe musicians a living.
- shiranaihito 18y agoAs long as iTunes & the like don't offer full CD-quality, lossless encodes of songs, I'll keep buying CDs.
- cabalamat 18y ago> Do a Good Thing today: convince a friend never to pay for recorded music again. I do that already. My argument is that when the record companies are bribing governments into enacting bad laws. This harms others and is therefore immoral. When you buy a CD, you give moeny to the recrod companies, which helps them do this. Therefore buying CDs makes you complicit in immoral behaviour. So it's not only in your self-interest to fileshare instead of buying CDs, it's the moral thing to do.
- seertaak 18y agoSo basically, because the record companies lobby government, the public should engage in illegal behaviour. News flash: most of corporate America engages in lobbying -- many industries far more aggressively and successfully than music. So if you think the music industry should be shunned for engaging in this activity, why not be consistent and avoid taking aspirin, paracetamol (pharmaceuticals: avoid), avoid using toilet paper (yes, those evil consumer staples companies also vigorously lobby government!), throw away your bank cards, ditch your car, turn off the lights (energy companies, y'know)... you get the idea. Two wrongs don't make a right. I agree that the corporate interests play too large a role in the formation of public policy, and skew the process for the worse. But liberal democracies give us a forum to address that problem; that being recourse to our elected representatives. What you're advocating is a selective and self-serving lynching of certain industries. As I mention elsewhere, if you don't agree with the music industry's practices or prices, then you have the right not to purchase (and listen!) to the music. Nobody's forcing you to listen to music -- you do it out of your own free volition because you like it, it gives you pleasure, it, in other words, has value for you. If you feel so strongly about the evils of the music industry that you can't fathom subsidizing some Big Bad Label by buying a CD or download of your favourite artist, pick up a guitar and play that whenever you want to hear music. But don't come here with some hare-brained argument that by stealing music you're doing a "Good Thing". That's just self-serving bullshit.
- seertaak 18y agoThis is so incoherent I don't where to begin. > On a less snappy note, I sincerely hope that these two-faced bastards Less snappy? Am I missing the irony here? If I understand correctly, the poster thinks paying for recorded music is bad. 360 degree plans? Nonsense that deserves to go out of business. But if a label can't charge for music, and obtaining revenue from other sources is also nonsensical, then pray tell, swombat, where is the money to fund promotion, recording, etc supposed to come from? Should it grow off trees? > this time by making big payola payouts to music sharing sites Err, what? It's the music sharing sites that pay the content owners for distributing their content, not vice-versa. And if you'd done at least a iota of independent research, you'd know that the majors (e.g. Warner with youtube) are unhappy with the arrangement because their revenues to date have been minuscule. > The world doesn't need Big Labels - with or without free recorded music. The funny thing is you're partially right here: with free recorded music, the world doesn't need labels (not just "Big Labels"), seeing as their raison-d'etre is the creation and monetization of recorded music. Which doesn't make the statement any less silly, paranoid, and juvenile.