4 ms·
"Approaching 50%" sounds very misleading to me. The top percentage on that graphic is 30%, for 196.3/650. And before the increases, the top percentage was 27%,
by majormajor 14y ago
"Approaching 50%" sounds very misleading to me. The top percentage on that graphic is 30%, for 196.3/650. And before the increases, the top percentage was 27%, for 70.4/260.
From that perspective, those changes look like much ado about nothing to me. 30% is a long, long way from 50%.
Edit: it's also, other than for the retirees, not very graduated at all. 28% for the 230K earner, 30% for the 650K earners. Personally I would like to see a higher marginal rate bracket, as well as a raise on capital gains, which you mention in your edit, if we're trying to balance the budget. (Side question: are capital gains taxes done progressively at all? Would it make sense to have marginal rates and tax smaller capital gains much less than large ones? Why or why not?)
(Further edit on that note: my personal crazy idea of the moment is to have dramatically higher rates on, say, 500K+ marginal income, but not matchingly high rates on capital gains of that same amount; my idea being to try to encourage higher levels of compensation to be given in forms like equity that would require long-term business success, not just short term profits, to pay off. But I'm not tax lawyer or accountant or whatever, so I'm sure there are problems with that idea...)
- apaprocki 14y agoThe tax amounts don't include state and local taxes. NYC residents pay ~12.8% state/local tax on top of federal taxes.
- majormajor 14y agoIncluding state and local taxes opens up a huge additional can of worms since that varies so much; if you want to do it really thoroughly, you have to start looking into how common renting vs buying is and how property taxes vary. You could also throw sales taxes in. This would show how its impact is felt more at certain income levels.
- muzz 14y agoThey also don't include nearly the amount of deductions and exemptions that Americans actually use. For the most recent year of data, the average American paid 7.2% of income in Federal income tax. Even the Top 1% of income earners only paid 21% and the next 4% paid 14.6% [1] [1] http://www.taxpolicycenter.org/taxfacts/displayafact.cfm?Docid=456 http://www.taxpolicycenter.org/taxfacts/displayafact.cfm?Doc...
- rayiner 14y agoThere are people who pay 40%+, however they're a relatively small bunch. Basically singles making $250-$400k in ordinary income. Basically, no quintile, nor the top 5% or 1% sub-groups pay more than about 30% on average: http://www.ctj.org/pdf/taxday2011.pdf http://www.ctj.org/pdf/taxday2011.pdf
- hnwh 14y agoAnd that's just coming in.. add 5%-9% as soon as you spend that dollar